-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 0
/
Copy pathpart3_flan_t5_generations.json
3086 lines (3086 loc) · 702 KB
/
part3_flan_t5_generations.json
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
596
597
598
599
600
601
602
603
604
605
606
607
608
609
610
611
612
613
614
615
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
636
637
638
639
640
641
642
643
644
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653
654
655
656
657
658
659
660
661
662
663
664
665
666
667
668
669
670
671
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
683
684
685
686
687
688
689
690
691
692
693
694
695
696
697
698
699
700
701
702
703
704
705
706
707
708
709
710
711
712
713
714
715
716
717
718
719
720
721
722
723
724
725
726
727
728
729
730
731
732
733
734
735
736
737
738
739
740
741
742
743
744
745
746
747
748
749
750
751
752
753
754
755
756
757
758
759
760
761
762
763
764
765
766
767
768
769
770
771
772
773
774
775
776
777
778
779
780
781
782
783
784
785
786
787
788
789
790
791
792
793
794
795
796
797
798
799
800
801
802
803
804
805
806
807
808
809
810
811
812
813
814
815
816
817
818
819
820
821
822
823
824
825
826
827
828
829
830
831
832
833
834
835
836
837
838
839
840
841
842
843
844
845
846
847
848
849
850
851
852
853
854
855
856
857
858
859
860
861
862
863
864
865
866
867
868
869
870
871
872
873
874
875
876
877
878
879
880
881
882
883
884
885
886
887
888
889
890
891
892
893
894
895
896
897
898
899
900
901
902
903
904
905
906
907
908
909
910
911
912
913
914
915
916
917
918
919
920
921
922
923
924
925
926
927
928
929
930
931
932
933
934
935
936
937
938
939
940
941
942
943
944
945
946
947
948
949
950
951
952
953
954
955
956
957
958
959
960
961
962
963
964
965
966
967
968
969
970
971
972
973
974
975
976
977
978
979
980
981
982
983
984
985
986
987
988
989
990
991
992
993
994
995
996
997
998
999
1000
{
"xsum": [
{
"Entry ID": 0,
"Input": "summarize: Media playback is not supported on this device The League One side were ahead after just three minutes as the forward scored with a low left-foot shot. Rovers went two clear with 20 minutes remaining when Williams netted from close range after a defensive error from a corner by Oliver Crowley. Bohan Dixon was unlucky to see his 20-yard free-kick tipped round the post by Doncaster keeper Thorsten Stuckmann.",
"Gold reference": "Andy Williams' double saw Doncaster ease to a comfortable victory over National League North side Stalybridge.",
"Greedy candidate": "Doncaster Rovers keeper Tom Williams scored a late equaliser as they beat Doncaster Rovers 2-1 to reach the top of League Two.",
"Beam candidate": "Doncaster Rovers extended their lead in the second half with a 2-0 win over League Two side Donfield.",
"Top-p candidate": "Doncaster manager Jack Williams pulled away from Rovers' stuttering tries to save a late goal from the field and after scoring from the 90-second intervals striker Anthony Williams made an almost no appearance as Doncaster took three minutes to an equaliser."
},
{
"Entry ID": 1,
"Input": "summarize: Liam Fox, the international trade secretary, said that he wanted a deal with the EU \"at least as free\" as the present arrangements. He said anything else would be bad for all the people of Europe, whatever some politicians on the continent might say about the need to show Britain that leaving the EU is not cost free. He also suggested he wanted Britain to take its seat as an independent member of the World Trade Organisation after Brexit. At present, Britain's membership is as part of the EU and some argue that Britain joining the WTO as an independent member will be a long and difficult process. I asked Dr Fox if he agreed with car manufacturers in Britain who said yesterday that tariffs between the UK and the EU could lead to job losses. \"Protectionism never actually helps anybody at all,\" he answered. \"And as we move into the post-Brexit arena, we want it to be as free and open as possible. \"And don't just look at it from the UK perspective; the European Union has a massive surplus in goods with the UK. \"Who does it harm more if we end up in a new tariff environment? \"Does it harm more, those who sell more to the UK, or the UK? \"It is in everybody's interest that as we move forward we have at least as free a trading environment as we have today. \"Anything else may not harm the politicians and the institutions, but it will harm the people of Europe and it is the people of Europe who should be at the forefront of our thoughts during that period.\" I also asked him about his comments that British business had grown too \"fat and lazy\" to take advantage of global trade opportunities. \"Well, first of all, I do understand why, the media loves splashes even if they are not always the words we actually say,\" he said. \"But let's stick to the important point here, which is we have a problem, that too few of our exporters - of our companies are now exporting. \"As a share of our GDP, if you compare our exports to say Germany there's a huge difference. \"If you look at total trade, imports and exports makes up about 57% of our total GDP - [it's] 86% in Germany. \"We have an increasing current account deficit that needs to be closed. \"And we need to ask ourselves how we can do that. What are the reasons why not all companies are performing?\"",
"Gold reference": "It is the strongest signal yet that Britain is plotting a \"hard exit\" from the European Union.",
"Greedy candidate": "Britain's trade minister has said he is \"very concerned\" about the prospect of a new tariff regime in the EU.",
"Beam candidate": "Britain's trade secretary has said he wants Britain to take its seat as an independent member of the World Trade Organisation after Brexit.",
"Top-p candidate": "British tariffs at home will \"significantly damage all trade in Europe\" if Britain leaves the EU after Brexit."
},
{
"Entry ID": 2,
"Input": "summarize: The group, who set off from the Canary Islands on 20 December, took 47 days to complete the 3,000-mile row to Antigua. Lee Spencer, Nigel Rogoff, Paddy Gallagher and Cayle Royce finished fifth out of the 26 competing crews. The Talisker Challenge - described as \"the world's toughest row\" - got off to a difficult start, with severe sea sickness hitting the team. Cayle Royce - 29, from Dartmouth. Suffered serious injuries serving in Afghanistan Paddy Gallagher - 30, from Cambridgeshire. He was injured in Afghanistan while serving with the Irish Guards Nigel Rogoff - 56, from Hereford, who lost his leg while taking part in an RAF parachuting display Lee Spencer - 46, from Yelverton in Devon. He lost a leg when he was struck by debris when he stopped to rescue a seriously injured motorist on the M3 The team, who named their boat Legless, also had to contend with huge waves and sleep deprivation, rowing for two hours on and two hours off, twenty four hours a day. They crossed the finish line in 46 days, 16 hours and 49 minutes. A tweet from Kensington Palace is among the hundreds of messages of congratulations for the crew on social media. The exhausted, but jubilant, skipper Cayle Royce, who lost both his legs in a bomb explosion in Afghanistan, said: \"We are so proud to be the first all-amputee team to row an ocean and extremely humbled by the support we have received.\" He said the message the team wanted to send out was that there was life beyond injury.",
"Gold reference": "Four ex-serviceman have become the first amputees to row across the Atlantic.",
"Greedy candidate": "The team of the world's longest rowing team has completed a row of eight - and a total of 26 - a day.",
"Beam candidate": "The team of the world's first all-amputee team to row an ocean has won the Talisker Challenge.",
"Top-p candidate": "The Olympic team has sailed back to Jamaica to run the world's biggest rowers."
},
{
"Entry ID": 3,
"Input": "summarize: Charity Twelves Company, based in Devon, said it had turned away 112 people seeking support in 2015. A BBC investigation revealed that in Devon and Cornwall police have seen a 55% rise in reports of sexual abuse in the past four years. Police urged victims to come forward and said they would be protected. Updates on this story and more from Devon and Cornwall Between January and November 2015, 1,326 reports of sexual abuse were made to the force, compared with 853 in 2011. The figures show more than 380 historic allegations - in which the offence was committed before 1 May 2004 - of rape involving a child have been reported to the force since 2011. Jon Brown, head of development and impact at the NSPCC, said: \"Unfortunately there is a significant gap between the number of people who need help and therapy as a result of the abuse, and the availability of services.\" He said the rise in reports was a result of historic cases of child sex abuse in the news, which had encouraged more people to come forward. 853 - 2011 888 - 2012 979 - 2013 1,221 - 2014 1,326 - 2015 Mr Brown said the prime minister had highlighted child sexual abuse as a priority along with dealing with terrorism which was \"encouraging\". However, Mr Brown said there needed to be a \"more joined up approach [between authorities] to provide the provision of help for victims\" including \"greater treatment and help\" and working with schools and families to prevent abuse. He said local authorities, health services and the police, as well as charities such as the NSPCC, had a duty to protect and care for victims. Tom Dingwall, chief executive of Twelves Company, which supports sexual and domestic abuse victims in the South West, said it provided services to almost 300 victims in 2015. \"Last year, demand outstripped our capacity to deliver services and we turned away 112 adults from receiving specialist support.\" Across Devon and Cornwall there are four Local Safeguarding Children's Boards - which aim to protect those at risk. Andy Bickley, chair for Plymouth, said investments, including training courses for those who come into contact with children, have been made. David Taylor, the chair for Devon and Torbay, said authorities were \"getting better at identifying abuse\". He said: \"It is an extremely complex and challenging area of work, and authorities in the region are learning from best practice in other parts of the country.\" Source: Devon and Cornwall Police Det Ch Insp Neil Ralph said the rise in reports of abuse was a \"challenge for the police service, locally and nationally\", but the force had made a \"huge investment\" by creating a dedicated unit and was working with other forces. \"It is a large increase and we've increased our digital and online footprint as these things can be really difficult to report over the phone so it enables them to report abuse [online] much easier. \"People have a high level of trust in the police and the Operation Yewtree impact [means] they have felt more compelled to report abuse to police. He said a high number of the reports, which were released in response to a freedom of information request by BBC News, related to historical crimes and the force \"would do everything it can to investigate them and bring the offenders to justice\". - Local authorities have the statutory responsibility for safeguarding children. - The safeguarding is overseen by Local Safeguarding Children\u00e2\u20ac\u2122s Boards. - These Boards are made up of a number of agencies such as local authorities, police, education & health providers. - Police will lead on criminal investigations with social care services leading on the safeguarding.",
"Gold reference": "Victims of child sex abuse are being turned away from support services that are being overwhelmed by a large rise in cases.",
"Greedy candidate": "A number of people have been reported to the force since 2011 after a spate of sexual abuse.",
"Beam candidate": "More than 380 reports of sexual abuse have been reported to the force since 2011.",
"Top-p candidate": "Acting from \"arrogant inhumanity\", a BBC investigation has revealed, says David Brown."
},
{
"Entry ID": 4,
"Input": "summarize: The 18-year-old was found in Caldy Walk, Islington, shortly after 18:00 BST on Wednesday and died a short time later in hospital. Two boys have been arrested on suspicion of murder and three others are being held on suspicion of robbery and perverting the course of justice. They are all being held in custody. A post-mortem examination gave the cause of Mr Appleton's death as a stab wound to the chest, shock and haemorrhage. Mr Appleton was in Nightingale Park with friends when he was attacked, police said.",
"Gold reference": "Five 16-year-old boys have been arrested in connection with the fatal stabbing of teenager Stefan Appleton in north London.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man has died after a stab wound to the chest and a stab wound to the chest.",
"Beam candidate": "A 16-year-old man has died after being stabbed to death in a park in Islington.",
"Top-p candidate": "A 26-year-old man has been charged with murder after one of his friends was killed in a robbery at a park in Greater Manchester."
},
{
"Entry ID": 5,
"Input": "summarize: Ian Stephens, of Cumbria Tourism, said there was a need to \"reassure\" travel firms and \"get the message out businesses are operating as usual\". He said the reopening of the A591 was a \"massive priority\" after a four-mile section between Keswick and Grasmere was closed by a landslide. Some areas were hit by flooding three times in as many weeks in December. Mr Stephens said the impact on visitor numbers was \"still unfolding\". \"We've seen a collapse in forward bookings, which is a very worrying trend,\" he said. \"Accommodation held up reasonably well over the Christmas period. \"As you'd expect there were fewer day trippers around and fewer people in the towns and villages, which has an economic impact, and there's an urgent need to get a positive campaign on the road.\" Storm Desmond saw a record amount of rainfall in the county over the weekend of 5 and 6 December, followed by more in the rest of the month. Carlisle, Keswick, Appleby and Glenridding were badly affected, with water deluging homes and shops. Cumbria Tourism launched a social media campaign before Christmas and is continuing to work with Visit Britain and Visit England. \"It's a big job to do,\" Mr Stephens said. \"We're talking to coach and travel operators so they don't change their itineraries. \"There's a big danger of them saying, 'We'll wait and go somewhere else in the UK until things are better in Cumbria,' and we then lose a huge number of bookings across the year.\" Keswick Tourism boss Linda Furniss, said last week that local businesses had \"suffered\".",
"Gold reference": "Flooding in Cumbria has led to a \"collapse\" in bookings in the county, a tourism chief has said.",
"Greedy candidate": "A tourism campaign has been launched to \"reopen\" the A591 in Cumbria, a tourism boss has said.",
"Beam candidate": "Cumbria Tourism has said it is \"a big job to do\" to reassure travel firms that they are operating as usual.",
"Top-p candidate": "More than 300,000 Christmas people have been warned to travel on Sunday to avoid returning to the rest of the county, according to a travel expert."
},
{
"Entry ID": 6,
"Input": "summarize: \"The EU needs a complete overhaul,\" says Germany's Sueddeutsche Zeitung. \"The remaining union has to learn from the Brexit vote and carry out the most fundamental examination of its policies\" since its creation in 1957, the paper argues. Der Tagesspiegel agrees, and tells the EU to \"reform or be destroyed\". But it also warns that there is a \"shocking gulf\" between remedies offered by the political elites - closer integration, especially in economic terms - and the expectations of ordinary Europeans. The answer, it concludes, is \"more openness, more transparency\", as well as a stronger focus on welfare. Under a picture of French and Dutch far right leaders Marine Le Pen and Geert Wilders, an article in Der Spiegel voices alarm at the rise of the \"great simplifiers\", saying they threaten democracy by appealing to the irrational. \"The populists are on the loose, and not just in Great Britain,\" it warns. \"They are dragging Western Europe towards its downfall.\" \"Populism is tearing Europe apart,\" a commentary in Spain's El Pais agrees, but warns that any changes to the EU should not try to appease their \"anti-establishment\" discourse. \"Populist parties have grown by exploiting the idea that the EU is to blame for an economic crisis caused by the whims of the markets,\" it argues Instead, it calls for policies that \"promote stability\" and \"reject blaming Europe for our ills when it is part of the solution\". An article entitled \"the dictatorship of democracy\" in El Mundo voices the fear that other countries could follow Britain's example. \"What is disturbing is that, after Brexit, fools can say with greater strength and certainty: 'Yes you can.'\" In Italy's La Repubblica, a commentary says the vote for Brexit reflects rising general discontent by the \"excluded\" that is driving the rise of the likes of Donald Trump in the US, as well as of Italy's own populist Five Star Movement. On the website of Polish news magazine Polityka, commentator Andrzej Celinski warns against \"giving in to the wave of nationalism\", and appeals to Poles to end what it calls their hesitant approach to the EU project. \"In the face of a real threat to the [European] Union, Poland's political leaders must stand together to fight for European unity,\" he urges. \"Do not follow the British. Build Europe\". An article in Polish newspaper Gazeta Wyborcza agrees, saying that the anger felt by many EU citizens must be channelled into a desire for a \"stronger Europe and better democracy, not nationalist phantoms\". BBC Monitoring reports and analyses news from TV, radio, web and print media around the world. You can follow BBC Monitoring on Twitter and Facebook.",
"Gold reference": "Digesting the UK's vote to leave the EU, papers across Europe call for radical change to counter what they see as a rising tide of populism and nationalism on the continent.",
"Greedy candidate": "The EU needs a \"complete overhaul\" of its policies, says the German newspaper.",
"Beam candidate": "The EU needs to \"reform or be destroyed\" after the vote for Brexit, the paper says.",
"Top-p candidate": "Britain \"great understands\" \"the Unwilling fling\", a paper says."
},
{
"Entry ID": 7,
"Input": "summarize: Andrew Armstrong, 33, of Mossdale Road, Manchester, pleaded guilty to one count of rape at an earlier hearing. The victim reported the rape to police in 2002 but the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) decided no action should be taken. A fresh investigation was launched in 2013 when the victim reported it again. Police said the woman had \"suffered for years\" and been ostracised by family. The victim and a police officer handling the case were also threatened with rape via a text message on 12 May this year when Armstrong entered his guilty plea, police said. The threat came from an unknown number and also contained a sexually-explicit photo. A 59-year-old man has been arrested and bailed in connection with the incident. Det Con Rachel Wood said: \"This is one of the most harrowing cases I have ever dealt with during my years as a police officer.\" She said the woman had \"suffered for years\" knowing she had been a victim of rape and was \"further tormented\" because she was \"ostracised from her family who refused to believe her\". \"Both the victim and myself were subjected to vile sexual threats so it is even more testament to the courage and bravery of this woman that she did not back down in the face of such disgusting threats and, as a result, Armstrong has been convicted of his appalling crime.\" the detective said. \"She has told me that the abuse she suffered at the hands of Armstrong ruined her life, to the point where she is paranoid the same thing will happen to her own children.\" Armstrong was told he would remain on the sex offenders register for life. Det Con Wood said she hoped the sentence at Manchester Crown Court would mean the victim could now \"finally start to rebuild her life\".",
"Gold reference": "A man who raped a 14-year-old girl in 2001 has been jailed for six years.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man has been jailed for raping a woman in a Manchester street.",
"Beam candidate": "A man has been jailed for raping a woman in Manchester.",
"Top-p candidate": "A man has been jailed for the murder of a woman in Manchester after he sexually abused a woman, police have said."
},
{
"Entry ID": 8,
"Input": "summarize: The \u00c2\u00a345m facility, to be built at Sutherland Drive in Kilmarnock, will house primary and secondary schools, a Gaelic school and a childcare centre. East Ayrshire Council said it would ask permission from the McIlvanney family to name the campus in his honour. The renowned writer was born and educated in Kilmarnock. Council leader Douglas Reid said he was delighted to be able to \"preserve\" the William McIlvanney name in Kilmarnock as the writer was \"passionate about the provision of good education for young people\". McIlvanney became an English teacher after graduating from Glasgow University but changed career in 1975 to write full time. He gained immediate recognition with the publication of his first novel - Remedy Is None - and through other works he earned the title of \"Godfather of Tartan Noir\". McIlvanney wrote the acclaimed Laidlaw trilogy and other Glasgow-based works such as Docherty and The Big Man. He was also an influential poet, journalist and broadcaster, and contributed to political and sporting life in Scotland through a series of columns and TV programmes. The novelist died at his Glasgow home on 5 December.",
"Gold reference": "A schools campus in East Ayrshire is set to be named after the celebrated Scottish novelist William McIlvanney, who died last month aged 79.",
"Greedy candidate": "A new school in Glasgow is to be built to house a school for young people.",
"Beam candidate": "A school in Kilmarnock is to be named in honour of writer William McIlvanney.",
"Top-p candidate": "A charity dedicated to the writer of the title of Guardian Comics has proposed to name the home of writer William McIlvanney."
},
{
"Entry ID": 9,
"Input": "summarize: \"We save people here every day,\" said the 46-year-old policeman - managing to sound both proud and chiding and the same time. Mr Hassan has now spent three years assigned to the lifeguard unit that patrols the beach. At high tide on a recent Friday afternoon, thousands of mostly young Somalis were playing in the surf - a scene of cheerful relaxation that would have been unimaginable just a few years ago in a city notorious for its decades of anarchy, famine and violence. \"This place is bangin'! Beautiful!\" said an exuberant 21-year-old named Hassan Mohammed. Like many others at the shore, he was from the diaspora and spoke English in a broad London accent. \"Never been here before. Very nice country. I'm born and raised in Europe. I thought it would be like seeing the end of the world. But it's improved very much,\" he said. Several restaurants have opened up at Lido beach, their shaded tables packed with Mogadishu's wealthier elites. \"Octopus, sea turtle, lobster, shrimp - it's all over this place! Somalia is the most rich in seafood,\" said Lule Dhan, an Ethiopian who is executive chef at the Benadir Beach Restaurant. \"This fabulous city... is not what the media portrays,\" he declared. \"Absolutely, I'm here to stay,\" said the restaurant's slightly less effusive co-owner, Abdi Resak Jamcale, who has returned to Somalia after two decades in California. \"I'm not making a profit but I'm breaking even. We need new laws to have more foreign investment here. For years people here never knew what's wrong and what's right - whoever has the gun [was in control]. But we're getting there, slowly,\" he said. Read Andrew's other reports from Somalia: 'Why I left al-Shabab' Getting round remittance bans In a country famous for its entrepreneurial culture, Lido beach's popularity has attracted a range of new business ventures - the most visible being the stalls renting out bright red life jackets to the many less confident swimmers. \"When the security improves, everything gets better. Before there was no work at the seaside, but now we're very proud to have this business,\" said Mariam Hassan Ali, 45, sitting beside an inflated inner tube that she also rents by the hour. But if Lido beach is a clear indication of the growing sense of optimism in Mogadishu, this is not a city in which one can, or should, drop one's guard for long. Later in the afternoon, the local district police chief arrived and demanded that we leave the beach immediately, hinting darkly that our film crew might be working on behalf of al-Shabab. To reinforce his point, he was brandishing a grenade with some enthusiasm. Further down the beach, Hassan Mohammed - the young visitor from London - also began sounding slightly less emphatic about the city's charms when I asked him if he had any concerns about security, and al-Shabab. \"No. No. You talk about that and they'll come to you! You don't talk about that - not even a little bit. I'm scared of that. This country's un-trustable, the people are un-trustable. They're just like you but then they've got this different mentality. \"There's only certain people that you can trust but that's cos they're your family. Do you know what they say here [about al-Shabab]? Arsenal or Chelsea! They don't even call them by their name. They say Arsenal or Chelsea. And if you hear that, run! Run! Don't even turn around. Just run!\" he said.",
"Gold reference": "Abdullah Mohammed Hassan climbed down from his perch, and strolled purposefully into the sea to rescue yet another bather who appeared to be struggling against big waves and a rocky, barbed-wire-infested shoreline at Lido beach, on the northern edge of the Somali capital, Mogadishu.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man who has been a lifeguard for more than a decade has been a resident of the beach in Somalia.",
"Beam candidate": "An Ethiopian policeman has been arrested on suspicion of kidnapping a woman in Somalia.",
"Top-p candidate": "Mohamed Hassan (pictured) believes the ongoing work in Calcutta for the islands is \"not what the media portrays\" - but that there is a migrant black population that \"creeps my brain\" every day, according to the chief of police and marines."
},
{
"Entry ID": 10,
"Input": "summarize: The move follows a claim by Crossmaglen Rangers player Aaron Cunningham that he was the victim of verbal abuse during the 2 December Ulster football final. The Ulster Council carried out an investigation and BBC Sport understands one Kilcoo player is to be banned for six months and another for four months. Kilcoo said they had not been notified, and the players could appeal. The two suspensions have yet to be officially confirmed by the Ulster Council. It is believed the case was the first time an allegation of racial abuse had been lodged with the provincial governing body. When an investigation was announced, Ulster GAA president Aog\u00e1n O Fearghail, said anyone found guilty of racism would be dealt with severely. Kilcoo released a statement saying the club condemned abuse and would co-operate with the Ulster Council's investigation. The Gaelic Athletic Association, which governs the sport in Ireland, is to discuss how to deal with racism at its annual congress in March.",
"Gold reference": "Two Kilcoo players are to be suspended by Ulster GAA chiefs following allegations of racial abuse.",
"Greedy candidate": "Ulster GAA officials have suspended Kilcooo's players for two months and two months.",
"Beam candidate": "Kilcooo have suspended two players from the Ulster GAA after a racial abuse case was lodged.",
"Top-p candidate": "An investigation into an allegation of racial abuse has been completed and the claims of four broken sentences had been filed."
