Missing or Incorrect BGM in Minagoroshi

[GIN5]

Minagoroshi's Steam release contains many of the replacement songs from the April music update to all arcs. The songs that were replaced can be found in the HigurashiKai-OldBGM Pack, but the new songs used in Mina are missing from this pack. Using the HigurashiKai-OldBGM as a music replacement for Mina will result in a few songs playing their 2013 MangaGamer counterparts.

I made a spreadsheet comparing all of the files in the BGM folders from Mina on Steam, the original Japanese release of the Kai arcs, and HigurashiKai-OldBGM. I noted which tracks are MangaGamer tracks in the OldBGM mod as well as what songs were changed compared to the Japanese release.

This was discussed in depth in the Minagoroshi channel on the discord and briefly in the higu_support channel. Here I will summarize what changes are required that I am currently aware of.

File b_dive in the Steam release of Mina is actually the song Sheep Counts. This song used to replace both Sheep Counts and PROS, but those songs are still in the vanilla folder. This file is a MangaGamer track in the OldBGM mod and would need to be changed if b_dive is ever called for in the script.

File g_tactics on Steam is R of Can, which is correct as there is no separate R of Can file in the folder. This file is a MangaGamer track in the OldBGM mod and would need to be changed.

File g_operation on Steam is Blanc Pur, which is correct as there is no separate file for it in the folder. This file is a MangaGamer track in the OldBGM mod and would need to be changed.

File t1_requiem on Steam is chants90-AHH, which is correct as there is no separate file for it in the folder. This file is a MangaGamer track in the OldBGM mod and would need to be changed.

The song Tsuki (Zan⇔San) Uta is entirely missing from the Steam release as well as from the OldBGM mod and would need to be added. Naegles believes the file t1_requiem replaced this song in the Steam Mina release, so some changes to the script would be necessary to add it in according to the original release shown here between minutes 20 and 21:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IielCo8Z3oo&list=PLursX8FTbz1nHDxevOAmyt1jpK8neSgAL&index=192.

There may be other script issues concerning BGM playing over other songs, but I cannot confirm any at this time. In short, the files b_dive, g_tactics, g_operation, and t1_requiem from the OldBGM pack must be replaced with the files in the Steam release of Minagoroshi. Additionally, the song Tsuki (Zan⇔San) Uta must be added and written into the script where it plays in the original game. I have linked this song as tsukisanbika.ogg here.

Also attached is the spreadsheet I mentioned. It may come in handy when Matsuribayashi comes out, too. I contacted Doddler about this on Twitter but have not received a response yet. Best of luck with this, and I will help in any way I can! Thanks!

Higu Kai vs Steam Mina Music.xlsx

tsukisanbika.zip

[GIN5]

Hi, I have now gone through the original Japanese release and the vanilla Steam release to resolve all BGM inconsistencies with the help of 730. Attached below is the BGM pack that is needed to replace many of the tracks from the Steam release, as well as a text file noting all of the BGM calls in the script of Mina. This text file shows which song should be playing at each call by referencing the next displayed text in the script, and it also shows what song is being played in the modded Steam version with notes on necessary fixes. This took me quite a bit of time to put together, so I hope it will help you all when the time comes to implement alternative BGM choices for this project. Thank you for all you do!

https://mega.nz/#!wToFyazI!y5rZ4zcAup-Bw5kjwwrCAzIicAyd7YsPOkP2eZS9D2s
mina-music.txt
minatips-music.txt

Please note that this BGM replacement file is meant to be used by itself on the vanilla Steam release. Using the classic BGM pack will cause incorrect songs to play as stated in my previous post, but this pack will fix everything if the fixes from the text file are followed. The classic sound effects pack seems to be fine for the most part. They are not perfectly accurate to the original, but I did not analyze them thoroughly to propose comprehensive fixes. MangaGamer seems to have no interest in fixing this problem, so I hope you all can incorporate the original music if you so desire.