},
{
"Entry ID": 11,
"Input": "summarize: Steve Freer and Val Wawrosz, who worked together in HM Prison Leeds, have founded a charity called Tempus Novo to find jobs for prisoners who have served their sentences. They work unpaid in offices opposite the looming Victorian hulk of their old employer. Val used to run the prison print shop with \"the same faces\" turning up time after time and would ask why they had come back into prison. They would explain how they could not get a job, often sending hundreds of applications and getting nowhere, so, as a result, they had turned back to crime. Paul is one of their success stories. After serving nearly nine years in prison, he struggled to find employment. His probation officer suggested he talk to the pair and for the last six months he has been employed by Winder Power, a manufacturer in West Yorkshire. \"They brought me here, got me an interview, got me through the door,\" he said. \"They gave me a chance.\" Steve acknowledged employers were wary of ex-offenders at the start and has found small and medium-sized businesses easier to engage. He takes the boss of each company into the prison and shows them the prisoners hard at work, as \"human beings\". Steve and Val then pre-interview candidates, ensuring they are prepared to do any job, even sweeping the floors as a start. Then they ask the company to give them an interview and treat them like any other applicant. Crucially, they offer support to both employer and employee for 12 months. \"We're there all the time for them,\" said Val, who told me that it can be difficult for ex-offenders, or \"graduates\" as they call them, to \"settle into ordinary employment\". \"The slightest thing can send them off track, so we're there at the end of the phone just to pick them back up so they can keep their jobs,\" he explained. \"The savings are staggering,\" Val said. \"The first 54 guys that we placed into work had between them 838 convictions, which shows you we don't cherry-pick.\" Prisoners with multiple convictions are often hardest to place, but so far the overwhelming majority have kept their jobs. Deteriorating conditions in prisons have encouraged some repeat offenders to try much harder to find work, according to Val and Steve. One man told them: \"I don't really want to go back to prison. It's changed a lot recently.\" Both men say there are not enough staff to deal with problems of violence and legal highs. However, Justice Secretary Liz Truss hopes to address that by announcing the recruitment of 2,100 extra prison officers in England and Wales, in addition to the 400 recently promised. She is planning measures to tackle drug smuggling into jails and to target reoffending rates. More than 100,000 crimes are committed annually by former prisoners. Ms Truss wants to see people improve their education and skills in prisons, so they are more likely to find work. Many ex-offenders find it very difficult to get a job, regardless of their qualifications. Steve told me that throughout his career prison \"was always quite a safe, not overly violent environment. But over the last two, three years, that's changed in many prisons\". Tempus Novo is now working in several prisons. Steve and Val believe their approach could help ex-offenders across the country. \"It would be an incredible win for society,\" said Steve. \"Less crime, less victims, and a huge saving to the taxpayer.\"",
"Gold reference": "Two retired prison officers are trying to help the men they used to guard to return to the world of employment.",
"Greedy candidate": "A former prisoner who served nearly nine years in prison has been named Tempus Novo.",
"Beam candidate": "Tempus Novo, a charity aimed at finding jobs for ex-offenders who have served their sentences, has been founded.",
"Top-p candidate": "Two ex-offenders are helping a national charity in Leeds find jobs in the 1960s, say members of their own and a professional who also seek help."
},
{
"Entry ID": 12,
"Input": "summarize: Pte Sean Benton, 20, from Hastings, was found with five bullet wounds to his chest in June 1995 while on guard at a perimeter fence at Deepcut. An original inquest into his death recorded a verdict of suicide. His family applied for a new hearing after using the Human Rights Act to access evidence held by police. His twin, Tony Benton, and sister, Tracy Lewis, wept and said: \"We are just happy and relieved. It's been too long.\" A spokesperson for the Ministry of Defence (MoD) said: \"We care deeply about our young recruits and our thoughts remain with the family and friends of Private Sean Benton.\" BBC Local Live: For the latest updates and more news The malevolent culture at Deepcut barracks Justice Collins said fresh evidence had \"come to light which casts some doubt upon the correctness\" of the original decision. He added that under article two of the Human Rights Act there was material that questioned the care Pte Benton received from the Army at the time. Mrs Lewis said: \"Our family had just 20 years with Sean. It has taken us another 21 to secure the thorough, independent inquiry we should have seen immediately after his death.\" \"For two decades, our family has been tormented by questions about what Sean went through at Deepcut,\" she added. \"If his death had been properly investigated in 1995, we would have been spared years of uncertainty and pain. \"It should be a source of huge shame to the Ministry of Defence and Surrey Police that our mother had to fight for so long - far longer than she should have had to - to force the authorities to answer basic questions.\" The family said the original inquest took less than two hours and heard from six people. A criminal investigation seven years later found no evidence of third party involvement. Pte Benton's medical records were not obtained and no evidence was gathered or presented about his experiences at the base. The family, who are represented by human rights group Liberty, believe he was subjected to severe bullying. In a statement, the MoD said: \"The Armed Forces will not tolerate abuse, bullying, or discrimination. All allegations are taken very seriously and will be thoroughly investigated, either by the civil or military police and, where appropriate, action will be taken.\" \"It would be inappropriate to comment further while legal proceedings are ongoing - we will assist the coroner as necessary,\" it added. Pte Benton was the first of four young soldiers to die at the barracks between 1995 and 2002. Pte Cheryl James, 18, from Llangollen, North Wales, shot herself in November 1995, according to a second inquest into her death which concluded in June. However, the coroner criticised a lack of training, structure and inappropriate sexual relationships in the camp. Pte James' father, Des, said he had applied to the MoD for a full public inquiry into what went on at the barracks. Pte Geoff Gray, 17, from Hackney, east London, was found dead with two gunshot wounds to his head on 17 September 2001. Pte James Collinson, 17, from Perth, was found dead with a single gunshot wound through his chin on 23 March 2002. A date for the fresh inquest into Pte Benton's death is yet to be set.",
"Gold reference": "A fresh inquest can take place into the death of a young soldier at an army barracks in Surrey 21 years ago, a high court judge has ruled.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man who was found dead in a barracks in Surrey has been given a new hearing.",
"Beam candidate": "The family of a soldier who was found dead at Deepcut barracks in Surrey have said they are \"just happy and relieved\".",
"Top-p candidate": "Two men who are believed to have been indicted by authorities as teenager in Lainsweep on Tuesday have been held pending an inquiry into the death of a 4-10-year-old boy."
},
{
"Entry ID": 13,
"Input": "summarize: The 35-year-old wing has signed for the Mitsubishi Dynaboars in Division Two of the Japanese League on a one-year deal. Williams scored twice in his final competitive game as Ospreys . \"It was a last-minute offer that I had to give great thought to in a short space of time,\" Williams told Twitter. \"Really looking forward to this exciting venture.\" Williams announced his in February after he turned down Ospreys' offer to extend his playing career with the Welsh region to a 10th season. The 2008 International Rugby Board player of the year in December, with 58 tries in 87 games for his country and two in four Tests for the British and Irish Lions. Williams signed off from the international stage in typical fashion, scoring a last-gasp try in the in Cardiff on 3 December. The double-Grand Slam winner was also Ospreys' record try-scorer, with 57 touchdowns in 141 matches, and scored late on in his last game for both club and country. But Williams' final appearance in Europe was for the Barbarians in their in Cardiff on 2 June. He was expected to continue his association with the Ospreys next season by with the Liberty Stadium club but the Welsh region have released him for this \"once in a lifetime\" opportunity. An Ospreys statement said: \"Taking into account his fantastic service to the Ospreys, we understand that this is a once in a lifetime opportunity for Shane and his family to experience a new culture and life in a new country and will not stand in his way. \"We wish them the best of luck in Japan and look forward to welcoming Shane back to Ospreylia upon completion of his playing commitments, when he will continue to represent the region with distinction off the field.\" Williams is second in international rugby's all-time try-scoring list behind Australian wing David Campese. And the legendary wing follows former Ospreys team-mates Jerry Collins and Filo Tiatia, who joined Yamaha Jubilo and Toyota Verblitz respectively in 2011, to Japan.",
"Gold reference": "Wales' record international try-scorer Shane Williams has completed a U-turn on his rugby retirement and will play for a Japanese side next season.",
"Greedy candidate": "Shane Williams has signed for the Ospreys in the Japanese League. He scored twice in his final competitive game as Ospreys. The Welsh region have released him for a one-year deal.",
"Beam candidate": "Shane Williams has signed a one-year deal with the Welsh region. He scored twice in his final competitive game as Ospreys. The former Welsh rugby union player has scored two times in 141 matches for Wales.",
"Top-p candidate": "Former Welsh Rugby League and Italian former England international Shane Williams has agreed to sign for the Mitsubishi Dynaboars."
},
{
"Entry ID": 14,
"Input": "summarize: Media playback is not supported on this device The 23-year-old earned GB's second medal of the Hong Kong championships following Elinor Barker's silver medal in the women's scratch on Wednesday. Latham emerged from the pack to take bronze as he chased down Adrian Teklinski of Poland, who won gold, and Lucass Liss of Germany, who got silver. In the men's team pursuit, GB were beaten to the bronze medal by Italy. Media playback is not supported on this device \"I am really happy to come away with a medal, finally,\" Latham told the BBC. \"I wasn't sure that Teklinski was going to hold on there. \"I was in a decent position most of the time. I followed the Irish rider Felix English and I had a good lead out.\" Elsewhere Britain's sole rider in the men's keirin, Joe Truman, was outclassed in his semi-final, having tried to take the race out with two laps to go. And in the women's team pursuit, GB finished fifth in the heats and failed to make the bronze-medal ride. Olympic gold medallist Chris Boardman \"Latham had a fantastic final charge. He timed his effort well there. \"We hardly saw him in the race, he monitored things but that's why. He was waiting for that final sprint. And what a ride that was for him. \"But with three laps to go, I would not have said that Teklinski would make it, but he found something from somewhere to just hang on there. \"More than 2km out, he effectively started to sprint. It will take him some time to recover from that.\" Six-time Olympic gold medallist Sir Chris Hoy \"I don't think that would be expected. It's the kind of event you can never be super-confident of winning or winning a medal in. \"But if you ride sensibly, which he did, he positioned himself very well and didn't waste any energy in the first part of the race. \"He marked the danger men and clearly had the legs for the sprint at the end. That's fantastic, a really great result for him and the team.\" Team pursuit Olympic gold medallist Elinor Barker came into the quartet of Emily Nelson, Manon Lloyd and Ellie Dickinson. The young squad were unable to compete for a medal but Barker remained positive about their progress. She told the BBC: \"It's the first Worlds for all of these girls and it's made it a lot more exciting. \"The level is so high already physically and technically. We have so much scope for improvement. It's such a good place to be in. \"Four years until Tokyo and we've just come fifth at the Worlds.\" Double Olympic gold medallist Joanna Rowsell Shand said on BBC TV: \"Coming into the competition, I don't think anyone expected them to medal. \"Until Elinor Barker joined the team today, we had four brand new riders. With an average age of 19, they've all got bright futures ahead of them.\" Earlier in the day, Olympic bronze medallist Katy Marchant was eliminated from the women's sprint in the first round. The 24-year-old, who claimed bronze behind Kristina Vogel of Germany and fellow Briton Becky James at Rio 2016, was the only female sprinter to travel to Hong Kong. The former heptathlete qualified in 16th place but was ousted by 17th-fastest Lin Junhong of China earlier on Thursday. Marchant is scheduled to compete in two more events - Saturday's 500m time-trial and Sunday's keirin. \"I'm really disappointed. I feel like I'm just missing a little bit of zing, which is something that coming off Rio is to be expected,\" she said. \"I didn't get the roar when I got the number on my back today - maybe the fact it's not an Olympic Games or something in the back of my mind telling me that I'm not feeling great. \"I know to get knocked out in the first round is not what we expect from a medallist, but the preparation coming into this competition is about the process leading on to Tokyo.\" Media playback is not supported on this device",
"Gold reference": "Great Britain's Chris Latham won a bronze medal in the men's scratch race at the Track World Championships.",
"Greedy candidate": "Britain team pursuit champions.",
"Beam candidate": "Britain's keirin champions, Chris Latham says he is happy to come away with a medal.",
"Top-p candidate": "Australian international."
},
{
"Entry ID": 15,
"Input": "summarize: There is a general belief here that if you typed Ghana or Ghanaian into a search engine, the words that would be suggested automatically as a follow-up should be politics and football. It is these two subjects that spark animated discussions and get the juices flowing. Even though in football, we have not won anything on the continental or world stage for a very long time, we still believe that the Black Stars, our national team, are special. One of the inner sources of the strength that help Ghanaians survive is the fact that our national team regularly beats the national team of the United States at football. Trying to get a visa from Ghana to the United States is one of the most humiliating experiences for Ghanaians. But we are able to endure it all by simply repeating over and over again under our breaths: \"World Cup 2006, we defeated you, World Cup 2010, we defeated you.\" Now, we discovered quite unexpectedly that defeating the US at football has even deeper implications, when news broke that our government had accepted two Yemeni ex-detainees, Khalid al-Dhuby and Mahmoud Omar Bin Atef, from Guantanamo Bay, where the US detains terror suspects, to live in Ghana. Elizabeth Ohene: \"They are excited to come to Ghana because of Asamoah Gyan, the captain of the Black Star - they know him and they like him very much\" The government has struggled to explain this decision. We have been told the two men pose no danger whatsoever to Ghana; they were innocent 20-year-olds when they were arrested and to drive home their innocence, our president compares them to his own 20-year-old son. We have been told that even though the two men are such thoroughly harmless and nice people, their every move will be monitored. Normally taciturn officials from the US embassy are suddenly all over the radio and television trying to assure us we should all be proud of our government for bringing to Ghana men the US Senate deems too dangerous to enter their country. When none of these interventions appeared to be calming the protests, the two thoroughly harmless and nice men were brought out to state their own case on national radio. Guantanamo Bay prison: The pair said they do not belong to any terrorist group, and have been wrongly arrested for 14 years without any charge. They have suffered but are not looking for revenge. They want to live in Ghana quietly and peacefully, and put their lives together. All that did not sound very convincing to any of us here; what everybody really wanted to know was why they had been brought to Ghana - did they just pick us on the map because Ghana happens to be the physical centre of the world? And suddenly it all comes tumbling out. They are excited to come to Ghana because of Asamoah Gyan, the captain of the Black Stars, they know him and they like him very much. A lot of the detainees like Ghanaians very much, and during the 2010 World Cup, most of the people there in Guantanamo Bay - no, not most of them, all of them - were with Ghana and when the Black Stars beat America, they were very happy. So now we know... beating America at football has consequences. I am afraid I don't know what happened to our secret supporters in Guantanamo in 2014. They obviously did not cheer loud enough that year, which must be why we lost to the US. And for that reason alone, I think our two long-term visitors should be sent back to reorganize our supporters club in Guantanamo. More from Elizabeth Ohene:",
"Gold reference": "In our series of letters from African journalists, Ghanaian writer Elizabeth Ohene looks at the uproar that greeted Ghana's decision to allow two Yemenis freed from the US jail in Guantanamo Bay to live in the West African state.",
"Greedy candidate": "The two men have been arrested for allegedly threatening to kill two Yemeni men in Guantanamo Bay.",
"Beam candidate": "Two Yemeni ex-detainees from Guantanamo Bay, where the US detains terror suspects, have been arrested.",
"Top-p candidate": "Our presidency shifts from a colonial approach to a military mission."
},
{
"Entry ID": 16,
"Input": "summarize: The Women into Sustainable Employment scheme aims to improve language and workplace skills and is being piloted in Dundee and Glasgow. It is run by Bridges Programmes, which supports refugees, asylum seekers and others who do not speak English as a first language. If successful, the project could be extended across Scotland. The Scottish government said research suggested women from black and ethnic minority groups face many barriers to work and are under-represented in Scotland's labour market. Minister for Youth and Women's Employment, Annabelle Ewing, said: \"This course is aimed at precisely that group of women and I am very pleased that the Scottish government is able to fund the programme in two of Scotland's cities to help improve their employability, including building up their confidence, sharpen their English language skills and experience the workplace itself. \"We hope that if successful, such an innovative approach to the provision of English for speakers of other languages can be rolled out across Scotland to allow many more to benefit in the future. \"We are committed both to strengthening the economy and reducing inequality in Scotland. Schemes such as Bridges will help us make progress on both fronts by helping a minority group take their rightful place in the workplace.\" Founder and director of the Bridges Programmes, Maggie Lennon, said \"We are delighted that the Scottish government is funding what we know to be a successful and practical way of getting black and minority ethnic women into work. \"The key to the approach is working closely with employers at every stage, to ensure that the training is relevant to their needs as well as the women, meaning work- placements are more successful which in turn can lead to more sustainable job outcomes. \"Once again we see Scottish employers taking a pro-active role in supporting people far from the workplace.\"",
"Gold reference": "A new project to help women from ethnic minority backgrounds into work has been given \u00a3110,000 of government funding.",
"Greedy candidate": "A programme to help black and minority ethnic women in Scotland improve their English and workplace skills has been launched.",
"Beam candidate": "Women from black and ethnic minority groups in Scotland are being trained to speak English as a first language, the Scottish government has said.",
"Top-p candidate": "A woman from under five ethnic minority groups has travelled to Scotland to develop an language curriculum in a training course to help better understand English."
},
{
"Entry ID": 17,
"Input": "summarize: Lines, 47, followed up a 3-0 win over the Scot with a 4-0 defeat of England's 1991 world champion John Parrott. The event in Scunthorpe offers the winner a place in the World Championship qualifying event. Now aged 48, Hendry retired after being knocked out of the 2012 World Championship. \"I didn't play well. It feels like somebody else's arm out there,\" he said after losing to Lines.",
"Gold reference": "Peter Lines defeated seven-time world champion Stephen Hendry in the semi-finals on his way to winning the World Seniors Championship.",
"Greedy candidate": "The former England and Scotland champions have won the World Championships in Scunthorpe.",
"Beam candidate": "Scunthorpe's John Hendry has retired from the World Championships after he was knocked out of the European Championship.",
"Top-p candidate": "Michael Hendry has been eliminated from the final of the World Championship qualifying round."
},
{
"Entry ID": 18,
"Input": "summarize: The members say they'll continue as a four-piece after Zayn Malik announced he was leaving the group last week to \"live like a normal 22-year-old\". His departure was followed by rumours on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook that One Direction was about to break up. But Liam Payne thanked fans for sticking with the band and for \"not thinking it's finished\". He tweeted: \"I can see a lot of people thanking us for staying but your the real Heros here thanks for not thinking it's finished.\" The band continued their On the Road Again tour and have been playing concerts in South Africa. They start the European leg of the tour by playing Cardiff's Millennium Stadium on 5 and 6 June. Zayn Malik quit the group last week after flying back to the UK, having been \"signed off with stress\". It was after reports that he'd cheated on his 21-year-old fiancee, Perrie Edwards. He told The Sun that he was \"upset\" for the group's fans and he said there was no bad blood between him and his former bandmates, who he said had been \"really supportive\". It's thought he's working on a solo album with producer Naughty Boy, who's worked on tracks for Emeli Sande, Cheryl Cole and Leona Lewis. Follow @BBCNewsbeat on Twitter, BBCNewsbeat on Instagram and Radio1Newsbeat on YouTube",
"Gold reference": "One Direction is not on the verge of splitting up, despite rumours started on social media.",
"Greedy candidate": "One Direction have announced they will leave the group after announcing they are leaving the group.",
"Beam candidate": "One Direction have announced they are leaving the group on a two-day tour in South Africa.",
"Top-p candidate": "American record label One Direction has revealed it will not be releasing songs for fans to add to their future."
},
{
"Entry ID": 19,
"Input": "summarize: Jodie Whittaker was announced as Doctor Who's 13th Time Lord - the first woman to be given the role. She will make her debut on the show when the Doctor regenerates in the Christmas special. The actor Martin Landau (left), star of 1960s TV series Mission: Impossible, died at the age of 89. He won an Oscar in 1995 for portraying the horror movie star Bela Lugosi in Ed Wood. The film-maker George A Romero, who created the Living Dead movie franchise, also died at the age of 77. Many credit him for inventing the zombie genre that we see in horror films today. Game of Thrones returned for its seventh season. Fans and critics were very happy - though they weren't too pleased with Ed Sheeran's cameo as an unnamed singing soldier. Buzzfeed published a report accusing singer R Kelly of trapping six women in a sex \"cult\". He denied the allegations and his lawyer said he would work \"diligently and forcibly to pursue his accusers and clear his name\". The salaries of 96 of the BBC's biggest stars were revealed for the first time in the corporation's annual report. Only a third of the stars earning more than \u00c2\u00a3150,000 a year were women - a statistic director general Tony Hall said highlighted a need to \"go further and faster\" on gender issues. Luis Fonsi's Despacito became the most-streamed song of all time within just six months of its release. The hit single has been played 4.6 billion times, overtaking Justin Bieber's Sorry. Linkin Park lead singer Chester Bennington died aged 41. The singer is said to have struggled with alcohol and drug abuse and had talked in the past about contemplating suicide. Follow us on Facebook, on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, or on Instagram at bbcnewsents. If you have a story suggestion email entertainment.news@bbc.co.uk.",
"Gold reference": "A look back at some of the top entertainment stories over the past seven days.",
"Greedy candidate": "The BBC has revealed the first woman to be given the role of Doctor Who's 13th Time Lord.",
"Beam candidate": "The BBC has revealed the first woman to be given the role of Doctor Who's 13th Time Lord.",
"Top-p candidate": "This year's TV soap has confirmed the medical award for best actress in the Netflix series Game of Thrones."
},
{
"Entry ID": 20,
"Input": "summarize: The Harlequins centre will lead Wales in June Tests against Tonga and Samoa while the Lions take on New Zealand. Roberts, 30, played for the Lions in 2009 and 2013 but was not selected this time by Warren Gatland. \"I was gutted for about a day or two and then you refocus and you go again and you use it as motivation,\" he said. \"You respond to it in one of two ways. You mope around and continue to mope around, or you dust yourself off and you go again. \"I've played some good rugby in the last few weeks for my club at Harlequins and I'm thoroughly looking forward to this tour. \"And I suppose being captain gives me extra incentive.\" Roberts has started 83 of his 91 Tests for Wales but only one since they lost heavily to Australia in November. \"I was disappointed with the autumn series, in particular against Australia,\" said Roberts. Roberts acknowledges he \"deserved\" to be dropped for his performance against the Wallabies. \"It was a bad day at the office and I paid the price for it,\" he said. \"Hopefully that's given me a kick up the backside to go again, and in the Six Nations it was disappointing not to get a shot at starting.\" With 12 Wales players in the Lions squad, Roberts will lead a squad including 13 uncapped players. It will be his first experience of captaining a side since he led Cardiff Schools Under-15s. Wales' first Test is part of an Auckland double-header on Friday, 16 June, with their game against Tonga preceding New Zealand's match against Samoa. A week later, Wales will be in Apia to take on Samoa. Roberts said: \"For me, the fundamental thing is having the time of your life and being accountable. \"I want the young lads to have the time of their lives playing for their country. \"It's a hugely privileged position we're in to play rugby for Wales. It's every boy's dream, really, and I want them to have the most fun possible. \"I truly believe you do your best work when you truly enjoy what you're doing.\" Tonga have not beaten Wales in seven attempts, but Samoa have won four of the teams' nine matches. Roberts said: \"The biggest challenge for this group - and we weren't good at it in the Six Nations - is performing away from home. \"We know the comforts of the Principality Stadium, we know the motivation that gives Welsh players. Unfortunately, in the Six Nations, we didn't perform in Scotland and France. That is going to be the challenge. \"To embrace the occasion and pressure is what we want from the players - to embrace the environment and not be afraid of it.\"",
"Gold reference": "Jamie Roberts intends to use his disappointment at being overlooked by the British and Irish Lions as motivation when he captains Wales.",
"Greedy candidate": "Wales captain Steve Roberts says he is \"gutted\" for the first Test against Australia in the Six Nations.",
"Beam candidate": "New Zealand's James Roberts says he is \"gutted\" for being captaining a side in the Six Nations.",
"Top-p candidate": "Australia captain Sam Roberts says he feels an \"extra incentive\" when he retires to play rugby for Wales."
},
{
"Entry ID": 21,
"Input": "summarize: Mr Cunha was accused of taking $5m in bribes from a company that won contracts with the state oil company, Petrobras. He has vigorously rejected all the allegations. Mr Cunha was for many years one of Brazil's most powerful politicians. He led the impeachment process against President Dilma Rousseff, who was dismissed in August. Mr Cunha, from the centre-right PMDB party, was expelled from the Brazilian Congress last month. He was arrested in the capital, Brasilia, and has been transferred to the southern city of Curitiba, where federal judge Sergio Moro is leading the corruption probe. Mr Moro said he had ordered the arrest because there was \"a real possibility of [Mr Cunha] fleeing the country as he has resources hidden abroad\". The fact that he has dual Brazilian and Italian citizenship also increased the risk of him trying to evade justice, added Mr Moro. Mr Cunha has been detained for an indeterminate period. Petrobras is at the centre of a massive kickbacks scandal which cost the company $2bn (\u00c2\u00a31.5bn) and has led to the arrest of dozens of lawmakers and top businessmen. At least three businessmen have said under interrogation that they paid bribes to Mr Cunha, which they deposited in his overseas accounts. Along with his seat he has lost the partial immunity from prosecution that comes with being an elected representative. In March 2015 Mr Cunha stated that he did not have \"any type of account anywhere that is not declared on my income tax\". But authorities in Switzerland later gave information to a corruption inquiry in Brazil stating that Mr Cunha and his wife, former journalist Claudia Cruz, were beneficiaries of secret accounts worth about $5m (\u00c2\u00a33.7m). During the proceedings against him in Congress, Mr Cunha threatened to reveal secrets and destroy the reputation of many of those who, in his opinion, had betrayed him. Former President Dilma Rousseff said Mr Cunha had decided to accept a request to open her impeachment case in December last year after she refused to back him up in a corruption probe in Congress. She was replaced by her vice-president, Michel Temer, who is also from the PMDB party. Ms Rousseff accused Mr Temer of leading a political coup against her left-wing government.",
"Gold reference": "The former speaker of the lower house of the Brazilian Congress, Eduardo Cunha, has been arrested in connection with a major corruption investigation.",
"Greedy candidate": "Brazilian President Jose M. Cunha has been detained for a year after he was accused of bribery in Brazil.",
"Beam candidate": "Brazil's former Prime Minister Josef Cunha has been detained after he was accused of taking bribes from a oil company.",
"Top-p candidate": "Brazil's former presidential spokesman Lester Cunha has returned to Brazil and is being held on $11.5bn ($3.6bn)."
},
{
"Entry ID": 22,
"Input": "summarize: As part of the BBC's So I Can Breathe series, a week of stories exploring some of the different ways the world is seeking to reduce air pollution, people have been sharing their tips on how to improve the air around them. For Phoebe, Joylen and Verity, from London, the answer is to stop cutting down trees. Students at 50 London schools breathe air that exceeds legal pollution limits. \"Toxic air audits\" have been announced by the mayor of London to combat the problem. According to the US Forest Service, trees typically reduce urban air pollution by only up to 1%, but even this can have significant health benefits. Areej and her mother also want to plant trees in urban areas of Damascus to improve air quality. Wood-burning stoves are a cause of high indoor air pollution levels which have been linked to four million premature deaths annually, according to the World Health Organization. Adboulie Sey thinks they should be banned from Gambia and solar energy promoted instead. Africa's new breed of solar energy entrepreneurs A tax on wood stoves is another solution, suggested by Karen Baines on Twitter. Improving how we travel is a common desire. Swapping driving for cycling can reduce the number of vehicles on the road emitting pollutants such as nitrogen dioxide. Clare Rogers tweeted this picture of her and her daughter in Enfield. Robert Singleton suggests a ban on diesel powered vehicles would go some way to reducing pollution. Girl guides helping to clean Ghana's air pollution problem Improved public transport is also proposed by Maria Innes in Buenos Aires, and echoed by Oscar Soria, in New York. Mike Hall thinks government schemes to support people buying hybrid or electric cars is one way to encourage more environmentally friendly transport. And Pablo Nieto Gonzalez in San Sebastian, Spain, wants emissions from ships to be cut. A week of coverage by BBC News examining possible solutions to the problems caused by air pollution.",
"Gold reference": "From Ghana to Argentina and London, air pollution is a problem that people want to do something about.",
"Greedy candidate": "A week of stories exploring the ways the world is trying to reduce air pollution has been a week of stories exploring the ways the world is trying to reduce air pollution.",
"Beam candidate": "The BBC's So I Can Breathe series is examining ways in which the world is trying to reduce air pollution.",
"Top-p candidate": "A time has shown that nearly 1,100-year-old children are currently under severance heat without using a roof off their legs."
},
{
"Entry ID": 23,
"Input": "summarize: Environment Minister Mark H Durkan said drilling could have a significant impact on the environment. Tamboran Resources wanted to drill a 750m deep hole at a quarry at Belcoo, using permitted development rights. It issued a statement saying it was \"deeply concerned\" by the minister's decision. By John CampbellBBC News NI Economics & Business Editor Tamboran had intended to drill using \"permitted development rights\", which meant the firm would not have needed to apply for planning permission. The minister could only veto this if he assessed that work was likely to have \"a significant environmental impact\". And that is exactly the position he has arrived at. Tamboran will now have to make a full planning application with an accompanying environmental statement, a process that will, conservatively, take months to complete. But it does not mean the borehole will not eventually be drilled. Alternatively, Tamboran may want to try to get a judicial review of the decision, arguing that the minister has not interpreted the planning regulations correctly. \"The company is currently reviewing its position and will release a further statement in due course,\" Tamboran said. Tamboran will now have to make a full planning application with an accompanying environmental statement. On Monday night, protesters held an ecumenical service at the gates of the quarry to celebrate the minister's decision. Donal O'Cofaigh from Belcoo Frack Free welcomed the decision and said it could delay the project considerably. \"It's a great relief, the minister has made the right decision,\" he told the BBC. \"This is the first time that we are going to have the opportunity to be consulted on that. This is something that is of grave concern to the local community.\" The MP for the area, Michelle Gildernew of Sinn F\u00c3\u00a9in, also welcomed the announcement. \"The decision to deny Tamboran to begin deep bore test drilling in Belcoo, Fermanagh, is the correct decision given the clear opposition to fracking in the area,\" she said. Tamboran staff moved into the quarry three weeks ago and carried out work to secure the site. Protesters objecting to both fracking and gas exploration had held a permanent vigil at the quarry. The aim of the borehole was to check if there was enough gas below ground to warrant seeking a licence to set up a fracking operation. Protesters said they feared a borehole could be the first step towards the setting up of an industry that they believe could damage the environment and the health of local residents. The borehole drilling process would not have involved fracking. Currently, Sinn F\u00c3\u00a9in, the SDLP and UUP say they oppose fracking, while the DUP has said exploration should take place, and any application for extraction should be judged at the time. Last week, politicians condemned a petrol bomb attack that targeted the family home of a Tamboran worker in Letterbreen.",
"Gold reference": "Anti-fracking protesters have been celebrating a decision to block permission for an exploratory borehole for shale gas in County Fermanagh.",
"Greedy candidate": "A company has said it is \"deeply concerned\" by the government's decision to deny drilling drilling in a quarry in Fermanagh.",
"Beam candidate": "The government has denounced the government's decision to deny drilling drilling in Fermanagh.",
"Top-p candidate": "A former manufacturer of gas has stated he could not have resorted to fracking for construction."
},
{
"Entry ID": 24,
"Input": "summarize: Shortly after the show was aired on Sunday, technology entrepreneur Peter Jones tweeted that his investment did not go through. The Glasgow-based firm had hoped to use the money to help fund the expansion of its Bluetooth tracker, Xupo. The coin-sized tracking sensor helps people find misplaced personal items. The tracker was launched by Strathclyde University graduates Raj Sark and Vincenz Klemt in 2014 after they raised nearly \u00a327,500 in a crowdfunding campaign with Kickstarter. The idea was born when one of the founders lost his travel bag, including a new laptop computer and passport, at Heathrow Airport. During the show, Peter Jones had offered the investment for 30% equity of the business. Xupo had forecasted \u00a31m in revenues in the next year. However, just after the show Peter Jones tweeted: \"My investment with My Lupo (sic) didn't go through as some issues arose during due diligence. I still wish Raj all the best in the future.\" A PR firm had already issued a press release on behalf of Xupo welcoming the investment. Mr Sark had said he was \"thrilled by the investment and Peter Jones' confidence in the product\". Mr Klemt had said the investment would help them strengthen their position in the UK and expand into Germany and France, followed by Italy and Spain.",
"Gold reference": "A tech start-up firm which thought it had secured a \u00a3100,000 investment on the BBC's Dragons' Den TV show has had the funding pulled.",
"Greedy candidate": "A company has offered \u00a320m to fund a \u00a320m investment in a new tracker that helps people find lost personal items.",
"Beam candidate": "The founders of Xupo have raised \u00a31m for a new tracker that helps people find lost personal items.",
"Top-p candidate": "A Cardiff startup is investing more than \u00a3100m in a travel-first tracker."
},
{
"Entry ID": 25,
"Input": "summarize: Council officials will meet on Tuesday to start the process of identifying where the Maes will be. A cabinet report said 140 acres were needed, along with good mobile phone signal and, if possible, fibre broadband. Town and community councils will be contacted, asking for suggestions to be sent to Ceredigion council by March. Once these have been received, they will be forwarded to the National Eisteddfod board, which is responsible for choosing the host site. The county hosted the first known eisteddfod, when Lord Rhys, prince of Deheubarth, gathered poets and musicians at his castle in Cardigan in AD 1176.",
"Gold reference": "Suggestions for the potential host site of the 2020 National Eisteddfod in Ceredigion are being sought.",
"Greedy candidate": "A county council has been asked to find a site for the first known eisteddfod in the county.",
"Beam candidate": "Ceredigion councillors have been asked to find a site for the first known eisteddfod.",
"Top-p candidate": "A micronation on the hillside of Dafta is to be taken down and expected to be recreated by the Sussex government."
},
{
"Entry ID": 26,
"Input": "summarize: The Tyco BMW rider, who was injured in a 130mph crash at Ireland's Corner last August, also sat out this year's North West 200 and Isle of Man TT. Gary Dunlop will make his debut with his father's famous number three plate. \"I've never let anyone since Joey ride as number three but who better to use it than Gary,\" said clerk of the course Noel Johnston. \"I think it'll be pretty special to see it on the grid after all these years.\" Joey Dunlop won a record 26 Isle of Man TTs and 24 Ulster GPs before he was killed in a crash while racing in Estonia in July 2000. Michael Dunlop and Ian Hutchinson both return to Dundrod gunning for the top step of the podium with Dean Harrison, Ivan Lintin, Lee Johnston, William Dunlop, Peter Hickman, Bruce Anstey, Dan Kneen, Conor Cummins and Christian Elkin among the 173 entries. Johnston said the absence of Martin, who will be in Utah filming a land speed record attempt, is \"a shame, but in no way will there be any less of a spectacle for the fans\". He added: \"I'm very pleased with the final entry list and think it says a lot about the popularity of the event that the total number of entries are growing year on year, as is the number of newcomers [54] coming to Dundrod.\" Martin has presented a number of TV programmes in recent years, most notably Channel 4's Speed with Guy Martin. The 2016 Ulster Grand Prix will run between August 8 and 13.",
"Gold reference": "Guy Martin will not be racing at next month's Ulster Grand Prix because of TV commitments in America.",
"Greedy candidate": "Joey Dunlop will be the first driver to win a record-breaking land speed record in the US.",
"Beam candidate": "Joey Dunlop has been named number three for the 2016 Ulster Grand Prix in Dundrod.",
"Top-p candidate": "Mark Martin's unbeaten TT record ahead of Neil Matthews's Marquis Garbright third round, after a fatal crash, has earned a fifth consecutive Irish Grand Prix race title."
},
{
"Entry ID": 27,
"Input": "summarize: We received that question from Drew who is planning a trip to New York in December. He asked: \"Should I get my cash now or should I wait? Will there be much change between now and then?\" Anthony Reuben, from BBC Reality Check, had this answer: \"The BBC does not give financial advice, but here are a few things to bear in mind... \"The exchange rate between the pound and the dollar reflects the views of investors about the relative strengths of the two economies. \"Since the Brexit vote in June the pound has fallen about 18% against the dollar on the judgment that growth is likely to be stronger in the US than the UK and that UK interest rates are falling while the next movement in US rates is expected to be upwards. \"But it's always possible that something could happen to change that view - there is a presidential election in the US in November, for example. The outcome of that could make a considerable difference to the exchange rate. \"You do not necessarily have to put all your eggs in one basket - there is also the option to hedge your bets and buy half of your dollars now and half of them just before you go, as long as you are not going to be hit by extra charges for carrying out two transactions. \"It is always worth shopping around when buying currency - avoid buying your currency at the last minute at the airport. There are plenty of comparison sites online that will help you get the most dollars possible for your pounds, even if it is fewer than you would have got a few months ago.\" We asked readers to send in questions about the recent fall of the pound and rise of the FTSE 100. Anthony chose Drew's question: \"I'm planning on going to New York in December, should I get my cash now or wait? Will there be much change between now and then?\" Take a look at some of the other questions you've wanted us to answer: Why does the NHS spend on homeopathy? Could the UK take over existing EU trade deals? Does fracking affect the water supply? If you are reading this page on the BBC News app, you will need to visit the mobile version of the BBC website to submit your question.",
"Gold reference": "With the value of the pound falling dramatically since Brexit, a \"flash crash\" last week when the currency lost 6% of its value against the dollar, and news on Tuesday that the pound had fallen again, when would be a good time to change those pounds to dollars?",
"Greedy candidate": "What is the BBC's response to Drew's question?",
"Beam candidate": "Could the UK take over existing EU trade deals?",
"Top-p candidate": "Could the UK take over existing EU trade deals?"
},
{
"Entry ID": 28,
"Input": "summarize: Tweeters have been using #NoToSocialMediaBill to campaign against the proposal. It proposes up to a seven-year sentence or $25,000 (\u00a316,000) fine for anyone found to be sending \"abusive messages\". Human Rights Watch condemns the move as an attempt to muzzle free speech. Millions of social media users in Nigeria, as well as those sending text messages, could be affected, it says in a statement. The bill does not define \"abusive statement or messages.\" There will be a public hearing on the bill before it can be passed. Activists see the bill as an attempt to target critics of lawmakers and politicians. The BBC's Nasidi Adamu Yahya in the capital, Abuja, says Nigerian MPs often come under the media spotlight because of the huge money they earn. However, Senator Bala Ibn Na'allah of the governing All Progressive Congress, who sponsored the bill, said the publication of false stories was becoming rampant in the country. \"You can't write false stories just because it is social media,\" he told the BBC Hausa service. The offences the proposed bill seeks to criminalise already exist under Nigerian laws including those on treason, defamation, and libel, our reporter says. Nigeria has a vibrant civil society, with many activists who use social media for their campaigns. It has the largest number of mobile phone users in Africa.",
"Gold reference": "Nigerians have been reacting angrily to a draft bill being discussed in the Senate which aims to punish anyone who \"propagates false information\" on electronic media.",
"Greedy candidate": "Nigeria's government has a bill to fine a Nigerian MP for sending \"abusive messages\" to a group of people who are sending text messages.",
"Beam candidate": "Nigeria's government has approved a bill aimed at curbing the publication of false stories.",
"Top-p candidate": "A Nigerian party is denying online comment that it is running an attack on democracy."
},
{
"Entry ID": 29,
"Input": "summarize: Joe Murphy's scrambled early goal was the ideal start for Down and they led 1-8 to 0-6 at half-time. With Caolan Mooney starring, the Mournemen extended their advantage to six midway through the second half. Meath reduced Down's lead but they home side held on after a nervous finish. Down went into the game propping up Division Two after disappointing opening defeats by Fermanagh and Clare. County secretary Sean Og McAteer felt compelled to release a length statement on Thursday night denying reports of unrest within Eamonn Burns' squad and Saturday's win will be a huge boost for the management. After hammering Derry at Navan two weeks ago, Meath were favourites heading into the Pairc Esler contest but the Mournemen produced a performance of grit and determination to chisel out the vital Division Two victory. Murphy's goal, as he flicked a mishit Darragh O'Hanlon free past Paddy O'Rourke, was the perfect start for the home side as they were never headed in the contest. With midfielder Peter Turley putting himself about and former under-age star Mooney producing his best game in the Down senior jersey, the home side pushed on from leading only 1-1 to 0-3 to move five ahead by the interval. O'Hanlon slotted three first-half frees while the impressive Conor Maginn, Barry O'Hagan (two), Ryan Johnston and Aidan Carr also got on the scoresheet for Down in the opening period. Fresh from his Sigerson Cup heroics with St Mary's, Kevin McKernan also excelled in the opening period for the Mournement as Meath laboured, with free-taker Donal Lenihan hitting three of their points. A McKernan point extended Down's lead to 1-11 to 0-8 by the 52nd minute after a great block at the other end by Carr had prevented Brian Menton for netting a Meath goal. After their struggles in recent times, it was not a surprise to see Down attempting to hold on to their lead in the closing stages and Meath, helped by the introduction of the speedy Eamonn Wallace, reduced the margin to three by the time the game entered injury time. Inevitably, there was a late scare for Down as Lenihan aimed for goal from his last-gasp 13-metre free and the ball skimmed off the crossbar over for a point before the final whistle was blown seconds later. ALLIANZ FOOTBALL LEAGUE FIXTURES/RESULTS SATURDAY Division One Mayo 1-19 0-14 Roscommon Division Two Down 1-13 0-14 Meath Division Three Laois 1-10 1-16 Tipperary Division Four Carlow 1-10 0-10 Limerick, Dr Cullen Park SUNDAY - 14:00 GMT unless stated Division One Donegal v Dublin, Ballybofey Kerry v Monaghan, Killarney Tyrone v Cavan, Healy Park, 14:30 Division Two Cork v Fermanagh, Pairc Ui Rinn, 13:00 Derry v Kildare, Celtic Park Galway v Clare, Salthill Division Three Antrim v Sligo, Corrigan Park Longford v Armagh, Pearse Park Offaly v Louth, Tullamore Division Four Wicklow v London, Aughrim, 13:00 Wexford v Waterford, Wexford Park, 13:00 Westmeath v Leitrim, Mullingar",
"Gold reference": "Down ended a run of 14 straight defeats in competitive games stretching back to April 2015 as they earned a 1-13 to 0-14 win over Meath in Division Two of the Football League.",
"Greedy candidate": "Down, smashed a goal to give them a 1-0 win over Meath in the Mournement.",
"Beam candidate": "Meath's first goal of the season, was the perfect start for Down in the Division Two quarter-finals.",
"Top-p candidate": "Gerry as county officials advised off by FA Sports Secretary Jeremy Cushing, appeared to take part in an intense game to beat Grimsby."
},
{
"Entry ID": 30,
"Input": "summarize: Real Madrid's Gareth Bale will hope to prove his fitness and win a third European major title in his home town on Saturday, 3 June and watching with interest will be another high profile Cardiff-born football figure. Terry Yorath was the first Welshman to play in a European Cup final, as it was then, when his Leeds side of 1975 lost 2-0 to Bayern Munich in Paris. For a man raised in the city's Grangetown area, the sight of club football's biggest global game being staged in Cardiff is still something Yorath finds hard to believe. \"I never thought a European Cup final would be here in Cardiff in my lifetime,\" said Yorath. \"We have a fantastic stadium and when the Italians and Spaniards come here they will enjoy the city and make it one big party. We should be proud of that.\" Bale will aim to fulfil the dream of playing in his home city as he hopes to shrug off an injury which has sidelined him for almost a month. \"I hope Gareth plays because it would be great for him,\" said Yorath. \"When you look back 12 months when the game was announced, he would have been thinking 'I hope we are there'. His family must be so proud. \"He is injured at the moment, but it would be fantastic if he scored and Real Madrid won.\" While Bale might be the latest Welshman to appear in a European final, Yorath was the first as he played his part during Leeds' controversial 2-0 defeat to a German side captained by Franz Beckenbauer in the French capital 42 years ago. A series of refereeing decisions went against the English champions that day and crowd trouble involving Leeds fans marred the Parc des Princes occasion in which fellow Welshman, goalkeeper Glan Letheran, was an unused Leeds substitute. \"You never dream about it, but afterwards you look back and think how many people have actually played in a European Cup final,\" said Yorath. \"I am one of the lucky few and nobody can ever take that away from you. \"But we got beaten and the crowd trouble at the end marred everything. \"The Leeds crowd weren't good that day. I got substituted about 15 minutes before the end and had to walk behind the goal where the Leeds fans were and it was then the Leeds crowd started throwing seats. \"As I was walking by with the seats coming over the top of me, I thought I hadn't played that bad had I? \"But the referee wasn't good either. We were cheated, but we were used to that at Leeds.\" Being the first Welshman to play in a European Cup final allied with captaining his country in 42 out of 59 internationals and managing his nation formed the bedrock for Yorath becoming the 21st footballer to be inducted into the Welsh Sports Hall of Fame dinner in Cardiff. Yorath was added to the roll of honour alongside Wales and Lions rugby star Graham Price, Olympics sprinter Christian Malcolm and ex-Glamorgan cricketer Peter Walker. \"It fees fantastic because when I came here down from Leeds, I didn't have a clue and believed I was just being invited here as a guest,\" said Yorath. \"I am not sure how this has happened. I thought I would just go down and see my sister who lives in Cardiff. \"To be honoured in such a way is something I never expected. \"I thought my days of being named in a Hall of Fame or recognised by anyway with Wales were over. I am 67 now although I don't feel it. \"This is probably one of the best things that has ever happened to me in football including playing in European Cups and Cup finals. \"Nothing will ever surpass this as far as sport goes. \"I now live in Leeds and nobody understands what being Welsh is. \"They don't understand how involved I get involved with whatever sport Wales play, why I have tears when the national anthem is played. \"I love everything about Wales. This is just such an honour.\"",
"Gold reference": "In three weeks, the eyes of the sporting world will be on Cardiff when Real Madrid and Juventus arrive in town for the Champions League final.",
"Greedy candidate": "Real Madrid manager Gareth Bale is set to play in Cardiff's Grangetown area.",
"Beam candidate": "Real Madrid's Gareth Bale is set to play in a European Cup final in Cardiff on Saturday.",
"Top-p candidate": "Jim Yorath's wheelchair ridden jersey of the 1998 European Cup final has been changed in Cardiff."
},
{
"Entry ID": 31,
"Input": "summarize: The pants, embroidered with the royal VR monogram, are being sold on behalf of Yesterday's World museum in Sussex. Auctioneer Richard Edmonds said: \"We've been able to date the pants by measuring the waistband and they are from the last 10 years of her life.\" The sale also includes nightdresses and stockings worn by Britain's longest-serving monarch and Princess Alice. The royal intimate apparel - described as in \"excellent condition\" - is expected to fetch several thousand pounds when it goes under the hammer next week. Mr Edmonds, from Chippenham Auction Rooms, said he used the \"tried-and-tested method\" of measuring the waistline to date the underwear to about 1891. \"Earlier in her life she was slimmer but her pants got bigger as she got older,\" he said. \"As there's such a good photographic record of Queen Victoria, it's possible to calculate her waist measurement over time, so we know roughly when she would have worn items of this size.\" According to Mr Edmonds, the 125-year-old underwear was bought by Yesterday's World museum from a descendant of one of Queen Victoria's ladies-in-waiting. \"Items of Queen Victoria's clothing were often given to members of the royal household, particularly after her death in 1901,\" he said. \"And they're stamped with the royal crest which proves they're from the royal wardrobe.\" Also included in the sale on 11 July are stockings and shoes worn by Queen Victoria's third child Princess Alice and replicas of the Crown Jewels. In 2014, a pair of Queen Victoria's silk bloomers sold at auction in Kent for \u00c2\u00a36,200.",
"Gold reference": "A pair of Queen Victoria's cotton pants with a 45in (114cm) waistband are to be sold at auction in Wiltshire.",
"Greedy candidate": "A pair of Queen Victoria's pants are to be sold at auction in Kent for \u00a320m.",
"Beam candidate": "A 125-year-old underwear worn by Queen Victoria has been sold at auction.",
"Top-p candidate": "A \u00a31 million sale of gold jeans, leather shoes and sweaters worn by Queen Victoria has been held under the hammer for an estimated six years."
},
{
"Entry ID": 32,
"Input": "summarize: Crews were called to a building site in Bloomery Circle, Llanwern, at 21:15 BST on Wednesday. The blaze burned for more than 10 hours before it was extinguished. It is understood the burning material included a large amount of scrapped railway sleepers. A Gwent Police spokesman said: \"Officers are investigating the circumstances surrounding the fire... which is believed to have been deliberately set.\"",
"Gold reference": "A fire involving about 100 tonnes of waste wood and rubbish in Newport was started deliberately, the police and fire service have said.",
"Greedy candidate": "A fire has burned at a railway station in Gwent.",
"Beam candidate": "A fire at a railway station in Gwent has been extinguished.",
"Top-p candidate": "A section of a railway is being burnt by firefighters in west Belfast."
},
{
"Entry ID": 33,
"Input": "summarize: A 24-hour walkout by members of the Rail, Maritime and Transport (RMT) union, in protest at the introduction of driver-only trains, ended at 11:00 BST on Wednesday. Southern warned passengers to expect \"difficult and frustrating\" journeys throughout the day. Two further strikes have been announced for 10 May and 12 May. Latest updates here The RMT confirmed it would attend talks with Southern \"over the guards jobs and safety dispute\" on Friday. Dyan Crowther, chief operating officer for Southern owner Govia Thameslink Railway, told BBC Sussex: \"We are very pleased to hear that and we look forward to meeting the RMT\". Southern said some routes were again suspended or reduced with 700 fewer services across Sussex and east Surrey. Ms Crowther said the timetable would not return to normal until Thursday as they needed to get rolling stock and staff into the right position. Paul Barker, a commuter from Rye, normally catches a Southern train to Ashford then a high-speed service to St Pancras. He said he worked from home on Tuesday but went to Robertsbridge on Wednesday to catch a Southeastern service to London. He said: \"It was standing room only from Frant, but you cannot take two days off work\". RMT general secretary Mick Cash said: \"This dispute is about safety. The company, with an eye on ever-fatter profits, is prepared to axe the guards on some of the most overcrowded and potentially-dangerous services.\" The company said there would be no job or pay cuts but the planned changes would make conductors more visible while drivers would operate doors. It accused the RMT of \"scaremongering\" and said \"driver-only operation is a safe, proven way of working\" which had been used \"on 40% of trains across the Southern network for 25 years\".",
"Gold reference": "Talks to prevent a further strike by Southern rail conductors are to be held on Friday.",
"Greedy candidate": "Southern rail unions have agreed to strike a strike on the rail and rail network in Sussex.",
"Beam candidate": "Southern rail unions are to hold talks with the RMT over a \"scaremongering\" dispute over driver-only trains.",
"Top-p candidate": "Southern rail has released a quick summary of the strike organisers are demonstrating that they are seeking to free people who leave the rail fence after being stranded."
},
{
"Entry ID": 34,
"Input": "summarize: The study says girls as young as 10 are forced to marry much older men in countries including Afghanistan, Yemen, India and Somalia. Save the Children says early marriage can trigger a cycle of disadvantage across every part of a girl's life. Conflict, poverty and humanitarian crises are seen as major factors that leave girls exposed to child marriage. \"Child marriage starts a cycle of disadvantage that denies girls the most basic rights to learn, develop and be children,\" said Save the Children International CEO Helle Thorning-Schmidt. \"Girls who marry too early often can't attend school, and are more likely to face domestic violence, abuse and rape. They fall pregnant and are exposed to STIs (sexually transmitted infections) including HIV.\" The girl who said no to child marriage Europe struggles with migrant child brides Gambia and Tanzania ban child marriages Big money for Niger's child brides The report, called Every Last Girl, ranks countries based on the hardest place to be a girl based on schooling, child marriage, teen pregnancy, maternal deaths and the number of women in parliament. Chad, Niger, Central African Republic, Mali and Somalia were ranked at the bottom of the index. The report says girls affected by conflict are more likely to become child brides. It says many refugee families marry off their daughters as a way to protect them against poverty or sexual exploitation. The charity used the example of a 13-year-old Syrian refugee in Lebanon it called Sahar - not her real name - who was married to a 20-year-old man. Now 14, she is two months pregnant. \"The wedding day, I was imagining it would be a great day but it wasn't. It was all misery. It was full of sadness,\" Save the Children quoted her as saying. \"I feel really blessed that I am having a baby. But I am a child raising a child.\" The report says girls also suffer during humanitarian crises such as the Ebola outbreak in Sierra Leone where the shutting down of schools led to an estimated 14,000 teen pregnancies. The UN children's agency, Unicef, estimates that the number of women married in childhood will grow from 700 million today to around 950 million by 2030. The Save the Children's report coincides with International Day of the Girl on Tuesday.",
"Gold reference": "One girl under the age of 15 is married every seven seconds, according to a new report by Save the Children.",
"Greedy candidate": "UN children's agency says girls in Africa are more likely to become child brides than women in the country they are in.",
"Beam candidate": "UN children's agency estimates that the number of women married in childhood will grow to around 950 million by 2030.",
"Top-p candidate": "Five countries and a mother of two are struggling to meet women who break into marriage, a UN charity says."
},
{
"Entry ID": 35,
"Input": "summarize: Speaking to BBC Radio 4's Today programme, he said: \"The only response can be: 'yes, Mr President'.\" Gen Petraeus resigned as CIA director in 2012 following an extramarital affair with his biographer. It later emerged he had shared classified material with her. He served as a senior officer under Presidents Bush and Obama. He was the commander of US and Nato forces in Afghanistan, before retiring from the military to take the top position in the Central Intelligence Agency. Asked if he thought Mr Trump had the correct temperament to be the US President, he said: \"It's up to Americans at this point in time not only to hope that that is the case, but if they can, endeavour to help him.\" He then indicated he would personally serve under Mr Trump if asked. \"If you're asked, you've got to serve - put aside any reservations based on campaign rhetoric... and figure out what's best for the country,\" he said. \"I've been in a position before where a president has turned to me in the Oval Office in a difficult moment, without any pleasantries, and said 'I'm asking you as your president and Commander in Chief to take command of the international security force in Afghanistan.' \"The only response can be: 'yes, Mr President,'\" he continued. A number of media outlets have linked the retired general with positions in the new administration. A report in The Guardian last week linked Gen Petraeus to the race for secretary of state, citing diplomatic sources. Mr Trump has been putting together his administration made up of friends, family, and former rivals - but several key positions, including secretary of state, remain open. General Petraeus was indirectly critical of some of Donald Trump's rhetoric during the presidential election campaign, describing the president elect's anti-Muslim comments as toxic. However, he said he had heard good things from those who have been speaking with Mr Trump since the election result. \"It's interesting that those who have been talking to him have said, you know, he's very personable, very hospitable, very gracious guy, full of questions and dialogue,\" he said. He also suggested that Mr Trump could forge closer ties with Russia, comparing his political position to that of President Nixon's overtures to China in the 1970s. \"Only Nixon could have gone to China. Anyone else would have been criticised from the right,\" he said. \"I think that the current president would have been criticised from the right had he tried some of the kinds of outreach that, in fact, President-elect Trump may pursue.\" But he warned that any such outreach should be attempted \"with your eyes wide open\".",
"Gold reference": "General David Petraeus, one of the United States' most prominent military officers, has indicated he would be willing to serve in President-elect Donald Trump's administration if asked.",
"Greedy candidate": "US President Donald Trump has said he is \"so\" to serve under President Donald Trump if asked.",
"Beam candidate": "US Secretary of State John McCain has said he will serve under President Donald Trump if asked.",
"Top-p candidate": "US President Donald Trump has said he has advised Americans to try to support Trump during the election, because of criticism from media coverage."
},
{
"Entry ID": 36,
"Input": "summarize: Leigh-Anne Mahachi, 22, was discovered at a property in Spotswood Close, in Gleadless Valley, on Tuesday, but died later in hospital. A post-mortem examination found she died from multiple stab wounds. South Yorkshire Police described her death as a \"targeted attack\". A 37-year-old man from Colchester, Essex, arrested on suspicion of murder on Tuesday, remains in police custody.",
"Gold reference": "A woman stabbed to death at her home in Sheffield has been identified.",
"Greedy candidate": "A woman has died after a stab wound to her neck and a knife in a house in South Yorkshire.",
"Beam candidate": "A man has been arrested on suspicion of murder after a woman was found stabbed to death in South Yorkshire.",
"Top-p candidate": "A woman who was found murdered by a man in the South Yorkshire area has been questioned over her disappearance."
},
{
"Entry ID": 37,
"Input": "summarize: It was a scrappy effort, which saved the game from going to what had seemed an inevitable penalty shootout. Stevie Mallan though had earlier missed the game's best chance for the home side when he failed to score from the penalty spot. St Mirren now lead Group G by three points. It might have been picture postcard weather for the first half in Paisley, but there wasn't much to write home about. St Mirren were too predictable with long balls floated forward for John Sutton and David Clarkson up front, although Mallan's dead ball delivery was, as always, a threat. Ayr started well enough and Paul Cairney had a real early chance, but after that Saints looked comfortable at the back. St Mirren's best chance of the half fell for Calum Gallacher who got on to the end of a lovely ball from Clarkson. It was screaming for the first-time volley, but he chose the wrong option in taking a touch and the opportunity melted in the evening sun. Things, we hoped, could only get better in the second half. They did. A bit. Lewis Morgan was highly impressive down the left side for the home team, embracing the concept of dazzling wing play and hitting the by-line before delivering the cross. But no-one could cash in. He won his team a penalty with another dazzling run. The usually deadly Mallan took the spot kick, but United goalkeeper Greg Fleming produced a wonderful save to his right hand side to urge the game toward further penalties after 90 minutes. But then central defender Baird chipped in with his last-minute effort, bundling the ball over the line after a scramble in the box. Enough to set Saints proudly at the top of their section. St Mirren manager Alex Rae: \"We struggled to get any intensity in the first half. I'm conscious of the fact it was really warm out there tonight. \"A lot of the boys are just not up to speed. This competition has come really early. \"Lewis Morgan tonight was sensational, driving at people. The boy is making a really big impact. \"I spoke to Stewart (Gilmour, the chairman) before the game, there may be funds for a loan deal, but we'll try and squeeze a few quid out of him.\" Ayr United manager Ian McCall: \"I thought it was a really poor game of football. We're a mile short in terms of bodies and fitness but a draw would have been fair. To lose one so late is hard to take. \"But, we've got two games left and if we win them two you never know. \"We need strikers. We need a wide player. We need a centre back. We're four or five short of where we want to be. The substitutes Alex (Rae) was able to make was the difference.\" Match ends, St. Mirren 1, Ayr United 0. Second Half ends, St. Mirren 1, Ayr United 0. Goal! St. Mirren 1, Ayr United 0. Jack Baird (St. Mirren) right footed shot from the centre of the box to the bottom left corner following a corner. Corner, St. Mirren. Conceded by Patrick Boyle. Attempt blocked. Lewis Morgan (St. Mirren) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked. Attempt missed. David Clarkson (St. Mirren) left footed shot from the left side of the six yard box is close, but misses to the left. Corner, Ayr United. Conceded by Jason Naismith. Foul by Lewis Morgan (St. Mirren). Nicky Devlin (Ayr United) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Attempt missed. David Clarkson (St. Mirren) right footed shot from the centre of the box is high and wide to the left. Corner, St. Mirren. Conceded by Ross Docherty. Lewis Morgan (St. Mirren) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Foul by Nicky Devlin (Ayr United). Foul by Kyle Hutton (St. Mirren). Ross Docherty (Ayr United) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Foul by Lawrence Shankland (St. Mirren). Paul Cairney (Ayr United) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Attempt missed. Patrick Boyle (Ayr United) left footed shot from the left side of the box is close, but misses to the left. David Clarkson (St. Mirren) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul. Foul by David Clarkson (St. Mirren). Patrick Boyle (Ayr United) wins a free kick on the right wing. Nicky Devlin (Ayr United) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Foul by David Clarkson (St. Mirren). Corner, St. Mirren. Conceded by Greg Fleming. Penalty saved! Stephen Mallan (St. Mirren) fails to capitalise on this great opportunity, right footed shot saved in the bottom left corner. Penalty St. Mirren. Lewis Morgan draws a foul in the penalty area. Penalty conceded by Nicky Devlin (Ayr United) after a foul in the penalty area. Foul by Kyle Hutton (St. Mirren). Paul Cairney (Ayr United) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Attempt missed. Lawrence Shankland (St. Mirren) header from the centre of the box is too high following a corner. Corner, St. Mirren. Conceded by Paul Cairney. Substitution, Ayr United. Craig McGuffie replaces Michael Donald. Ross Docherty (Ayr United) is shown the yellow card. Stephen Mallan (St. Mirren) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Foul by Paul Cairney (Ayr United). Foul by Tom Walsh (St. Mirren). Michael Donald (Ayr United) wins a free kick on the right wing. Attempt saved. Stephen Mallan (St. Mirren) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the top centre of the goal. Substitution, St. Mirren. Tom Walsh replaces Calum Gallagher. Substitution, St. Mirren. Lawrence Shankland replaces John Sutton.",
"Gold reference": "Jack Baird scored a dramatic last-minute goal to preserve St Mirren's 100% record in this season's Betfred League Cup.",
"Greedy candidate": "St Mirren's first goal of the season was a dazzling one-goal win for the club.",
"Beam candidate": "St Mirren's first goal of the season was a dazzling volley by Lewis Morgan.",
"Top-p candidate": "England striker Lewis Morgan made a good start to the League Two table, reaching at the top of Group G."
},
{
"Entry ID": 38,
"Input": "summarize: Turnout: 394,990 valid votes (42.5%) Second preference votes are only used if no candidate receives more than 50% of the vote. The top two candidates then receive the second preference votes from their eliminated opponents. Also see: South Wales Police is the largest Welsh police force area by population - some 1.2m people live within it. It covers everything from Swansea to Cardiff and includes Bridgend, Rhondda Cynon Taf, the Vale of Glamorgan and Merthyr Tydfil. There are 2,937 officers that work in South Wales Police, with 1,746 support staff and 406 community support officers. The force's chief constable is Peter Vaughan, with Matt Jukes serving as deputy chief constable. The total force budget for 2016/17 is \u00a3258.9m. The precept is \u00a3207.85 for band D properties. That compares to \u00a3200.07 in Dyfed-Powys, \u00a3220.06 in Gwent and \u00a3240.12 in North Wales Police force areas. The force has current projected savings of \u00a35.4m in 2016/17 with a projected cut in staff numbers of 21. There were 89,864 crimes recorded in south Wales between September 2014 and September 2015, a rise of 4% on the year before. Violence against the person rose by 23%, although all police forces apart from one recorded a rise in the category of offences. Sexual offences rose by 11%, while burglary offences fell by 5%. Theft offences fell by 6%, while criminal damage and arson fell by 1%. The last annual inspection of police forces by Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary (HMIC) said South Wales Police was good at preventing crime and antisocial behaviour and had a good understanding of local neighbourhoods. HMIC said the force is good at identifying and tackling serious and organised crime groups.",
"Gold reference": "Labour's Alun Michael has been re-elected as South Wales police and crime commissioner.",
"Greedy candidate": "South Wales Police has been voted out of a vote of a second preference vote by the top two candidates.",
"Beam candidate": "South Wales Police is the largest police force in Wales, with a total budget of \u00a3258.9m.",
"Top-p candidate": "Shrewsbury's full - 151 and 77 in Wales and Wales had made a list of the top two candidates."
},
{
"Entry ID": 39,
"Input": "summarize: Compounding the trauma of personal loss they face a lonely battle to find and identify husbands, wives and children before trying to bring them home for burial. Mohammed Nowrouz Noori is an Afghan man in his late 30s but he is already a broken man. In January this year he set off with his wife Nilufar, son Mohammad and baby daughter Nastaran from the Turkish coast heading for Greece. \"When we were boarding my son said 'Dad I have prayed that we reach to other side safely',\" Nowrouz says as he recounts the tragedy at the family home back in Kabul. \"We could see lights from Greece. I reassured him, saying 'tonight is the last night of our troubles'.\" But the boat arranged by people smugglers soon got into trouble and capsized. \"In a matter of seconds water was everywhere, filling the boat. It was dark. I lost my children and my wife who had been sitting next to me,\" Nowrouz says. At least 39 migrants, including several children drowned that day. Nowrouz was among more than 60 rescued, What came next was a 12-day struggle to recover the bodies of his loved ones and bring them home for burial. Read more: The untold story of Europe's drowned migrants Anatomy of a shipwreck Nowrouz says he received medical treatment in a camp on the Turkish coast where police showed him photos of bodies which had been recovered. \"I saw my family's pictures there,\" he says. \"I saw the photo of my one-year-old daughter, my six-year-old son and my wife who was 25. I lost them.\" A police officer asked whether Nowrouz intended to bury his family in Turkey or take them home. After phoning relatives he decided the family should be buried in Kabul. The next day a minibus took Nowrouz and other survivors to Istanbul where he turned to the Afghan consulate for help. \"They said that I have to repatriate the bodies myself,\" he says. At the Afghan consulate in Istanbul, Zia Zaki is one of those trying to cope with the fallout from the migrant crisis. \"We have assembled a team of three people to deal specifically with refugee issues,\" he says as he sifts through piles of documents. \"In the last incident I attended there where 25 Afghans who lost their lives at sea. I saw a child's body in the cold room. \"I have my own small child. I tried to stay strong because it was my job to be there and identify the bodies. But when I returned home I looked at my child and I cried.\" Nowrouz spent days calling relatives back home. \"I had to borrow money to repatriate my family back to Afghanistan,\" he says. The consulate told Nowrouz that the bodies of his wife and children were kept in Bursa, a town 300km (187 miles) inland from where the accident happened. He hired a car for the four-hour drive, leaving in the middle of the night. He also booked flights to Kabul for the following evening. But once in Bursa, he could find only the bodies of his wife and son; his baby daughter was missing. With flights arranged he had little choice but to leave her behind to be buried in one of Bursa's cemeteries. At Bursa's Kent cemetery, Imam Neshet Kaya performs the funeral rites for deceased migrants. \"I just buried a child who has no name and we don't know who he was,\" he says. \"He was buried here surrounded by me and a few cemetery workers. Today we are his brother, sister and his family.\" Whether he buried Nowrouz's daughter here is impossible to know. Many of the migrant victims are Muslim and the imam says he makes sure they are buried properly. \"We go to hospital to pick up the body and bring it here to perform the Islamic rituals, washing them and wrapping them in a shroud,\" he says. \"Later we perform the prayers at the mosque.\" The cemetery keeps records of each grave together with available documents, photos or DNA records to allow possible identification and exhumation if a body is claimed at a later date. For Afghans taking a body home means travelling by air. In Bursa, Mr Nowrouz bought coffins for his wife and son, hired an ambulance and headed back to Ataturk airport for the flight to Kabul. At Istanbul airport, Sohila Shalizai runs the office of Afghanistan's Ariana airline - the tragedy of migrants' deaths has become overwhelming here too. \"Lately we have been carrying at least two or three, even up to seven bodies on each flight,\" Ms Rizi says. \"Sometimes we can't cope with the numbers of bodies that come to us and we have refer people to Turkish airlines. Sometimes most of our cargo is coffins.\" Her colleague, Khan Mohamad, says the airline has transported 70 bodies back to Afghanistan over the last 12 months. \"I just returned from customs where I have processed another coffin which came from Izmir.\" Sometimes, Mohamad says, families don't have the money. \"They lose it all when they capsize or the smugglers take it. Last time we sent four bodies to Afghanistan and the relatives still need to pay.\" Nilufar and Mohammad were buried the day they arrived back in Kabul. But even in grief the family is not united. \"I wanted to bring my daughter's body to Afghanistan too\", Nowrouz says, \"but because the whole process took so long I couldn't find her.\" Compounding the heartbreak of losing his family, he now has debts to worry about as well. Having borrowed $8,500 to cover the costs of the ordeal, Nowrouz has been left bankrupt by a journey that already cost him everything. Additional reporting from Ismael Shahamat and Johannes Dell",
"Gold reference": "Hundreds of migrants face huge debts and a logistical nightmare to repatriate the bodies of loved ones who have died during perilous sea crossings to Europe.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man in Afghanistan has been rescued from a boat smuggling in Turkey.",
"Beam candidate": "At least 39 migrants have been rescued from a boat arranged by people smugglers.",
"Top-p candidate": "Dreams have lost hope for Syrian refugees, locals and other migrants, who are depressed and desperate for answers, according to BBC correspondent Zia Zaki."
},
{
"Entry ID": 40,
"Input": "summarize: The 24-year-old from Runcorn became Britain's first champion in the event's 17-year history in 2016. After winning gold in the season-opener in Switzerland earlier in April, she finished behind 18-year-old Janja Garnbret in Chongqing, China. Coxsey still leads Slovenia's Garnbret in the overall rankings, with five more events to take place before August. Japan's Akiyo Noguchi, 27, picked up bronze with third place. \"It was a hot and sweaty final,\" Coxsey wrote on Twitter. \"I'm very happy to finish in second place. Massive congrats to Janja!\" Sport climbing - which includes bouldering - is one of five new sports confirmed for the 2020 Tokyo Olympics. This content will not work on your device, please check Javascript and cookies are enabled or update your browser WATCH: How Shauna Coxsey became the UK's first bouldering world champion",
"Gold reference": "Shauna Coxsey took silver in the second Bouldering World Cup event of the year as she continued her title defence.",
"Greedy candidate": "A British woman has been named Britain's first champion in the sport's 17-year history.",
"Beam candidate": "Olympic gold medallist Shauna Coxsey has been named Britain's first champion.",
"Top-p candidate": "Rory Josip Poepin has been named in the National Assault Team's World Head Top Four for the next 11 years."
},
{
"Entry ID": 41,
"Input": "summarize: The South Africa-born 23-year-old had been playing club cricket in the East Anglian Premier League this season. \"Sean shows a great maturity with the bat and understands his game well,\" Kent's high performance director Simon Willis told the club website. \"The number of runs he has scored in all formats is testament to his focus and concentration.\" Dickson, who has a British mother and holds a UK passport, has previously played first-class cricket for Northerns in South Africa. He also bowls medium pace and could make his first-team debut for the club in their T20 Blast match against Glamorgan on Friday. Kent have not disclosed the length of his contract at the St Lawrence Ground.",
"Gold reference": "Kent have signed batsman Sean Dickson after he impressed during a trial spell with their Second XI.",
"Greedy candidate": "Kent have signed South Africa international Scott Dickson on a one-year contract.",
"Beam candidate": "Kent have signed South Africa's Sean Dickson on a one-year contract.",
"Top-p candidate": "Kent have signed second-class England batsman Shane Dickson on a one-year contract."
},
{
"Entry ID": 42,
"Input": "summarize: If Prime Minister Theresa May does not appear to have had a particularly good night, Ruth Davidson, the Tory leader in Scotland, certainly has. The Scottish Tories have seen double-digit increases in their vote in almost every seat. They've more than doubled their returns in some places where the party was previously unelectable. First they knocked off Angus Robertson, the SNP's deputy leader and top dog at Westminster. They had called that their \"Portillo moment\" - but their best was yet to come, as they dethroned Alex Salmond in Gordon. They even overturned the fourth-safest seat in the country, in Banff and Buchan. Other Scottish Tory gains include: It's been a long time since the Tories have had a night like this in Scotland. In four elections in a row, they returned a single MP. The year before that, 1997, they got zero. You have to go back to 1992 for the last time they won more than a single seat in Scotland. They ended up with 13 - the party's best showing north of the border since 1983. What this Tory resurgence means for the rest of the UK in terms of parliamentary calculations is unclear. The margins are razor-thin, so every seat is precious. But the Tories are resolute in what they believe it means for Scotland. \"Indyref2 is dead,\" Ms Davidson says. The prospect of a second independence referendum has been at the core of the Tory campaign, and indeed their entire revival in Scotland. The SNP have a majority of seats, and thus a \"triple lock\" mandate for that referendum, according to their manifesto - but it certainly seems a more distant prospect than ever. And while Mrs May's future might now be in doubt, Ms Davidson's star is burning more brightly than ever.",
"Gold reference": "Election night has turned out to be a night of contrasting fortunes for the Conservative and Unionist Party.",
"Greedy candidate": "The Scottish Conservatives have a great night in the UK, and it's a good time to see the party's resurgence.",
"Beam candidate": "Scotland's Tories are resolute in what they believe it means for the rest of the UK.",
"Top-p candidate": "Meanwhile, the iconic Tory star is bucking their new leader in the Scottish elections."
},
{
"Entry ID": 43,
"Input": "summarize: A Munster statement said O'Connell, 36, would provide \"invaluable technical expertise and advice\" to the Irish province's next generation of players. \"Every club in the world would love to have an iconic figure such as Paul O'Connell involved in their set-up,\" said Munster chief Garret Fitzgerald. O'Connell made 174 Munster appearances and earned 108 Ireland caps. \"As a Limerick native and proud Munster and Irishman who has played and led teams for Munster, Ireland and the Lions, we were very eager to secure his services in some capacity,\" added Fitzgerald. \"An appointment such as this is a further boost to our academy staff and young players, and to the organisation as a whole.\" The Limerick man, who played on three British & Irish Lions tours, was forced to retire from the game in February after being unable to recover from serious hamstring injury sustained at last year's World Cup. The injury meant that O'Connell was forced to cancel his contract with French club Toulon. Former Lions captain O'Connell spent 14 seasons at Munster and helped the province win two European Cup titles and three Celtic Leagues. O'Connell was also part of Ireland's Grand Slam winning team in 2009 and captained his country to successive Six Nations titles in 2014 and 2015. Munster have appointed former South African international Johan 'Rassie' Erasmus as their Director of Rugby for next season with Anthony Foley's job title remaining as head coach.",
"Gold reference": "Munster great Paul O'Connell will work with the province's academy in a part-time mentoring role over the next year.",
"Greedy candidate": "Munster have appointed Paul O'Connell as their new head coach.",
"Beam candidate": "Munster have appointed Paul O'Connell as their new head coach.",
"Top-p candidate": "Munster boss Garret Fitzgerald is expressing \"reluctant\" an interest in signing Irish coach Paul O'Connell from the University of Limerick."
},
{
"Entry ID": 44,
"Input": "summarize: Marc Carter's plea to find a replacement sippy cup for son Ben was retweeted more than 12,000 times. The 14-year-old has only drunk from the double-handled vessels, which are no longer produced, since the age of two. Tommee Tippee said it will produce 500 cups after it searched factories worldwide and found the original mould. The firm's attention was drawn to the family's plight when Mr Carter launched the Twitter appeal to find a replacement. More on a dad's desperate search for a cup, and other stories His original plea prompted offers of help from as far away as Australia. Mr Carter, 42, said the response from well-wishers had been \"incredible\" and it was a \"huge surprise\" to be contacted by the manufacturer. Mr Carter said: \"For me it's massive. Some people think I'm exaggerating but without it he doesn't drink so personally I'm very relieved.\" Tommee Tippee will send the cups on demand for free to the Carter family. Mr Carter said: \"I would not be happier if I won the lottery. We've moved down to the middle of nowhere and don't want much. \"Just knowing he has got these cups gives us peace of mind.\" Northumberland-based Tommee Tippee does not normally keep the moulds but had been searching factories around the world in the hope of finding the original plans. A spokesman said: \"We are delighted to confirm that we are able to start production on a run of the original cup. \"This will ensure that Ben has a lifetime supply and that his family won't ever have to worry about finding another cup for Ben.\" Mr Carter, from Devon, told the BBC his son has had his current blue cup for three years, but it is now falling apart and may only last a few more weeks. He said: \"This tiny blue cup dictates our life.\"",
"Gold reference": "A dad's desperate search to replace his autistic son's beloved \"little blue cup\" has ended - after the manufacturer stepped in to make a lifetime's supply.",
"Greedy candidate": "A father has been urged to find a replacement sippy cup for his son after he was snatched from a bottle of a blue cup.",
"Beam candidate": "Tommee Tippee has launched an appeal to find a replacement sippy cup for Ben Carter.",
"Top-p candidate": "France's biggest blue coffee company has begun to ship only 250 of its Blue Cups across the world."
},
{
"Entry ID": 45,
"Input": "summarize: Winger Matt Phillips is still nursing a hamstring problem and remains out for the fourth game in a row. Mohamed Elneny should be available for Arsenal after making a quicker than expected recovery from an ankle injury. Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain and Kieran Gibbs are both fitness doubts and will be assessed, while Santi Cazorla remains a long-term absentee. Martin Fisher: \"Even a win in this one won't be enough to lift Arsenal back into the top four, a worrying sign of what might be their fate come the end of the season. \"The FA Cup again offers Arsene Wenger the chance of silverware but it's extending his proud record of Champions League qualification that's more likely to persuade him to sign that contract on his desk. \"After losing three of their last four Premier League outings, the Gunners can ill afford any slip-ups against an Albion side I saw well beaten at Everton last weekend. \"Having superbly steered West Brom to safety by the end of February, the challenge for Tony Pulis now is to make sure the season doesn't peter out tamely.\" Twitter: @martfisher1 West Brom head coach Tony Pulis: \"The most important thing is that we get that mentality into the players and into everyone around the football club that we want to get more points, that we want to push on. \"My aim is to get a team that can stay in the top 12 every year and get to cup finals. You've got to have that strong mentality and desire to do that.\" Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger: \"Success, it's not down to me to judge that. Our job is to do as well as we can until the end of the season. We want to play in the Champions League next season. \"We have a tough job because we have six or seven teams fighting for the places. We are in the semi-finals of the FA Cup, we have an opportunity to do that as well. So overall that's our targets. \"After that, success is basically to take the maximum out of the potential of the team. Where is that? We will see.\" The Baggies are yet to beat a top-seven team this season but I am expecting a response from them on Saturday after their recent displays. Arsenal have a mixed record at The Hawthorns with only one win in their past three league visits, and I don't see them leaving with three points this time either. Prediction: 1-1 Lawro's full predictions v boxer Anthony Crolla Head-to-head West Bromwich Albion Arsenal SAM (Sports Analytics Machine) is a super-computer created by @ProfIanMcHale at the University of Salford that is used to predict the outcome of football matches.",
"Gold reference": "West Brom midfielder James Morrison will miss Saturday's game against Arsenal because of an ankle injury.",
"Greedy candidate": "Arsenal have a hamstring problem after a hamstring injury.",
"Beam candidate": "Arsene Wenger has ruled out the possibility of signing a new contract with West Brom.",
"Top-p candidate": "Jordan Henderson should feature at home for Arsenal after QPR moved out."
},
{
"Entry ID": 46,
"Input": "summarize: Spencer Vaughan, 27, of Campbell Road, Plymouth, suffered spinal damage after hitting his head on a sand bar in Gran Canaria while on a training course. He is seeking damages from the MoD for not warning about the dangers of diving into shallow waters. Mr Justice Davis will give his ruling at a later date. Mr Vaughan, who comes from Cwmbran, South Wales, is now an incomplete tetraplegic following the accident in 2009 and gave evidence from his wheelchair at London's High Court. Mr Vaughan insisted he was \"on duty\" when he walked into the sea to \"cool off\", executing a shallow, surface dive as the waters reached waist height. Malcolm Sheehan QC, for the MoD, suggested to Mr Vaughan that he and his comrades were simply \"chilling out\" on the beach. \"It is unrealistic to say that you were on duty because you had a free choice about how to spend your time\", the barrister said. The QC referred him to \"other accounts\" which suggested that he \"ran into the water and then carried out a Baywatch-style dive\". Mr Vaughan agreed that he and his fellow marines were \"relaxing and chilling out\", but said their primary purpose was to exercise and to swim. Mr Vaughan said he had walked carefully into the water to avoid a young family in front of him. Mr Sheehan said he had \"every sympathy\" for Mr Vaughan's plight, but added: \"On the facts of this case there is no basis for a finding of negligence on the part of the MoD.\" Mr Justice William Davis has now reserved his judgment on the case and will give his ruling at a later date.",
"Gold reference": "A Royal Marine who is suing the Ministry of Defence for up to \u00a38m, has denied that he broke his neck performing a \"Baywatch-style\" dive.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man who suffered a spinal injury after he swam into the sea to avoid a young family has been given a ruling.",
"Beam candidate": "A tetraplegic who suffered a spinal injury after he walked into the sea to \"cool off\", has been ruled guilty of negligence.",
"Top-p candidate": "A judge has decided that by a lack of the recovery power he is accused of obliviously sailing in the sea a golfer had spent more time on the risk of fractured muscles."
},
{
"Entry ID": 47,
"Input": "summarize: Charlie Austin put the home side ahead with a penalty after Shane Long was fouled by Martin Kelly's challenge. Saints deservedly doubled their lead through midfielder Jake Hesketh's first goal for the club just after the hour. Connor Wickham had Palace's best chance but failed to latch on to a loose back header from Jose Fonte inside the box. Austin's fourth goal in the space of six days and three games gave Claude Puel's Southampton a deserved lead after half an hour. Palace lost captain Scott Dann early on to a suspected hamstring injury and it was his replacement Kelly who was at fault in the build-up to the opening goal. The central defender failed to control the ball with his chest and as it ran away from him Long gave chase and was tripped inside the box. Long almost netted a goal of his own in the closing stages of the first half when he rounded Palace goalkeeper Wayne Hennessey, but his finish lacked power and allowed Damien Delaney to clear off the line. Saints' continued pressure in the second half finally told as they doubled their lead through 20-year-old Hesketh. Long drove into the box and when his shot was saved by Hennessey the rebound broke to Hesketh, who calmly swept a left-footed finish into the bottom corner. Southampton midfielder Jake Hesketh told BBC Radio Solent: \"First and foremost we're through in the cup, but to score a (first senior) goal was perfect for me. \"It's a bit of a whirlwind really. It's come back to me nicely and then I've just run off. \"In my head I'm thinking, 'what am I doing here?' as I wasn't sure whether or not to celebrate with a knee-slide. But, it was brilliant. \"It's really nice and you feel really appreciated by the fans and to get a goal for them, I'm really happy. \"Training with the lads day-in, day-out is really beneficial. You try to take everything on board and take it into situations like tonight.\" Crystal Palace manager Alan Pardew: \"Shane Long is quick and has got a bit of history in those situations. He was definitely going over, I know that, but the video I saw was inconclusive. \"The players felt it (the penalty) was a bit harsh but it was difficult to see unless you see it clearly on television. \"The best team won for sure. They were very sharp. Their passing and movement caused us problems. \"It is always a risk when you make a lot of changes and we had one or two players that looked a bit rusty. We didn't have enough imagination to find a route to goal.\" Match ends, Southampton 2, Crystal Palace 0. Second Half ends, Southampton 2, Crystal Palace 0. Offside, Crystal Palace. Joel Ward tries a through ball, but Christian Benteke is caught offside. Corner, Southampton. Conceded by Wayne Hennessey. Attempt saved. Nathan Redmond (Southampton) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom right corner. Assisted by Matt Targett. Christian Benteke (Crystal Palace) wins a free kick on the left wing. Foul by Jos\u00e9 Fonte (Southampton). Foul by Joel Ward (Crystal Palace). Jordy Clasie (Southampton) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Substitution, Southampton. Dusan Tadic replaces Shane Long. Wilfried Zaha (Crystal Palace) wins a free kick on the right wing. Foul by Harrison Reed (Southampton). Yohan Cabaye (Crystal Palace) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul. Foul by Yohan Cabaye (Crystal Palace). Nathan Redmond (Southampton) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Attempt missed. Yohan Cabaye (Crystal Palace) right footed shot from outside the box is high and wide to the left. Attempt saved. Christian Benteke (Crystal Palace) header from the centre of the box is saved in the centre of the goal. Assisted by Wilfried Zaha with a cross. Lee Chung-yong (Crystal Palace) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Foul by Shane Long (Southampton). Matt Targett (Southampton) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul. Wilfried Zaha (Crystal Palace) wins a free kick on the right wing. Foul by Matt Targett (Southampton). Substitution, Southampton. Pierre-Emile H\u00f8jbjerg replaces Jake Hesketh. Delay over. They are ready to continue. Delay in match Maya Yoshida (Southampton) because of an injury. Delay over. They are ready to continue. Substitution, Crystal Palace. Jason Puncheon replaces Jordon Mutch. Delay in match Jos\u00e9 Fonte (Southampton) because of an injury. Yohan Cabaye (Crystal Palace) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Foul by James Ward-Prowse (Southampton). Attempt saved. Jake Hesketh (Southampton) left footed shot from outside the box is saved in the centre of the goal. Assisted by Nathan Redmond. Substitution, Crystal Palace. Christian Benteke replaces Bakary Sako. Goal! Southampton 2, Crystal Palace 0. Jake Hesketh (Southampton) left footed shot from the centre of the box to the top right corner. Attempt saved. Shane Long (Southampton) right footed shot from the centre of the box is saved in the centre of the goal. Assisted by James Ward-Prowse. Attempt missed. Matt Targett (Southampton) left footed shot from outside the box misses to the right following a corner. Corner, Southampton. Conceded by Damien Delaney. Connor Wickham (Crystal Palace) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Foul by Maya Yoshida (Southampton). Substitution, Southampton. Nathan Redmond replaces Charlie Austin. Jordon Mutch (Crystal Palace) wins a free kick in the defensive half.",
"Gold reference": "Southampton made light work of Crystal Palace in their all-Premier League tie, with a goal in either half sending Saints into the EFL Cup fourth round.",
"Greedy candidate": "Southampton's first goal of the season was a brilliant one-point victory over Southampton.",
"Beam candidate": "Crystal Palace's first goal of the season has been a whirlwind as they beat Southampton in the Premier League.",
"Top-p candidate": "New signs and goals from Charlie Austin and Jake Hesketh combined to lift Palace up as they flew to Southampton."
},
{
"Entry ID": 48,
"Input": "summarize: Speaking on a visit to Swansea as part of his \"Say No to the EU tour\", he rejected the idea that Wales is a net beneficiary of being in the union. Mr Farage visited an e-cigarette firm and attended a rally of 400 people. Swansea East Labour AM Mike Hedges said many industries were \"highly dependent\" on the EU and it would be a \"giant leap in the dark\" for the UK to leave. David Cameron has promised a referendum on UK membership of the European Union by the end of 2017. During the factory visit, Mr Farage told the BBC: \"Wales gets a rotten deal from Europe. \"Its fishing industry is being destroyed, its steel industry is being seriously damaged, little businesses like this are under threat of going out of business, and there's nothing a politician in the assembly or in Westminster can do about it.\" He said the UK had \"given away control of industry, fishing, farming and business to Brussels\". But Mr Hedges insisted remaining an EU member was very much in Wales' interests. \"We've really become part of it, a lot of industries and commerce are highly dependent on the European community,\" he said. \"I voted to come out last time, but it'd be a giant leap into the dark if we decide to come out now.\" Around 40 people gathered outside the Liberty Stadium to protest against Mr Farage speaking there on Friday evening. The unions Unite and Unison organised the rally. Andy Richards, chair of Unite in Wales, accused Mr Farage of being \"intolerant towards asylum seekers and immigrants\". Addressing the protesters, Llyr Powell from UKIP rejected the accusation the party was intolerant. He said the protest was \"politically motivated\" because \"UKIP is digging in to the core Labour vote in south Wales\". Mr Farage told the rally the referendum was a chance \"to take back control of our lives\". He urged not to listen to a \"pro-EU elite\", which he said included the Kinnock family. \"There's an argument we must confront the Kinnocks with, and virtually everyone in Welsh politics, apart from UKIP. \"It's that far from the EU being good for Wales and business, actually by saying no to the European Union we can take back control of our own lives and put business first. \"The referendum is an opportunity of a lifetime.\" Responding, Lord Kinnock said: \"Personal attacks mean he's losing the argument. \"Wales benefits economically and socially from EU membership, not from UKIP.\"",
"Gold reference": "UKIP leader Nigel Farage has said Wales gets a \"rotten deal\" from the UK's membership of the EU.",
"Greedy candidate": "UKIP is \"disappointed\" by the EU's decision to leave the EU, a Labour MP has said.",
"Beam candidate": "UKIP has said it would be a \"giant leap into the dark\" for the UK to leave the European Union.",
"Top-p candidate": "The U.S. has criticised the legal and social status of the European Union by calling out his government to not be part of an EU."
},
{
"Entry ID": 49,
"Input": "summarize: Brake manufacturer Meritor, which owns the site in Cwmbran where facilities could be built, is backing proposals. Joint plans from Coleg Gwent and Torfaen council will now be put to the Welsh government for approval. A consultation with residents will then be held into the plans. Councillor David Yeowell, executive member for education, said: \"The proposal will see a new integrated post-16 centre built on land next to Morrison's supermarket in Cwmbran. \"The new centre will provide an equitable provision for all young people in the borough and is long overdue.\"",
"Gold reference": "A new training and post-16 education centre could replace high school sixth forms in Torfaen after the council's cabinet backed \u00a332.5m plans.",
"Greedy candidate": "A new post-16 centre in Cwmbran is to be built on land next to Morrison's supermarket.",
"Beam candidate": "Plans for a new post-16 centre in Cwmbran have been approved by the Welsh government.",
"Top-p candidate": "A council is to approve a modern post-16 post-16 scheme for schools in Denbighshire."
},
{
"Entry ID": 50,
"Input": "summarize: The latest Markit/CIPS services Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) fell to 52.7 last month, down from January's reading of 55.6. Any figure above 50 means expansion, but the rise in service sector activity was the weakest since March 2013. The service sector accounts for more than three-quarters of the UK economy. Surveys from Markit/CIPS earlier in the week put the manufacturing sector's PMI at 50.8 and construction at 54.2. \"The weaker increase in services activity mainly reflected a slower expansion in the volume of incoming new business,\" the survey said. Markit chief economist Chris Williamson added: \"Survey responses reveal that firms are worried about signs of faltering demand, but boardrooms have also become unsettled by concerns regarding the increased risk of 'Brexit', financial market volatility and weak economic growth at home and abroad.\" He added that the extent of the slowdown would come as a \"shock\" to policymakers and would put an end to talk of a possible interest rate rise. Mr Williamson described February's three PMI readings as \"a triple whammy of disappointing survey news\". Last week, official figures confirmed that the UK economy grew 0.5% in the final three months of 2015, with the services sector highlighted as the key factor driving growth. The Office for National Statistics said the \"buoyancy\" of services had offset the \"relative sluggishness\" of the rest of the UK economy. Signs of weakening growth in the UK economy have pushed back estimates of when the Bank of England might begin to raise interest rates. Commenting on the latest PMI survey, Jeremy Cook, chief economist at World First, said: \"The May Bank of England meeting had previously been seen as a possible time for a rate hike. The volatility of global markets and the self-inflicted wound of the EU referendum put paid to that months ago. \"We still believe, however, that some measures that foresee the Bank of England holding rates at 0.5% until 2020 are little short of absurd.\" Martin Beck, senior economic adviser to the EY Item Club, said the PMI readings would provide \"plenty of food for thought\" for the Bank of England's rate-setting Monetary Policy Committee. He added: \"Members will have to judge the degree to which the surveys are flagging a genuine slowdown in activity growth, or merely reacting to the negative headlines since the start of the year. In reality, growth may be softening, but perhaps not as sharply as the survey data suggest.\" Meanwhile, a similar survey indicated that eurozone businesses had their worst month for more than a year in February, bolstering the case for more monetary policy easing by the European Central Bank. Markit's final composite PMI, which is regarded as a good guide to growth, fell to 53 last month from January's 53.6 - its lowest reading since the start of 2015. However, that was better than the preliminary reading of 52.7 and well above the 50 mark that denotes growth.",
"Gold reference": "The UK's dominant services sector weakened in February, registering its slowest rate of growth for nearly three years, a survey has indicated.",
"Greedy candidate": "The UK economy has jumped to a record high of 0.7 per cent in the last three months, according to a survey by Markit/CIPS.",
"Beam candidate": "Markit/CIPS's service sector activity fell to a record high of 52.7 last month, according to the latest survey.",
"Top-p candidate": "Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) levels went up at 51.5, an early warning in February."
},
{
"Entry ID": 51,
"Input": "summarize: They said the Indian prime minister stole the show when he rolled out his yoga mat and eased uncomfortably into the lotus position to help break the world record for what is claimed to be the largest yoga session in history. Narendra Modi boasts that he does yoga for an hour every morning but he looked a little stiff as he joined 37,000 other people to perform a series of asanas - yoga positions - on the lawns outside the Indian parliament in celebration of the first UN World Yoga Day. Mr Modi had consistently said he wouldn't be taking part in the record attempt but in the event he stretched and puffed his way through the 35-minute routine with the rest of them. Some say he simply couldn't resist the opportunity for an image that will undoubtedly appear in newspapers around the world tomorrow morning. And that's in keeping with the real spirit of this event, because this is all about public relations. The Indian government's new-found enthusiasm for yoga can be traced directly back to Mr Modi. He's already created a ministry of yoga with its own dedicated yoga minister, and his personal intervention is said to have been decisive in persuading the UN to designate June 21st as World Yoga Day. The official publicity presents today's festivities as a humble celebration of an ancient Indian tradition of exercise. It is India's second greatest gift to the world after the number zero, according to Mr Modi's PR machine. But there was always much more to the government's agenda than that. It isn't about propagating Hindu nationalism, as some in India's Muslim minority complained. The government quickly stripped out anything that could be described as \"Hindu\" from today's event in response to these criticisms, purging the Om chant and sun salutations from the menu. But Mr Modi has recognised that yoga can do more for India than just encourage health and happiness through regular exercise. The Indian prime minister has always had a talent for publicity and he has spotted that with yoga India has a unique \"brand\" that can deliver huge economic benefits for the country. According to one estimate the worldwide yoga industry has boomed into a $30 billion-plus business. Hundreds of thousands of tourists visit ashrams and undertake yoga classes in India every year. Mr Modi is hoping tens of thousands more can be persuaded to come. But he's also got an eye on the country's wider image abroad. He sees yoga as a wonderful way to promote India in the world. What better badge of nationhood than this ancient tradition of health and harmony? And if that enhances the image of Mr Modi himself along the way, all the better, will be Mr Modi's likely judgement.",
"Gold reference": "Today wasn't World Yoga Day but World Modi Day, sniped some critics this morning.",
"Greedy candidate": "India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi has stepped up his yoga practice to mark the first day of the world's first World Yoga Day.",
"Beam candidate": "India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi has said he will take part in a record attempt to break the world record for the largest yoga session in history.",
"Top-p candidate": "Five days after the first session of the Yoga Music Express ended, which was presented in India's parliament on Friday, India announced that it would host the 35-minute practice, which he said would show way ahead."
},
{
"Entry ID": 52,
"Input": "summarize: Aweys Faqey, from North London, was arrested at the airport, north-east of London, on 23 May. He is due to appear at Westminster Magistrates' Court on Tuesday afternoon. His arrest is not connected to last week's suicide bomb attack at Manchester Arena, Scotland Yard said after he was detained.",
"Gold reference": "A 37-year-old man has been charged with preparing for acts of terrorism after being arrested at Stansted Airport.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man has been charged with the murder of a man who was shot in the head by a man in the Manchester Arena attack.",
"Beam candidate": "A man has appeared in court charged with the murder of a man who was stabbed to death in Manchester.",
"Top-p candidate": "A man has appeared in court charged with the murder of two people after he was released by a security guard at a London airport."
},
{
"Entry ID": 53,
"Input": "summarize: Derek Medina admitted taking the picture on his phone and uploading it on to the social media site. He failed to convince the jury that he had shot Jennifer Alfonso eight times in self-defence after years of abuse. He said his wife was threatening him with a knife when he shot her in their home in Miami, but prosecutors said she was cowering on the floor. When he posted the picture, he wrote on Facebook that he expected to go to prison or be sentenced to death for the killing. Prosecutors successfully argued that the 27-year-old wife was in fear of her life when she was shot in August 2013. Medina had vowed to kill her if she left him and she had told friends she intended to do that, the court heard. Miami-Dade State Attorney Katherine Rundle said: \"No family should ever have to see their daughter killed and then exhibited worldwide on the internet like some macabre trophy to a husband's anger.\" Medina, 33, faces a sentence of 25 years to life for second-degree murder.",
"Gold reference": "A Florida man who killed his wife and posted a photo of the body on Facebook has been found guilty of murder.",
"Greedy candidate": "A Miami-Dade judge has sentenced a man to life in prison for a second-degree murder.",
"Beam candidate": "A Miami-Dade judge has sentenced a man to life in prison for second-degree murder.",
"Top-p candidate": "Jurors have defended a man charged with extorting cocaine in his home in Miami, including its US wife, a woman who shoots a white man in a video-sharing video."
},
{
"Entry ID": 54,
"Input": "summarize: Adrian Ismay, 52, was seriously hurt after a booby-trap device exploded under his van in Belfast on 4 March. The police said that a post-mortem examination showed he died as a \"direct result of the injuries\" of the bomb. A dissident republican group, widely referred to as the new IRA, said it carried out the attack. The organisation said Mr Ismay was targeted for training officers at Maghaberry Prison near Lisburn, County Antrim. Sue McAllister, director general of the Northern Ireland Prison Service, spent time with the Ismay family on Wednesday. She said they were \"devastated and beyond shock at what's happened\". \"Like all of us, they thought that he was on the mend and was doing really well,\" said Mrs McAllister. \"We thought he would make a full recovery, we expected him to come back to work in due course, so we're all shocked, but particularly Sharon and her daughters.\" Mrs McAllister condemned the behaviour of some paramilitary inmates at Maghaberry Prison, who reportedly cheered, smoked cigars and mocked wardens at the high-security jail when news of Mr Ismay's death filtered through. \"This was just unacceptable behaviour by a very small number of prisoners,\" said Mrs McAllister. \"My colleagues in Maghaberry dealt with it professionally, with great fortitude and with the courage they display on a daily basis.\" She admitted she and her colleagues in the Prison Service felt \"very angry\" on hearing the reports of the celebrations in the exercise yard of the prison. \"We encounter challenging behaviour by a small number of prisoners every day, and we deal with it with great professionalism and we do not stoop to behaving that way in response,\" she added. A man appeared in court on Saturday charged in connection with the bomb attack on Mr Ismay. Det Ch Insp Richard Campbell said it was \"yet another difficult day for the Ismay family, his friends and colleagues as they struggle to come to terms with the events of the past 12 days\". He added: \"We have spoken to the family this morning and advised them of this development. \"We are also liaising with the Public Prosecution Service in relation to the individual who is currently charged with attempted murder and causing an explosion with intent to endanger life.\" The PSNI have also repeated an appeal for information on two cars that police believe may have been used by the bombers - a red Citroen C3 and a silver Skoda Fabia.",
"Gold reference": "The PSNI has launched a murder inquiry into the death of a prison officer who died 11 days after being injured in a dissident republican bomb attack.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man has been charged with the murder of a man who was attacked by a bomb at a prison in Belfast.",
"Beam candidate": "A man has been charged with the murder of a paramilitary inmate at Maghaberry Prison in County Antrim.",
"Top-p candidate": "A former prisoner has died as a result of a \"failure\" and possession of a device, the Irish IRA says."
},
{
"Entry ID": 55,
"Input": "summarize: A statement says to meet the criteria for the revamped 2014 Super League they had to establish a partnership with a men's club or similar institution. It is the chairman's belief that by incorporating the ladies' team with the men's team, we can develop a one-club mentality The club say the shared chairmanship of Ray Trew will bring \"mutual gain\". \"The players will have access to the kind of facilities and resources the Notts squad have,\" the statement read. \"This was another key driving factor. Together with the benefits for the playing staff, there are numerous off-field advantages also, with the ladies' side able to tap into the well-established commercial, media and marketing facilities available at Notts County.\" Many Lincoln Ladies supporters were angered by the move, which will see the club playing their home games around 35 miles away from their current temporary home at Lincoln City's Sincil Bank. The Lady Imps, who had an application to relocate blocked by the FA Women's Super League in 2012, say they understand fans' concerns and \"are working closely with organisations in both Nottingham and Lincoln to ensure that following the club in our new home will be as easy and affordable as possible\". The statement added: \"It is the chairman's belief that by incorporating the ladies' team with the men's team, we can develop a one-club mentality that will benefit both sides and aid growth of the combined brand.\" Lady Imps player Megan Harris told BBC Lincolnshire: \"It's a really tough situation. I have been with Lincoln since the very beginning so it is hard to see something that I have been part of move. \"But obviously I work for the club as well and can see behind the scenes and what's going on and how the women's game is progressing. It is turning into much more of a business now and money is starting to talk. \"Liverpool are sitting top of the Super League because they had a massive cash injection and the men's team are backing them. If you want to compete at the highest level then that's what you have to do.\"",
"Gold reference": "Lincoln Ladies have insisted their controversial relocation to Nottingham and decision to play as Notts County next season was their only option.",
"Greedy candidate": "Lincoln Ladies have agreed to a \u00a320m deal with the club to create a new club.",
"Beam candidate": "Notts County Ladies have signed a new chairmanship of Ray Trew, the chairman of the club.",
"Top-p candidate": "Just two-thirds of Lincoln Ladies players will be employed by Notts County or be part of a team where they can do football for it's own."
},
{
"Entry ID": 56,
"Input": "summarize: The German shepherd, which belonged to Cleveland Police, was being exercised near to Ormseby Stables in Eston when it bit a 28-year-old man. The man suffered puncture wounds on his arm and upper body and was taken to hospital. The dog handler also suffered an injury to his arm. The force has apologised and referred itself to the Independent Police Complaints Commission. A police spokesman said: \"Based on an assessment of the animal it has been put to sleep. \"This was not an easy decision for any of the people involved, but has been made in the best interests of all those involved.\" The incident occurred on 6 June. Temporary Assistant Chief Constable Ciaron Irvine said it would be \"wrong to speculate\" until the full circumstances were known. \"What is clear is that this incident should not have happened and we must absolutely understand what went wrong,\" he added.",
"Gold reference": "A police dog has been put down after biting a member of the public.",
"Greedy candidate": "A dog handler has been put to sleep after a dog bit a man in a secluded area of the city.",
"Beam candidate": "A dog handler has been put to sleep after it bit a man in the north-west of England.",
"Top-p candidate": "A dog handler has been hit by a cat in the Highlands, County Tyrone after he was badly injured in a dog attack."
},
{
"Entry ID": 57,
"Input": "summarize: Ackerman was initially banned in October last year after being found guilty of corruption. He had laid bets against a horse knowing its jockey aimed not to win. Ackerman was granted a stay of implementation in November, but his disqualification has been reactivated with immediate effect until 11 June. However, his fine of \u00a35,000 was quashed upon appeal, at the invitation of the British Horseracing Authority. Ackerman was banned after an investigation into six races featuring Ad Vitam at Kempton and Wolverhampton between 2 November, 2011 and 8 March, 2012. He was found to have breached the rules of racing alongside jockey Michael Stainton, registered owner Kenneth Mackay and former owner David Greenwood. Stainton was banned for two years, Mackay for six months and fined \u00a35,000, with Greenwood, who had already been warned off for a separate offence, banned for eight years. All three also failed in their appeals, although, a separate appeal by Stainton against the penalty imposed \"will be considered in due course\". Stewart-Moore Solicitors, who represent Ackerman, Greenwood and Mackay, said in a statement that the \"matter needs to be resolved by a High Court judge\". \"Messrs Ackerman, Greenwood and Mackay have not acted in breach of the rules of racing in any way,\" they added. \"In spite of this they have been found, yet again, to have taken part in a conspiracy that has never been properly put to them.\"",
"Gold reference": "Towcester racecourse chief executive Kevin Ackerman has failed in his bid to overturn a six-month suspension from racing.",
"Greedy candidate": "A horse racing boss has been fined \u00a35,000 after he was found guilty of a \"serious\" sabotage of a horse.",
"Beam candidate": "A jockey has been fined \u00a35,000 after he was found guilty of failing to win a race at Kempton and Wolverhampton.",
"Top-p candidate": "A 62-year-old motor racing champion have been fined \u00a325,000 by a High Court judge."
},
{
"Entry ID": 58,
"Input": "summarize: Officials in the city of Novosibirsk ruled that Parnas, the main opposition coalition, had failed to collect enough valid signatures to take part. Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny called the move a \"blow to the democratic freedom of Russians\". The regional ballot is seen by Russia's opposition as a key test in the run-up to next year's parliamentary vote. The three hunger strikers were detained by police and fined for staging a protest. They and other activists in the Siberian city had spent weeks collecting the thousands of signatures required to register for election. But the election commission in Novosibirsk - Russia's third largest city - found faults with more than 1,000 of the 11,000 signatures they submitted. The activists insist they were valid, and said the authorities used out-of-date databases to check them. In one case, a woman's signature was ruled out because her middle name came up in records as Timurovich, a man's name, instead of Timurovna. The three - Leonid Volkov, Sergey Boyko and Yegor Savin - have said they will eat nothing and drink only water until their case is reviewed. Mr Navalny warned that the \"surreal\" action could be replicated in other elections, both regional and national. He is a fierce critic of President Vladimir Putin, accusing the government of large-scale corruption. \"There is a political order not to let the opposition take part in elections,\" he told Moscow Echo radio station.",
"Gold reference": "Three Russian opposition activists have gone on hunger strike after they were barred from running in local elections.",
"Greedy candidate": "Three activists have been fined for a \"blow to the democratic freedom of Russians\" in a bid to take part in a regional election.",
"Beam candidate": "Three activists have been fined for failing to register for election in Russia's capital, Novosibirsk.",
"Top-p candidate": "A Moscow government has ordered Syrian President Bashar al-Assad's government to file a regional election by ordering Russia to \"decafeate\" the parliamentary vote in the city."
},
{
"Entry ID": 59,
"Input": "summarize: The Hemel Hempstead-born 37-year-old succeeds fellow Briton Ian Poulter, who hosted the 2015 event at Woburn. This year's tournament was the first since 2008 and was won by Sheffield's Matthew Fitzpatrick. The Grove has only ever held a European Tour event once before in its history - when Tiger Woods won a World Golf Championship tournament in 2006. \"We knew the British Masters would get great crowds,\" said Donald. \"The British people love coming out and supporting their events and supporting the British players. It was a fun and successful week. \"Woburn was a tremendous venue and Ian did a brilliant job as the ambassador. It's my turn next and I will be looking forward to coming back and hopefully having even more success and bringing even more people to this amazing tournament.\"",
"Gold reference": "Luke Donald will host the 2016 British Masters at The Grove in his home county of Hertfordshire.",
"Greedy candidate": "The British Masters have been held in the UK for the first time since 2008.",
"Beam candidate": "The British Masters have been held at The Grove in Sheffield for the first time since 2008.",
"Top-p candidate": "The final round of the British Masters at The Grove has been won by Ian Donald."
},
{
"Entry ID": 60,
"Input": "summarize: It has been a busy period of transfer activity as teams look to strengthen and build on their previous campaign. With gaps to fill, many clubs have been looking outside of the Scottish border for new talent. Alongside club stalwarts and players familiar with the Scottish game, which players will help shape the season? Celtic built their title-winning side around a solid foundation at the back last season. Virgil van Dijk and Jason Denayer were at the heart of a defence that kept 22 clean sheets in the league. With the latter returning to parent club Manchester City, manager Ronny Deila has been quick to find a replacement. Dedryck Boyata signed a four-year contract this summer, ending a nine-year stay at Manchester City and the 24-year-old has already looked settled among his new team-mates. A goal on his competitive debut against Stjarnan, followed with the winner on Thursday, helped Celtic secure a 1-0 first leg lead over Qarabag. Celtic will be looking for this form to continue as they chase a fifth consecutive title. Last season, Aberdeen had their best league campaign since the 1993-94 season as they secured second place. This season, they will be looking to improve on the promising strides they have taken under Derek McInnes. The Dons have strength in depth in most departments, but the acquisition of goalkeeper Danny Ward from Liverpool on a season-long loan looks to have been a smart piece of business. McInnes deployed both Jamie Langfield, 35, and Scott Brown, 30, between the sticks last season, but the early indications seem to point to Ward being given the opportunity to stake a claim to be the club's number one this season. Impressive displays in the Europa League qualifiers have strengthened the 22-year-old Welshman's position and he could be a key factor if the Dons are to push Celtic all the way in this season's title race. Nadir Ciftci's \u00a31.5m departure to Celtic this summer has left Dundee United boss Jackie McNamara with a position to fill in his forward line. McNamara will be hoping that Croatia Under-21 cap Darko Bodul will be the man to do the job. At 26, Bodul has plenty of experience throughout Europe. Beginning his career in his native Austria with First Vienna, Bodul has also had spells with Dutch sides Heerenveen, Ajax and Sparta Rotterdam, as well as stints with Nacional of Portugal, Austrians Sturm Graz and Danish outfit Odense. He left Austrian Bundesliga side Rheindorf Altach at the end of last season. Bodul made his pre-season debut in a United shirt during the 2-1 defeat by Queens Park Rangers, coming on as a second-half substitute before starting in the 1-0 friendly defeat by Watford, lasting an hour before being replaced. McNamara described his new signing as ''technically gifted, skilful and a penalty box goal scorer\". With some impressive teams on his CV and a two-year contract, United will hope to see the best of Bodul in the coming season. He may have the most famous name in Scottish football, but Dutchman Rodney Sneijder wants to be his own man at Dundee United. The younger brother of Galatasaray midfielder Wesley, Rodney was signed on a two-year deal after his release by Almere City in his homeland. It marks the first time that the 24-year-old midfielder has played for a club outside of the Netherlands. Having begun his career at Ajax, Sneijder will be looking to kick-start his time in Scottish football when the season gets under way. With United looking to rebuild after the recent departures of Gary Mackay-Stevens and Stuart Armstrong to Celtic, it would appear that he will likely get the opportunity to do so. Sneijder may get his first chance on the opening weekend as his side face Aberdeen at Tannadice this Sunday. After winning the Championship last season, Hearts will be determined to re-establish themselves as a top-flight club after their season in the second tier. Robbie Neilson has conducted a squad overhaul as they look to build upon their title success. The conclusion of Genero Zeefuik's loan spell from Groningen has left a void up front that Neilson will be looking for Juanma Delgado to occupy. The 24-year-old Spaniard joins from Greek Super League outfit Kalloni on a three-year contract. At 6ft 2in, the former Levante youth player will have a presence in the forward line that Neilson will require to meet his ambitions of finishing in the top six this season. He is described by his new manager as \"a good player, technically very good, great in the air and has good link-up play - and he's a great character\".",
"Gold reference": "The Scottish Premiership season commences this weekend and fans can expect to see a swarm of new faces run out for their side for the first time.",
"Greedy candidate": "Celtic have signed a new manager and a new manager.",
"Beam candidate": "Celtic are looking for new players to help shape the Scottish Premiership, with Virgil van Dijk and Jason Denayer returning.",
"Top-p candidate": "Unlike Germany and one of the world's leading football clubs, Celtic have released their second striker of the season."
},
{
"Entry ID": 61,
"Input": "summarize: Families with one parent with a taxable income of more than \u00a350,000 will lose some of the benefit, and it will be withdrawn entirely if one parent earns above \u00a360,000. The government hopes to save \u00a31.5bn a year to help reduce the deficit. David Cameron described the move as \"fundamentally fair\" but Labour said it was a \"huge assault\" on families. Defending the policy, the prime minister said: \"I'm not saying those people are rich, but I think it is right that they make a contribution. \"If we don't raise that... from that group of people - the better off 15% in the country - we would have to find someone else to take it from.\" Shadow chancellor Ed Balls said the government should tax the richest, rather than make changes that affect those on middle incomes, and described the changes as a \"complete shambles\". The change comes the day before a key Commons debate over the welfare system, when MPs discuss plans to break the link between benefit rises and inflation. Chancellor George Osborne has proposed a cap of 1% - which is below the expected rise in the cost of living - on increases in most working-age benefits, such as Jobseeker's Allowance and maternity pay, and tax credits for three years from 2013-14. Child benefit, housing benefit and universal credit will be capped for two years from 2014-15. All these changes will affect millions of people. More than 250,000 high earners have already opted out of receiving child benefit but several hundred thousand others who missed a deadline to declare they will no longer qualify will now have to fill in self-assessment tax forms. Campaigners say this has created complexity in the system. They have also pointed to the fact that a family where two parents work and both earn \u00a349,000 a year will keep their benefits, while a family with a single earner on \u00a351,000 - where the other parent may have chosen to stay at home in a caring role - will lose part of theirs. Child benefit is paid at the rate of \u00a320.30 a week for the first child, and then \u00a313.40 a week for each child after that. It lasts until each child reaches 16, or 18 if they are still in full-time education, and in some cases until they are 20. More than a million people are set to be affected by the cut, with the Institute of Fiscal Studies estimating that they would lose an average of \u00a31,300 a year. Any child benefit paid to high-earners who have failed to opt out will be clawed back through the High Income Child Benefit Charge, administered by HM Revenue and Customs. If somebody earning more than \u00a350,000 or their partner keeps claiming child benefit, then the higher earner will have to admit this in a self-assessment tax form. The IFS estimates that 500,000 extra people might have to fill in these forms as a result of the change. They will need to register for self-assessment, if they have not already, by 5 October or face a fine. A Treasury spokesman said: \"Withdrawing child benefit on the basis of the combined family income would require intrusive means-testing of all eight million households getting child benefit. The way we are doing it is simpler for the vast majority of families.\" But the stance has not been welcomed by many people who would be affected. Paul, from West Sussex, who has a six-year-old son was one of a number of people who reportedly failed to receive a letter from HMRC explaining the options for higher earners on what to do. He told the BBC: \"My salary goes up and down, but we will continue to claim it. But my tax affairs are very simple so the one thing I don't really want to do is the self-assessment thing.\" The deadline has now expired for higher earners to opt out of receiving child benefit. They will still be able to do so, but may still face a tax charge for the time still in the system since 7 January. The latest official figures from HM Revenue and Customs show that 191,873 people have opted out of receiving child benefit - mostly because they know they will consistently earn more than \u00a360,000 a year, or earn over \u00a350,000 and do not want to be pulled into the self-assessment system. That figure was expected to rise above 250,000 over the weekend. These figures will be confirmed later.",
"Gold reference": "More than a million better-off families will lose some or all of their child benefit, under rules now in force.",
"Greedy candidate": "Labour's new tax policy will be withdrawn if one parent earns more than \u00a360,000 a year, the prime minister has said.",
"Beam candidate": "Labour's prime minister has said the government should tax the richest, rather than make changes that affect middle incomes.",
"Top-p candidate": "Connacht, Labour has said it would not raise the voice of wealth, triggering a massive new effort to lead jobs across Britain and and by reducing the wealth gain."
},
{
"Entry ID": 62,
"Input": "summarize: Salva Kiir issued a decree dismissing all ministers and deputy ministers, as well as Vice-President Riek Machar. No clear reason was given for the sackings, but analysts say Mr Kiir and Mr Machar have been embroiled in a power struggle for months. South Sudan has suffered from chronic economic problems since it split from Sudan in 2011. There was tight security outside ministry buildings on Wednesday, while radio broadcasts urged people to remain calm, the AFP news agency reports. Its stability has been hampered by lingering rows over territory and oil with its northern neighbour. Recently some of Mr Kiir's colleagues have hinted at discontent with his leadership. Local reports say Mr Kiir is battling to maintain control of the Sudan People's Liberation Movement (SPLM), the former rebel group that now runs the country. Mr Machar, who had been stripped of some of his powers in April, had hinted that he may stand against Mr Kiir for leadership of the SPLM before the next presidential election in 2015. By Nyambura WambuguBBC News, Juba Dissolving the cabinet in South Sudan hints at a wider attempt by the president to restructure not only the government but power and access to power in the country. There have been reports in recent weeks of strained relations within the governing SPLM and the relationship between the president and his deputy are said to be at an all-time low. Although the cabinet restructuring has been a long time coming, its timing is curious and raises suspicions that the president could be using his executive powers to stamp out dissent in the party and disagreement within his government. Whether the sacking of the entire cabinet will succeed in calming the disquiet within South Sudan's political circles remains to be seen -there is also a real fear that this might further divide the country along ethnic lines. The BBC's Nyambura Wambugu in the capital, Juba, says there is a real fear that the sacking could further divide the country along ethnic lines. Mr Kiir is from the Dinka community, which is the largest in South Sudan, while Mr Machar is from the second-largest group, the Nuer, some of whom have complained about Dinka domination. Under-secretaries have been put in charge of the departments and the government insists it can function smoothly until new ministers are appointed. Barnaba Marial Benjamin, who had been information minister until Tuesday, characterised the sackings as a \"major reshuffle\" and said it was part of Mr Kiir's constitutional mandate. \"Some of these people will come back and some will not,\" Mr Benjamin AFP. Among the other leaders to be dismissed was Pagan Amum, the top negotiator in peace talks with Sudan. He was removed from his post as SPLM secretary general and the decree said he would be investigated for mismanaging the party. Last month Mr Kiir sacked two other senior ministers embroiled in a multi-million dollar financial scandal, a decision reportedly criticised by Mr Amum. It was unclear whether Tuesday's decree had any link to the scandal. South Sudanese journalist Nhial Bol said Mr Kiir had probably acted to end the paralysis in his government. \"Things have not been moving in the government because of this internal fighting over who is going to control the SPLM,\" Mr Bol told Reuters news agency. South Sudan is rich in oil, but is one of Africa's least developed countries, with few paved roads and poor health and educational facilities. It gained independence from Sudan in July 2011 after a decades-long civil war. However, the oil refineries are on Sudanese territory, so the South relies on its northern neighbour to get its product on to the market.",
"Gold reference": "South Sudan's president has sacked his entire cabinet, in an apparent power struggle with other senior leaders.",
"Greedy candidate": "South Sudan's president and deputy ministers have been sacked, a government official says.",
"Beam candidate": "South Sudan's deputy ministers and vice-presidents have been sacked in a row over the government, the BBC has learned.",
"Top-p candidate": "South Sudan's top ministers and deputy ministers have been sacked and an Aydhya Enron official says the sackings have lent hope that their involvement in South Sudan may be a decisive blow to the country's political bloc."
},
{
"Entry ID": 63,
"Input": "summarize: Officers said a \"huge recovery\" of what were believed to be controlled substances were recovered in a pre-planned operation in Staffordshire. Properties in Manchester, Essex and London are also being searched. The suspects are currently in custody and being questioned on suspicion of conspiracy to supply Class A drugs. They include four men from London, aged 25, 28, 29 and 56, a 45-year-old man from Northolt, two men from Poland, aged 32 and 48, and a 44-year-old man from the Netherlands. The raids on Friday evening involved officers from the Titan North West Regional Crime Unit and the National Crime Agency.",
"Gold reference": "Eight men have been arrested on suspicion of drugs offences after three vehicles were stopped on the M6 motorway.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man has been arrested in a raid on a drug supply in the UK, police have said.",
"Beam candidate": "Two men have been arrested on suspicion of supply of cocaine and heroin in a pre-planned operation in Staffordshire.",
"Top-p candidate": "Police on suspicion of drugs bombing raids have seized explosives as part of a government raid."
},
{
"Entry ID": 64,
"Input": "summarize: The Republic of Ireland currently has strict abortion laws, which only allow a pregnancy to be terminated if there is a serious risk to a woman's life. The Citizens' Assembly voted 64% to 36% in favour of having no restrictions. Anti-abortion groups have condemned the result of the vote, but any change to the law would require a referendum. The Citizens' Assembly was set up by the Oireachtas (Irish Houses of Parliament) to advise elected representatives on a number of ethical and political dilemmas facing the Irish people. These include abortion, climate change and how the Republic of Ireland deals with the challenge of providing for its aging population. The body is made up of 99 members who were chosen at random to broadly represent the views of the Irish electorate. Its most controversial task was to consider a campaign to repeal the Eighth Amendment of the Irish Constitution - which gives an equal right to life to a pregnant woman and an unborn child. Assembly members held 10 days of intensive and emotive debates over the past five months, culminating in this weekend's series of votes. On Saturday, members voted against repealing the Eighth Amendment, but they did support change - voting to amend or replace the law. On Sunday, a majority of Citizens' Assembly members approved 13 separate grounds for legal terminations in the Republic of Ireland. Of the votes cast, 89% were in favour of allowing abortion on grounds of rape or fatal foetal abnormality - when doctors believe an unborn child is likely to die before, during or shortly after birth. There was less support for legal terminations for \"socio-economic reasons\" but still, 72% of members who took part voted in favour of abortion in those circumstances. However, anti-abortion campaigners dismissed the results of the ballots as a \"muddled and confused farce\". Cora Sherlock of the Pro Life Campaign accused the assembly of having a \"chaotic\" and \"one-sided approach\" in how it conducted its business from the beginning. She added: \"There is nothing liberal or progressive about the assembly recommending a referendum to strip unborn babies of their right to life in law and also ignoring the negative consequences of abortion for women.\" The Citizens' Assembly is chaired by the Supreme Court judge, Ms Justice Mary Laffoy, who will now present a report on members' recommendations to the Oireachtas by late June. In a statement, the chair said members had \"reached a conclusion of sorts\" and she thanked them for having \"engaged with some of the most complex pieces of legislation, immersed themselves in medical and ethical discourse, and listened with respect to the voices and opinions of others\". \"I also wish to acknowledge those whose perspectives or opinions did not emerge in the final vote,\" the judge added. \"This is an exercise in deliberative democracy and their vote remains important to me because of the very fact it captures that other perspective, that dissenting voice, the different interpretation and I wish to assure them that their votes and voices will be recorded and have a place in the report.\" On receipt of her report, elected representatives will consider members' calls for a change in the law, and whether or not to hold a referendum.",
"Gold reference": "A public forum that advises the Irish government on constitutional issues has voted to recommend the introduction of unrestricted access to abortion.",
"Greedy candidate": "The Citizens' Assembly has voted to repeal the Eighth Amendment of the Irish Constitution, which gives an equal right to life to a pregnant woman and an unborn child.",
"Beam candidate": "The Citizens' Assembly has voted to repeal the Eighth Amendment of the Irish Constitution, which gives an equal right to life to pregnant women and unborn children.",
"Top-p candidate": "The constitutional amendment to the Republic of Ireland's existing ban on abortion will not be allowed until the Republic of Ireland releases it on 30 March."
},
{
"Entry ID": 65,
"Input": "summarize: Gatland says Henry indicated to his players at the outset of the trip of Australia who would be selected for the Test matches. He says that meant his compatriot \"lost half the team on day one\". \"The players knew straight away what was the Test side and who was making up the numbers,\" said the New Zealander. Gatland, who on Wednesday named his side to face the Provincial Barbarians in the tour opener on Saturday, says each of his 41-man squad is in contention to face the All Blacks. \"Keeping harmony in the squad is paramount,\" he said. \"It's about giving everyone an opportunity. \"It's important these guys feel like they are putting themselves in the shop window and have a chance to prove themselves, and with a little bit of luck are in contention for the Tests. Media playback is not supported on this device Owen Farrell and Johnny Sexton appear to be in competition for the fly-half spot after Gatland reiterated he sees the Englishman as a \"world-class 10\", rather than a centre. Irishman Sexton starts on Saturday, with Farrell on the bench. \"The players are pretty aware about the competition in that position,\" Gatland said. \"Johnny gets a start on Saturday, and the other two [Farrell and Dan Biggar] will get a start in the next two games.\" Gatland's son Bryn will start for the Provincial Barbarians at fly-half. \"I spoke to Bryn last night and he's enjoying the week,\" Gatland Sr said. \"We'll catch up tomorrow, and he'll expect to have to make a few tackles on the weekend. \"We haven't spoken too much about the game but he's excited about the opportunity.\"",
"Gold reference": "British and Irish Lions head coach Warren Gatland says he will not repeat Graham Henry's 2001 mistake by splitting the squad early in the tour.",
"Greedy candidate": "England's Henry Gatland says he has a \"very good week\" ahead of the Tests, but says he is \"enjoyed\" by the opportunity.",
"Beam candidate": "England's Henry Gatland says he is confident his side are in contention to face the All Blacks in the Tests.",
"Top-p candidate": "A New Zealander says his team is \"summarising the number of families taking part in the Tests\" on a tour of Australia."
},
{
"Entry ID": 66,
"Input": "summarize: The body of Kimberley Jones, 25, was found by a paramedic at the house in Cwmbach, Aberdare, on 9 August, 2013. Mother-of-one Ms Jones was due to move into the house the following day, but was allowed to stay the night before. Tests on the fire showed the flue was ineffective allowing smoke to leak into the room, the Aberdare inquest heard. During those tests carbon monoxide gas was at 16 times the acceptable level. Ms Jones' father, Andrew Jones, told the inquest he knew the owner of the house, Ms Linda Parfitt, as a family friend for 25 years and he arranged to buy the house from her to use as a home for his daughter. Ms Parfitt left the property at the start of the week and Mr Jones was decorating it that week. He said he stayed there for two nights to keep the house secure. His daughter, who worked as a care worker, was due to stay there on Thursday 8 August, but Mr Jones said he had woken up cold the previous morning so decided to light the fire. He told the inquest that he told his daughter to keep a window open as he did not want her to die from carbon monoxide poisoning. He said: \"That will haunt me for the rest of my days.\" Mr Jones said his wife called him the following morning as she could not contact their daughter. He said he went to the house but the emergency services were already there. He told the coroner he identified his daughter's body later that day. Plumbing inspector Howard Reed told the coroner the fire was dirty with a lot of soot and debris. Tests showed its window and door leaked smoke and carbon monoxide tests found that after two hours there were 829 parts per million (ppm) of the gas in the room. A domestic carbon monoxide alarm would sound at about 50 ppm and levels of between 600 and 750ppm are likely to cause fatalities, the hearing was told. Debris on the fire's throat plate, which is used to restrict airflow, was blocking the flue and Mr Reed estimated it had not been removed for \"many years\". The owner of the house at the time, Ms Parfitt, told the inquest that she and her ex-partner arranged for the fire to be installed. Ms Parfitt told the inquest that a vent in the living room had been there prior to moving into the house. She said that she did not inspect it and could not explain how a magazine cover found its way into the grill opening. When shown a picture of smoke coming from the fire during the inspection after Ms Jones died, Miss Parfitt told the coroner: \"I've never seen smoke coming out of it like that - I'm sure about that.\" The inquest has now been adjourned until later in the year.",
"Gold reference": "The flue of a coal fire at the home of a woman suspected to have died from carbon monoxide poisoning was blocked, an inquest has heard.",
"Greedy candidate": "A family friend who stayed at a house in Aberdare for two nights has been found dead.",
"Beam candidate": "The body of a woman who died from carbon monoxide poisoning has been found in an Aberdare house.",
"Top-p candidate": "A house owned by a family friend who was due to take his daughter to the hospital to breathe in a shot of carbon monoxide gas has been found."
},
{
"Entry ID": 67,
"Input": "summarize: The Department for Transport said up to 60 trains, capable of speeds of about 225mph, were needed. The contract, which will also involve maintaining the fleet, will be awarded in 2019. The trains are for the first phase of the project, due to open in 2026 and run between London and Birmingham. Construction will begin later this year and it is expected to reduce rail times between Birmingham and London by 32 minutes. A second Y-shaped phase of HS2 will open in two stages. The line from Birmingham to Crewe will launch in 2027, with the remaining construction - which includes a spur taking HS2 to a new station at Manchester Airport - due to finish six years later. There will be separate contracts in the future to supply trains for this phase. Transport secretary Chris Grayling said the new railway would carry more than 300,000 people a day. \"Hundreds of jobs will be created in building and maintaining these trains, representing a great opportunity for British-based businesses and suppliers. \"In total 25,000 jobs and 2,000 apprenticeships will be created during HS2 construction and we have held discussions with UK suppliers to make sure they are in the best possible position to win contracts,\" he added. Friday's launch comes ahead of a formal start of the process in spring 2017, when companies interested in bidding can learn more about the process. Formal invitations to tender will be made in 2018. Hitachi Rail Europe said it will bid for the contract to build the HS2 trains. The rail manufacturer is headquartered in London and builds trains at its plant in Newton Aycliffe in County Durham. Its sales director, Nick Hughes, said: \"Our HS2 trains would be built in Britain, for Britain, and combine world-leading Japanese Shinkansen technology with British manufacturing know-how.\" Gordon Wakeford, managing director of Siemens Mobility, said a manufacturing contract of this scale was \"exciting news\" for the rail industry and would have a \"positive impact on the wider UK supply chain\". The company had recently \"ramped up\" its HS2 activity with the appointment of two executives to lead the HS2 rolling stock bid team, he added. HS2 has been dogged by controversy, with critics saying the scheme poses a threat to swathes of English countryside.",
"Gold reference": "The search for a company to take on the \u00a32.75bn contract to build high speed trains for the HS2 rail network got underway on Friday.",
"Greedy candidate": "A new HS2 line has been built in the UK to build a new railway.",
"Beam candidate": "Plans to build a new HS2 train line between Birmingham and Crewe have been announced.",
"Top-p candidate": "Work to build a new high-speed railway will be completed by the end of 2016."
},
{
"Entry ID": 68,
"Input": "summarize: Though the unverified story was short on details, and did not have the husband's side of the story, \"divorced because of fat face\" quickly became a top trend on microblogging network Weibo. State media picked up the story on Thursday, which was first reported in a local evening paper earlier this week. Liaoshen Wanbao reported the 49-year-old woman in Shenyang city had claimed her husband had divorced her 10 years ago because he disliked the shape of her face, said to be \"large and square\" with \"fat cheeks\". She said it spurred her to undergo facial surgery three times at a local hospital to shave her jawbones and reshape her face into a slimmer shape. During the third surgery the doctors discovered that if they proceeded further her nerves may be damaged, and halted the procedure. The woman, identified only by her surname Wang, later sued the hospital for 1.7 million yuan ($260,900; \u00c2\u00a3183,900) in damages. She alleged the surgery had left her with soreness in her chin, and she could only eat and drink through a straw as \"when she exerted force on her lower jaw, she had the sensation that it would break\". The hospital, however, argued that the surgeries were conducted according to regulations, and pointed out that they encouraged her to seek psychiatric help instead of a third operation, which she refused. After mediation the woman agreed to accept 20,000 yuan ($3,100, \u00c2\u00a32,200) as compensation, said the report. On Weibo, some condemned the woman's husband, but others also chastised the woman. One top-voted comment read: \"It's purely an excuse, if her face was large then why did he decide to marry her in the first place? If he stopped loving her then he should have just said so.\" It continued: \"This woman is also very silly to have believed that her face shape was the real reason for the divorce, she is lying to herself.\" Said another Weibo user: \"Even if you had gone for facial surgery and made your face smaller, he would still have found other reasons to divorce you.\" One person noted the sharp difference in the compensation amount and voiced suspicions: \"1.7 million was dropped to 20,000, it makes me wonder if she really did have a problem with her jaw.\" Still others took the opportunity to crack jokes. \"What an odd reason for divorce! I wonder how square was this woman's square-shaped face? Like a television set? Microwave oven?\" Plastic surgery has long been a hot topic on Weibo. In December, users similarly expressed outrage when a Chinese man took out a newspaper advertisement pleading for his wife to go for plastic surgery. More than seven million cosmetic surgeries were performed in China in 2014. The industry's value, pegged at around 400bn yuan, is expected to double by 2019, according to the China Association of Plastics and Aesthetics.",
"Gold reference": "A report about a woman who said she had repeated plastic surgery after her husband divorced her because she had a \"fat face\" has sparked outrage among China's online community.",
"Greedy candidate": "A woman in China has been accused of having a \"fat face\" after a woman's husband divorced her 10 years ago.",
"Beam candidate": "A woman who claimed her husband divorced her 10 years ago says she was \"divorced because of fat face\".",
"Top-p candidate": "A woman in Shenyang has slashed her face after meeting a doctor in an alleged embarrassment."
},
{
"Entry ID": 69,
"Input": "summarize: Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary said some forces are \"downgrading\" 999 calls, in order to justify responding to them more slowly. HMIC's report found that most of the 43 forces in England and Wales were providing a good service. But that others have let victims down. The inspectors said there are now too few detectives and in some areas an erosion of neighbourhood policing. The former chief constable of Greater Manchester Police, Sir Peter Fahy, said that forces will have to do things differently in the future, if the government continues to ask them \"to do more with less\". In its annual report on forces, the inspectors said officers were arresting fewer people and too many crimes were being shelved without proper investigation. It found that 67,000 people suspected of crimes were not entered onto the police national computer - so that all forces were made aware of them. The report highlighted measures some forces had deployed to manage demand - although in each case it was not entirely clear whether they were directly caused by cuts or local management decisions. HMIC said: \"We are leading to a very serious conclusion regarding the potentially perilous state of British policing,\" said Zoe Billingham, the lead inspector. \"Over the last few years, HMIC has said consistently that police forces were managing well in increasingly difficult circumstances. \"Nonetheless, today, I'm raising a red flag to warn forces of the consequences of what is, to all intents and purposes, an unconscious form of rationing.\" Rated \"Outstanding\": Durham Rated \"Good\": Avon & Somerset, Cambridgeshire, Cheshire, City of London, Cleveland, Cumbria, Derbyshire, Dorset, Essex, Greater Manchester, Gwent, Kent, Lancashire, Lincolnshire, Merseyside, Norfolk, North Wales, North Yorkshire, Northumbria, South Wales, Suffolk, Surrey, Thames Valley, Warwickshire, West Mercia, West Midlands, West Yorkshire and Wiltshire. Rated \"Requires Improvement\": Devon & Cornwall, Dyfed-Powys, Gloucestershire, Hampshire, Hertfordshire, Humberside, Leicestershire, Metropolitan Police, Northamptonshire, Nottinghamshire, South Yorkshire, Staffordshire and Sussex Rated \"Inadequate\": Bedfordshire HMIC also warned there was now a \"national crisis\" caused by a shortage of detectives - with the Metropolitan Police alone short by 700. One ex-detective has told the Victoria Derbyshire programme why she quit her \"dream job\". These shortages had led to excessive workloads and stress for investigators who were sometimes carrying out complex investigations without the right skills and experience. In one area, inspectors found a uniformed officer carrying out a rape investigation. HMIC has urged police chiefs to come up with a plan by the summer to attract, recruit and train more detectives. Ms Billingham warned that while neighbourhood teams were the \"bedrock of British policing\" they were being \"chipped away... sometimes by stealth\". A survey of neighbourhood officers found they were being pulled from local duties at least once a week to supervise the detention or transport of suspects. A fifth of the officers said they could find themselves on other duties three times a week. One police officer resigned last week after 13 years in the Devon and Cornwall, publishing a damning resignation letter on social media criticising police for \"putting their employees last\". Dr Alan Billings, South Yorkshire police and crime commissioner, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: \"I don't think I've ever read a report from the Inspectorate that was quite as sobering as this.\" Dr Billings said there was \"no doubt\" that neighbourhood policing was under pressure, adding: \"I think that's true of my own area - because if people are really pressured to answer 999 calls, deal with incidents, they're going to pull officers out of neighbourhood areas.\" He said HMIC's report reflects what is happening across the public sector. \"You can't get away from the fact that all of us are now trying to do more and better with less. \"And year on year, we're receiving less funding. Now of course a police force cannot run a deficit - so you have to make the books balance, and that leads sometimes to poor decisions.\" Chief Constable Michael Barton of the National Police Chiefs' Council, said budgets had fallen by 22% in five years - leading to a loss of 32,000 officers and staff - at a time when many crimes were changing. \"It's a simple reality that we are required to prioritise more,\" he said. \"Difficult decisions are being made between resourcing neighbourhood teams, response units, specialist investigations and digital and cyber-enabled crime. There are no easy answers.\" Ms Billingham said the failings were \"not simply about money\" because there was a huge variation in results, in particular in how well forces were winning the support of domestic violence victims in how they investigated and concluded cases. Policing Minister Brandon Lewis said: \"This Government has protected police funding, through the 2015 spending review. \"There can be no excuse for any force that fails to deliver on its obligations. Those identified as inadequate or requiring improvement must take HMIC's findings very seriously and I expect to see rapid improvement But the Police Federation, which represents rank-and-file members, described the report as a \"worrying wake-up call\". And Jon Boutcher, chief constable of Bedfordshire, criticised his force's rating as inadequate, saying community policing had to change because of the huge demand for specialist officers to deal with domestic abuse, sexual offences and the rising threat of online-related crimes.",
"Gold reference": "Some police forces are putting the public at risk by rationing their response as they struggle with cutbacks, the police standards watchdog has warned.",
"Greedy candidate": "Police forces in England and Wales are \"disappointed\" by the government's decision to force more than 999 calls, a report has found.",
"Beam candidate": "Police forces in England and Wales have been unable to respond to 999 calls, a report has found.",
"Top-p candidate": "Intractable orders for police forces and contractors under threat in the future - to be blamed in England and Wales - have been warned of a potentially perilous state."
},
{
"Entry ID": 70,
"Input": "summarize: Some have asked to remain anonymous so have only given their first names. The minute's silence went relatively well because we only had two incidents. The pupils involved showed reticence so they had a chat with the civics teachers. The school was at the heart of the events, close to the Charlie Hebdo offices. One of my students heard the shots being fired by the Kouachi brothers. Many of our pupils skateboard in Place de la Republique. It all meant a lot to them. They needed to make sense what had happened. We discussed the issues: it was the first act of war in Paris for a long time. We talked about caricatures, blasphemy, freedom of speech. A few loudmouths said: \"They [Charlie Hebdo] were asking for it.\" We discussed this in class and some of them ultimately revised their opinion. So what we had was mostly blustering. It was very spontaneous. On the Thursday morning I saw some of my final-year students as I came in. They asked me for adhesive tape because they wanted to make banners. They took the initiative very quickly. They went to see the head teacher to get authorisation for their plan. They made a speech to younger students after the minute of silence on Friday, then demonstrated across the city, and of course took part in the main [unity] rally on Sunday. The initial reaction was one of unanimous revulsion among pupils. On the Thursday everyone agreed that you don't kill people because you are offended by drawings, regardless of your beliefs. On the Friday, frictions started to creep in. Then there was the mass \"Je suis Charlie\" demonstration at the weekend. When the pupils returned to school on the Monday, the disruption began. Two pupils found conspiracy theories on the internet: The Kouachi brothers were innocent\u00e2\u20ac\u00a6 Wasn't it strange that police had found the ID card left in the car? It was obviously a plot by intelligence services\u00e2\u20ac\u00a6 I asked what purpose there could be in killing people of various ethnicities and religions. They came back with the answer: \"To sully Islam.\" I was surprised because those two boys of North African origin had never said that sort of thing. But they were defiant. I represented the official version, and they had access to a hidden truth. Problems in the school system run deep. Courses on the Enlightenment, for instance, can be a problem. In a class last week I was analysing an article by Voltaire on religious fanaticism, which is on the national curriculum. As I was talking, the pupils were listening so intently that there was silence. Suddenly two of them made increasingly loud snoring noises that ended up covering my voice. Secularism is not the only sensitive issue. It is also difficult to teach colonial wars. You will be challenged, some will whistle or hum to stop you talking. You will be accused of dishing out propaganda. I noticed an abrupt change in 2001, when I was teaching in an immigrant suburb. My students refused to observe a minute's silence for the victims of 9/11. The most radical among them started singing Hamas songs. I was a young teacher and did not know what to do. Discipline is a big problem. When people talk in class and the teacher tells them to be quiet, a common retort is: \"I'm not talking to you\" - meaning you're interrupting my conversation. What plays against me is that I am a woman - some pupils will not respect me. If I have two or three troublemakers per class here, I can only imagine what it must be like for my colleagues who have remained in deprived suburbs. Boosting civics courses and encouraging pupils to sing the Marseillaise (as the education minister suggested following 200 reported incidents during the minute's silence) does not go nearly far enough to tackle the underlying problems. When I heard pupils recycling conspiracy theories after the Charlie Hebdo attacks, it reminded me of 9/11. The very next day, on 12 September, a boy said in class that Jews were behind the attack. He knew this because there were no Jews in the twin towers at the time. I said: \"You must be really smart! We still don't know the number of victims, but you already have the list, with their religion.\" Everybody laughed. The kid felt a bit silly and I defused the situation that way. When I am confronted with that sort of thing I now use texts by Hitler, Stalin, Bin Laden and other classics of the conspiracy genre to show the similarities between their visions of the world: a hidden elite is pulling the strings - often the same people incidentally. And I show that such ideas have serious consequences: tens of millions of people killed in the case of Nazism and Stalinism. It can be tricky teaching some subjects - such as the Holocaust, colonial wars, or the Middle East - but this is mostly a problem of teacher training. When a kid tells you a genocide has been committed by the French in Algeria or by the Israelis in Gaza, you have to refer to the official definition of a genocide and see whether its applies. You are going to be challenged: background knowledge and a good relationship with pupils are vital to meet that challenge. Today teachers are competing with other sources of information - notably social networks and the internet. Teachers are no longer the ultimate source of knowledge. So you have to be extremely strong on learning in order to have authority. And if there is an emotional bond with the pupils, you can deliver any message. On the Thursday (a day after the Charlie Hebdo attack) I was shaken by what I had seen on TV. I spoke to the head teacher, who gave me permission to post a \"Je suis Charlie\" banner in my classroom. But he also said something that surprised me: he would not force teachers to enforce the minute's silence (declared by the education minister) on the Friday. He had anticipated problems - but I had not. I could not imagine that pupils would not observe a minute's silence. Then I faced my class of 14 to 15-year-olds, with whom I have a wonderful relationship. I asked how they felt about the events of the previous day, without giving my own reaction. Their response hit me in the guts: \"Miss, the journalists got what was coming to them\"; \"You should not mock the Prophet.\" Only the Muslim pupils spoke - about a third of the class. The others did not say a word. When they saw the tear on my face, they held back: they did not want to upset me. In my younger class, they were even more virulent. \"When you receive death threats you have to stop what you are doing,\" they said. On the Friday they all observed the minute's silence, but I did not feel it was out of respect for the victims - but out of respect for me. Some of my colleagues who do not have that sort of relationship with their pupils had problems; others did not observe it at all. More recently, a boy mimicked the killings in a corridor, firing an imaginary Kalashnikov and shouting \"Allahu Akbar\" (God is great, in Arabic). I thought the battle of secularism had been won, and that after several years in school they had absorbed all this. But I now realise that this is not the case. But I will not give up. I will continue to fight for my convictions. I am a daughter and granddaughter of teachers: secularism and the values of the Republic are in my genes. If there were more teachers like me - more teachers who believe in what they do and stop looking the other way, things would be better.",
"Gold reference": "Here teachers in France tell the BBC about their struggles to assert the country's traditional values of free expression and secularism in the wake of the Charlie Hebdo attacks.",
"Greedy candidate": "The school system was a mess.",
"Beam candidate": "The moment of silence went relatively well because we only had two incidents, and the pupils involved showed reticence.",
"Top-p candidate": "Filmed by the Canadians, the school had a history that it combines the basics for a class. It even left us with an inspiration for the culture of the public and the history of the English culture, about school life."
},
{
"Entry ID": 71,
"Input": "summarize: The blast happened in a cafe in the town of Velez-Malaga at about 17:00 GMT during a local festival. Pictures from the scene show severe damage to the La Bohemia cafe and debris strewn across a street. Local newspaper La Opinion de Malaga said that the chef had raised the alarm moments before the blast. The newspaper also reported (in Spanish) that police cars helped ferry the injured to hospital because the local ambulance service was overwhelmed with casualties. The cause of the blast \"could have been a gas leak,\" the town's mayor, Antonio Moreno Ferrer, told local reporters.",
"Gold reference": "More than 70 people have been injured, four seriously, in an explosion caused by a suspected gas leak near the southern Spanish city of Malaga.",
"Greedy candidate": "A chef has raised alarm after a fire broke out in a cafe in the town of La Bohemia.",
"Beam candidate": "A chef has raised the alarm after a blaze broke out in the La Bohemia cafe.",
"Top-p candidate": "A chef has raised the alarm at a Spanish-language newspaper which reported on the death of his five-year-old son in a fire on his car."
},
{
"Entry ID": 72,
"Input": "summarize: Daniel Filmus, Argentina's minister for the islands - called the Malvinas locally - announced the case in London. The companies involved are Falkland Oil and Gas, Premier Oil, Rockhopper, Edison International and Noble Energy. Mr Filmus told the BBC the companies were \"performing illegal acts by entering Argentine territory\". He added: \"I want to make it clear for the directors of these companies and for British public opinion that Argentina will use the full force of the law - both national and international law - to prevent these countries from taking the riches which belong to 40 million Argentine citizens. \"Argentina has extradition treaties around the world and we intend to use them.\" He added that the area being drilled was \"as much ours as the centre of Buenos Aires. Neither the UK nor any other country would allow anyone to enter their territory and take away their riches.\" In response, UK Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond accused the Argentines of \"outrageous bullying\". He said the islanders had a \"perfect right to develop their own economic resources and Argentina needs to stop this kind of behaviour and start acting like a responsible member of the international community\". The Falklands Islands government also said the Argentines had no case. \"We have the right to develop our economy, including the hydrocarbons industry, and we are exercising that right,\" it said. \"It is worth remembering that it was the government of Argentina who walked away from working with the Falkland Islands on the development of a hydrocarbons industry some years ago. \"Argentine domestic law does not apply to the Falkland Islands and this latest action is clearly another attempt by Argentina to try to block economic growth in the Falkland Islands.\" Analysts suggested Argentina would have little joy in the courts. \"The Argentines will lose,\" Malcolm Bracken at Redmayne Bentley told the BBC. \"They have no jurisdiction - the UN settled the matter in 1982.\" In fact, he said the country's current position would prove counterproductive. \"All they're doing is handing any possible benefit that Argentina may have had from the oil boom in the south Atlantic to Chile. \"There'd be an awful lot of logistic support needed for drilling that simply isn't available in the Falklands. They'd need a port somewhere and that's likely to be near Chile rather than Argentina, so they're cutting their own nose off to spite their face.\" Earlier this month, Argentine foreign ministry officials said they would prosecute oil companies operating near the Falkland Islands. The officials said companies active there were operating illegally in Argentine territory. This came after the three British oil companies announced new oil and gas finds north of the islands, and as Argentina marked the 33rd anniversary of the war with the UK over the islands. Tensions between the UK and Argentina were already running high after the UK announced it would spend \u00c2\u00a3280m over the next 10 years on improving defences on the islands.",
"Gold reference": "Argentina has begun legal proceedings against three British and two US companies for drilling oil near the Falkland Islands.",
"Greedy candidate": "Argentina's government will use the law to prevent the country from taking the riches of 40 million Argentine citizens, the BBC has learned.",
"Beam candidate": "Argentines have been accused of illegally entering the Falkland Islands, the BBC has learned.",
"Top-p candidate": "A UK government, whose director says they're an opposition government, has been arrested in an attempt to \"force Argentina to develop and try to block economic growth in the Falklands\"."
},
{
"Entry ID": 73,
"Input": "summarize: The Spiders' David Galt headed against the outside of the post before Shire took the lead. Thomas Orr took advantage of Bryan Wharton's poor header to burst through on goal and finish past William Muir. David McKenna doubled the advantage from close range and Scott Ferries' effort completed the win.",
"Gold reference": "East Stirlingshire moved off the bottom of Scottish League Two with a surprise victory over promotion-chasing Queen's Park.",
"Greedy candidate": "Shire extended their lead in the first half as they beat the defending champions Shire.",
"Beam candidate": "Shire extended their lead at the top of the Scottish Premiership with a 3-0 win over Sheffield Wednesday.",
"Top-p candidate": "Smithball and Red Devils ended their three-match losing campaign as they were beaten to claim their first win since winning a friendly in Benedikt."
},
{
"Entry ID": 74,
"Input": "summarize: The crash happened at about 14:15 BST on the B1191 at Thornton, near Woodhall Spa. Lincolnshire Police said the motorcyclist killed in the collision lived locally, but has not released any further details. The tractor driver was not injured. The force has appealed for witnesses to the collision to come forward. The B1191 was closed in both directions between the B1192 Tattershall Road junction in Woodhall Spa and the A158 Jubilee Way junction in Horncastle",
"Gold reference": "A man has died in a collision between a tractor and a motorcycle in Lincolnshire.",
"Greedy candidate": "A tractor driver has died after a tractor crash in Lincolnshire.",
"Beam candidate": "A tractor driver has died in a crash in Lincolnshire.",
"Top-p candidate": "A tractor driver has died after an tractor driver and a tractor driver were killed."
},
{
"Entry ID": 75,
"Input": "summarize: Saints - the last visiting team to win at Ibrox 13 months ago - took the lead early on when Blair Alston curled in a fantastic strike. Joe Garner headed Rangers level from a corner before the break. The visitors had several chances in the second half with Alston firing against the post while Garner had a header saved for the hosts. With Aberdeen defeated at Hamilton Academical on Tuesday and Hearts beaten at Kilmarnock, Saints could have gone second with victory but instead they go level on points with the second-placed Dons, albeit having played a game more. Rangers, having taken 16 points from a possible 30 since being promoted, stay fifth edging to within a point of Hearts. The Ibrox side have won only two of their home league games this season, having also dropped points to Hamilton and Ross County. Mark Warburton's side had improved defensively in recent weeks with clean sheets in league wins over Partick Thistle and Inverness. However, with Wes Foderingham resuming goalkeeping duties from Matt Gilks - Rangers' best player in the 1-0 Scottish League Cup semi-final defeat by Celtic - the Ibrox side found themselves a goal down early on to Saints as Alston picked his spot after robbing Lee Hodson for his first Saints goal. Tommy Wright engineered an away win over Rangers in last season's League Cup when the hosts - then in the Championship - bringing an end to a 11-game winning sequence. And the Northern Irishman's team had several opportunities to go back in front early in the second half with Brian Easton, Liam Craig, Danny Swanson and Chris Kane all going close before Alston fired against a post. Garner had netted just once since his summer move from Preston North End but the striker broke his Ibrox duck with a headed finish off Harry Forrester's corner, having gone close from a similar situation moments before. And Garner threatened to nod Rangers ahead on 74 minutes but could not beat Zander Clark, who made good first-half saves to deny Jason Holt and Josh Windass. Warburton sought fresh impetus in attack with the introduction of Martyn Waghorn, Kenny Miller and Barrie McKay off the bench but St Johnstone held firm with David Wotherspoon clearing a Miller effort off the line. Rangers' Mark Warburton: \"It was a decent first half but we didn't continue that and we gave the ball away cheaply. \"We weren't brave getting out, despite the possession stats we didn't play the way we wanted to. \"It's a demanding crowd because they're used to success. The players have to recognise it's an expectant crowd - and quite rightly. We have to respect that and learn from that.\" St Johnstone's Tommy Wright: \"It's never easy coming here. We're happy to take a point but we could have taken all three as we had a few good chances in the second half. \"We knew we'd stay above Rangers with a positive result. We're content with the return but there are no prizes given out so we're not going to get carried away with it.\" Match ends, Rangers 1, St. Johnstone 1. Second Half ends, Rangers 1, St. Johnstone 1. Rob Kiernan (Rangers) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul. Foul by Rob Kiernan (Rangers). Liam Craig (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Attempt blocked. Kenny Miller (Rangers) left footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked. Corner, Rangers. Conceded by Joe Shaughnessy. Andy Halliday (Rangers) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Paul Paton (St. Johnstone) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul. Foul by Paul Paton (St. Johnstone). Corner, St. Johnstone. Conceded by Clint Hill. Corner, Rangers. Conceded by Paul Paton. Substitution, St. Johnstone. David Wotherspoon replaces Chris Millar. Substitution, Rangers. Martyn Waghorn replaces Joe Garner. Foul by Rob Kiernan (Rangers). Steven Anderson (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Corner, Rangers. Conceded by Richard Foster. Kenny Miller (Rangers) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Foul by Richard Foster (St. Johnstone). Attempt missed. Kenny Miller (Rangers) header from the centre of the box misses to the left. Attempt missed. Liam Craig (St. Johnstone) left footed shot from the left side of the box is high and wide to the left. Corner, St. Johnstone. Conceded by Lee Hodson. Foul by Rob Kiernan (Rangers). Danny Swanson (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Attempt blocked. Lee Wallace (Rangers) left footed shot from outside the box is blocked. Corner, Rangers. Conceded by Danny Swanson. Substitution, Rangers. Barrie McKay replaces Harry Forrester. Attempt missed. Blair Alston (St. Johnstone) right footed shot from the centre of the box is close, but misses to the right. Attempt saved. Andy Halliday (Rangers) left footed shot from outside the box is saved in the centre of the goal. Attempt saved. Joe Garner (Rangers) header from the centre of the box is saved in the top right corner. Corner, Rangers. Conceded by Zander Clark. Joe Garner (Rangers) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Foul by Joe Shaughnessy (St. Johnstone). Corner, Rangers. Conceded by Blair Alston. Foul by Rob Kiernan (Rangers). Graham Cummins (St. Johnstone) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Substitution, St. Johnstone. Graham Cummins replaces Christopher Kane. Attempt missed. Harry Forrester (Rangers) right footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses to the left. Andy Halliday (Rangers) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Foul by Christopher Kane (St. Johnstone).",
"Gold reference": "Rangers and St Johnstone had to settle for a point each after a Scottish Premiership draw in Glasgow.",
"Greedy candidate": "Mark Warburton's side moved to the top of the Scottish League Cup with a 1-0 win over Rangers.",
"Beam candidate": "Brendan Rodgers scored a hat-trick as Rangers beat Hearts in the Scottish League Cup semi-finals.",
"Top-p candidate": "Daniel Craig scored three minutes as Rangers beat Rangers 3-0 on penalties to win a Women's League Two clash with Hearts."
},
{
"Entry ID": 76,
"Input": "summarize: Francisco Palomo was shot at least 12 times by gunmen in Guatemala City. Mr Palomo, 63, defended Gen Rios Montt against charges connected to the killing of more than 1,700 indigenous Guatemalans in the 1980s. The general was sentenced to 80 years in prison two years ago but his conviction was overturned. A retrial scheduled for January has been postponed indefinitely because of a legal dispute. Mr Palomo was shot in the chest and face while driving his car at about midday on Wednesday, emergency services spokesman Raul Hernandez said. Witnesses said the gunmen were on a motorcycle. \"The victim, still alive, tried to flee the attack and drove a few metres before crashing into a tree,\" Mr Hernandez said. The motive for the killing is still not clear.",
"Gold reference": "A lawyer who represented former Guatemalan military leader Efrain Rios Montt against genocide charges has been shot dead.",
"Greedy candidate": "A Guatemalan general has been jailed for killing a general in the 1980s, a police spokesman says.",
"Beam candidate": "A Guatemalan general has been sentenced to eight years in prison after he was shot in the chest and face by gunmen.",
"Top-p candidate": "A Guatemalan general has been retold to police on charges he killed a man in the end of the 1980s, police say."
},
{
"Entry ID": 77,
"Input": "summarize: The 24-hour Underground service was originally scheduled for September, but was delayed over a dispute about pay and conditions. Following the breakdown of talks on Wednesday, union leaders said the launch would not happen this year. But during a trip to Japan Mr Johnson said: \"We are going to have a Night Tube eventually.\" He had previously said he was \"relaxed\" about when the service was introduced, as long as it happened before the end of autumn. Mr Johnson said during a business visit to Japan: \"We'll do a Night Tube and obviously I hope very much that the offer on the table, which is a very good one, is now communicated properly to the workforce of London Underground and I think we should just get on with it. \"We've done without it for 150 years and I'm sure we can rub along a little bit longe,r but we are going to have a Night Tube eventually.\" Unions took industrial action during the summer having called for increased pay and a limit on how many all-night shifts their members would be asked to do. As negotiations between the unions and London Underground came to a halt, Finn Brennan from drivers' union Aslef, said discussions had broken up because LU management had \"mishandled\" the process.",
"Gold reference": "London mayor Boris Johnson has backed away from a timetable for the opening of the city's Night Tube.",
"Greedy candidate": "London Underground unions have launched a night tube service to help workers in the city of London.",
"Beam candidate": "London Underground unions have announced plans to launch a night tube service in Japan.",
"Top-p candidate": "London Underground has offered more than \u00a325,000 to push the full 30 hours of dance underground trains for months."
},
{
"Entry ID": 78,
"Input": "summarize: Pools, who were relegated from the English Football League last season, lost their opening game at home to Dover on Saturday but started well at Moss Rose, with Cassidy and Jack Munns both firing inches wide. Macclesfield hit back, with Danny Whitaker's volleyed effort superbly tipped away by goalkeeper Scott Loach. The home side took the lead in the 38th minute when Elliott Durrell's ball into the box was headed home by Whitaker. There was a let-off for Hartlepool at the start of the second half when a mistake from defender Scott Harrison set Tyrone Marsh clear but he shot straight at Loach. Pools levelled after 58 minutes when Cassidy nodded in a cross from Ryan Donaldson and came closest to winning it when the striker's flicked header was saved. Match report supplied by the Press Association. Match ends, Macclesfield Town 1, Hartlepool United 1. Second Half ends, Macclesfield Town 1, Hartlepool United 1. Substitution, Macclesfield Town. Koby Arthur replaces Elliott Durrell. Substitution, Macclesfield Town. Scott Wilson replaces Scott Burgess. Substitution, Hartlepool United. Blair Adams replaces Jack Munns. Substitution, Macclesfield Town. Kieran Kennedy replaces George Pilkington. Goal! Macclesfield Town 1, Hartlepool United 1. Jake Cassidy (Hartlepool United). Second Half begins Macclesfield Town 1, Hartlepool United 0. First Half ends, Macclesfield Town 1, Hartlepool United 0. Jack Munns (Hartlepool United) is shown the yellow card. Goal! Macclesfield Town 1, Hartlepool United 0. Danny Whitaker (Macclesfield Town). Tyrone Marsh (Macclesfield Town) is shown the yellow card. Liam Donnelly (Hartlepool United) is shown the yellow card. First Half begins. Lineups are announced and players are warming up.",
"Gold reference": "Jake Cassidy's second-half equaliser earned Hartlepool their first point in the Vanarama National League as they drew against Macclesfield.",
"Greedy candidate": "Jake Cassidy's late goal helped Macclesfield to a comfortable victory over Hartlepool at the National Stadium.",
"Beam candidate": "Jake Cassidy scored a hat-trick as Macclesfield beat Hartlepool to reach the League Two quarter-finals.",
"Top-p candidate": "Hartlepool scored just one more of their tries as they beat Hartlepool in their first friendly at League Two."
},
{
"Entry ID": 79,
"Input": "summarize: The shortlist for this year's St David Awards, which will be presented on 10 March, has been announced. They acknowledge extraordinary achievements, with categories including citizenship, culture and sport. In the bravery category, Peter Fuller was nominated for stepping in to stop a machete attack in Mold in January 2015. Matthew James from Pontypridd is also nominated for shielding his partner from bullets during last summer's Tunisia terror attacks.",
"Gold reference": "A man who intervened in a machete attack and a holidaymaker who shielded his fiancee from terrorists have been nominated for awards.",
"Greedy candidate": "The St David Awards have been announced in the wake of the first ever St David Awards ceremony.",
"Beam candidate": "The St David Awards have been announced in a bid to celebrate the achievements of the country's leading terror suspects.",
"Top-p candidate": "Mark Salon, the principal at Cardiff's Little Merry and the architect of Pontypridd, has been named in the British and British Heritage shortlist."
},
{
"Entry ID": 80,
"Input": "summarize: Nathan Smith's overhead kick hit the bar and bounced in off luckless keeper Dean Snedker's back to give the Gulls an early lead before Nathan Blissett's towering header doubled the advantage. Kelvin Langmead then headed in before Arthur Gnahoua shot home the equaliser. But Smith poked in an 82nd-minute winner after a goalmouth scramble to earn Torquay's fourth successive win. It leaves the Gulls four points from safety with a game in hand, but Colin Gordon's Harriers are now 11 points off 20th-placed Boreham Wood with nine games left. Former Harriers striker Blissett's goal was his fourth in six games since arriving on loan from Bristol Rovers.",
"Gold reference": "Torquay United, 22nd in the National League, edged a thrilling relegation battle with bottom club Kidderminster.",
"Greedy candidate": "Torquay Gulls snatched a 3-0 victory over Torquay to earn a 2-1 win over Torquay.",
"Beam candidate": "Torquay Gulls snatched a late equaliser to earn their first win of the season as they relegated to League Two.",
"Top-p candidate": "Liam Boyd netted a 3-0 win to earn Torquay City's first ever Championship medal win at Upton Park."
},
{
"Entry ID": 81,
"Input": "summarize: The Right Reverend Rachel Treweek, 53, has taken over from The Right Reverend Michael Perham after his retirement. Two women bishops have already been appointed, but Bishop Treweek is the first woman to run a diocese. At a service in Gloucester Cathedral she was presented with her pastoral staff and placed in her bishop's chair. She also preached her first sermon as a bishop. During the service, she was welcomed by the Dean of Gloucester, the Very Revd Stephen Lake.",
"Gold reference": "The most senior woman bishop in the Church of England has formally begun her new role as the Bishop of Gloucester.",
"Greedy candidate": "A woman who has been appointed as the first woman to run a diocese has been appointed as the first woman to run a diocese.",
"Beam candidate": "A woman has been appointed as the first woman to run a diocese in Gloucester.",
"Top-p candidate": "A priest who served as the modern Canterbury Cathedral's bishop in Gloucester has been given a new job."
},
{
"Entry ID": 82,
"Input": "summarize: The approval depends on Shell getting a nod from other US regulators, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management said. Shell stopped Arctic exploration more than two years ago after problems including an oil rig fire and safety failures. Environmental campaigners oppose the move. Shell has spent about $6bn (\u00c2\u00a33.85bn) on exploration in the Arctic - a region estimated to have about 20% of the world's undiscovered oil and gas. The Anglo-Dutch company wants to drill up to six wells in water about 40 metres deep, using two vessels that can serve as backups in the event of an emergency. \"We have taken a thoughtful approach to carefully considering potential exploration in the Chukchi Sea,\" said Abigail Ross Harper, director of the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, in a statement. This conditional approval means Shell must obtain permits from the federal government and the state of Alaska to begin drilling this summer. Susan Murray, an official at Oceana, a group against Arctic drilling, said: \"Our government has rushed to approve risky and ill-conceived exploration in one of the most remote and important places on Earth.\" Among Shell's woes the last time it tried to drill in the area were its failure to have a spill-response barge on site before the drills reached oil-bearing zones, as it had promised, and the outbreak of fire on the Noble Discoverer rig that Shell had hired. The Kulluk, a circular drilling barge, broke away from its towing vessel and ran aground on its way to a shipyard in Washington state. \"The approval of our Revised Chukchi Sea Exploration Plan is an important milestone and signals the confidence regulators have in our plan,\" said Shell spokesman Curtis Smith.",
"Gold reference": "Oil firm Royal Dutch Shell has won approval from the US Department of Interior to explore for oil in the Arctic.",
"Greedy candidate": "Shell has approved a plan to drill in the Chukchi Sea, a region estimated to have about 20% of the world's undiscovered oil and gas.",
"Beam candidate": "The US government has approved a plan to drill in the Chukchi Sea in Alaska.",
"Top-p candidate": "Shell is to begin drilling in Arctic waters, a major oil and gas project has been approved, a State of Alaska has said."
},
{
"Entry ID": 83,
"Input": "summarize: Ms Pinkney, who currently works for Sussex Police, will be the first woman to hold the top position in the Hampshire and Isle of Wight force. Police and Crime Commissioner Simon Hayes said Ms Pinkney, who takes over from Andy Marsh, was \"an incredibly strong candidate\". She will take up her new role on 4 April. Her appointment was unanimously recommended by the Hampshire Police and Crime Panel following a recruitment process involving 18 partner organisations. Ms Pinkney said: \"I'm absolutely delighted to hear the panel's decision and I look forward to leading the professionals within Hampshire Constabulary and serving the communities across the county and the Isle of Wight.\" Mr Hayes said Ms Pinkney, who received the Queen's Police Medal in the 2016 New Year's Honours List, will bring \"a wealth of operational experience and strategic leadership\" to the role. Hampshire Constabulary is currently run by acting chief constable Graham McNulty.",
"Gold reference": "Deputy Chief Constable Olivia Pinkney has been confirmed as Hampshire Constabulary's new chief constable.",
"Greedy candidate": "Hampshire Police and Crime Commissioner John Pinkney has been appointed as the first woman to be appointed as a member of the Hampshire Police and Crime Panel.",
"Beam candidate": "Hampshire Police and Crime Commissioner John Pinkney has been appointed as the first woman to become a member of the Hampshire Constabulary.",
"Top-p candidate": "Hampshire's Victoria Pinkney is to take over as Hampshire's new police and crime commissioner."
},
{
"Entry ID": 84,
"Input": "summarize: The 30-year-old midfielder moved to McDiarmid Park for a second spell in February 2016 after a frustrating five months with Hearts. He has scored 14 goals in 48 appearances since then, having netted twice while on loan in 2015. \"The pull of Hibernian was too much for me,\" said Swanson. \"It's always been an ambition of mine to play for the club and I am looking forward to this new challenge and to help achieve their goals back in the Premiership.\" The Championship winners are yet to reveal details of the contract agreed with the former Dundee United, Peterborough and Coventry City player. Saints offered the midfielder new terms, with Swanson adding: \"The decision to leave St Johnstone has been a difficult one for me. I've felt settled at the Saints and really enjoyed my football, and my period at the club has been the most enjoyable and satisfying time of my career. \"So, it goes without saying, my decision to leave McDiarmid Park was not taken lightly. \"I want to thank the manager, Tommy Wright, who has supported me in so many ways, on and off the field. \"His trust in me on the football park allowed me to flourish. The way he treated me like an adult off the park also helped me to mature and develop as a person. \"Now that we are in the top six yet again, which is yet another fine achievement, for the next five games it's my focus to make sure I play my part in helping St Johnstone qualify for a European place.\" Saints are currently fourth in the top flight, five points ahead of Hearts in the race for the final Europa League spot. Asked what Swanson would bring to his Hibs team, head coach Neil Lennon told his club website: \"Goals from midfield, hopefully, creativity, \"He's had a great season, into double figures. \"I think he sees a pass, he's a fit lad, he crosses the ball well. And, whenever I have seen him play for St Johnstone, he has probably been their best player and more likely to create something. \"And, allied to that, he is a Leith boy. He gets the club and that's always important as well.\" Find all the latest football transfers on our dedicated page.",
"Gold reference": "Danny Swanson has confirmed that he is leaving St Johnstone to join Hibernian, saying he could not resist the lure of his boyhood favourites.",
"Greedy candidate": "Hibernian Swanson have signed a new contract with the club for the first time since January.",
"Beam candidate": "Hibernian Swanson have signed a new two-year contract with the club.",
"Top-p candidate": "Manchester City defender Nick Swanson has signed a new contract with the High Fife Club on a three-year deal."
},
{
"Entry ID": 85,
"Input": "summarize: Industry magazine What Car? says prices of VW models have not collapsed as might have been expected. VW cars which are three years old, or have done 36,000 miles, are typically worth 42.21% of their original value, the magazine said. That is 2.7% lower than in September 2015, just before the scandal broke. However, across the industry as a whole, second hand values have fallen by 2% over the same timeframe, suggesting that Volkswagens have performed only slightly worse than the average car on the market. \"I'm sure there are motorists out there who were rubbing their hands in glee at the thought of used VW prices falling off a cliff because of the emissions debacle,\" said What Car? editor Steve Huntingford. \"That simply hasn't come to pass, however, and while the VW story continues to rumble on a year after the story first came to light, the Golf and Polo are still among the most popular new cars in the UK.\" The German car-maker admitted on 16 September last year that software had switched diesel engines to a \"clean mode\" whenever they were tested for emissions. VW has recalled 200,000 cars in the UK as a result. But while it is offering to repair them, it is not offering owners compensation. VW drivers in the US have been offered up to $10,000 each to make up for the deception. The What Car? research suggested that cars made by VW under the Audi brand experienced a similar drop in value to VW-badged cars over the past year. It also found that the value of second hand Seat and Skoda models, also made by the VW group, fell by less than 0.5% over the 12-month period.",
"Gold reference": "Second hand Volkswagens appear to be holding their value well, a motoring magazine says, despite the emissions scandal which emerged a year ago.",
"Greedy candidate": "Volkswagen has said it is a \"shocking\" story about the VW scandal that has rumbled on the market.",
"Beam candidate": "Volkswagen has recalled 200,000 cars in the UK as a result of the emissions scandal.",
"Top-p candidate": "Volkswagen has revealed that its Mercedes-Benz model has fallen by its second hand value, according to market data."
},
{
"Entry ID": 86,
"Input": "summarize: It comes after a jury concluded the death of a man from St Austell was suicide, while undergoing care 140 miles from where he lived. David Knight was killed by a train near St Austell after going on leave from a Somerset hospital. The Department of Health has admitted \"unacceptable\" patients \"are receiving care far from home\". Click here for live updates on this story BBS South West Political Reporter Tamsin Melville said county coroner Dr Emma Carlyon was understood to be satisfied there was a commitment locally to continue to work hard to ensure the lowest number of patients possible leave the county for treatment. An inquest in June heard that in May last year Mr Knight died of multiple injuries when he was hit by a train on the viaduct. The 29-year-old had been suffering from paranoid schizophrenia when he died. A jury said his death was contributed to by an inadequate risk assessment and support while he was on leave from Cygnet Hospital in Kewstoke, Somerset. The inquest heard Mr Knight was being treated there because there were no acute psychiatric inpatient beds available in Cornwall. The NHS said 30 adult mental patients were placed out of Cornwall in 2015/16, 150 the year before when a key unit was closed for six months, and 60 the year before that. The Department of Health said it had increased mental health funding to \u00c2\u00a311.7bn and had accepted the recommendation of the Mental Health Taskforce that the inappropriate use of out of area treatments for adults in acute care \"must be eliminated by 2020/21\". \"We will work to a faster timetable if at all possible,\" said a spokeswoman. \"We will consider Dr Carlyon's letter in detail once it arrives.\"",
"Gold reference": "Cornwall's coroner will raise concerns with the health secretary over the care of mentally ill patients far from home.",
"Greedy candidate": "A coroner has said he is \"really satisfied\" that the lowest number of patients in Cornwall are being treated for mental health in the county.",
"Beam candidate": "A county coroner has said he is committed to ensuring the lowest number of people in Cornwall leave the county for treatment.",
"Top-p candidate": "The death of a mental patient in Cornwall, Bristol, was due to be a cause for concern, a county coroner has said."
},
{
"Entry ID": 87,
"Input": "summarize: Sam Cooke, 22, from Manchester, arrived at his house to find two cards on his doormat. One said the parcel had been put through an open window. The second read: \"I'm really sorry I think your parcel might have fallen down the toilet...Accidently (sic)\". Thankfully, the box, containing printer ink, was \"too wide to hit the water\". Pictures of the apologetic postie's cards and box in the loo have been shared thousands of times on Twitter since Mr Cooke posted them on Twitter. Royal Mail has apologised but Mr Cooke didn't kick up a stink. He said: \"There's honestly nothing to apologise for, the parcel is absolutely fine, gave me and thousands of others a good laugh.\" Though he has said he will keep the window closed in future.",
"Gold reference": "A shocked sports journalist got home to find a parcel which was posted through his window had landed in his toilet.",
"Greedy candidate": "A postie has been apologised for a box of cards containing printer ink that was thrown into a toilet.",
"Beam candidate": "A postie has been apologised after he found a box of cards on his doormat.",
"Top-p candidate": "A postie's pictures of two apologetic paper cards with gum on it have been defended."
},
{
"Entry ID": 88,
"Input": "summarize: The Lord Advocate said he had informed First Minister Nicola Sturgeon of his intention to quit the post after five years in the job. He said it had been a \"real privilege\" to lead the prosecution service in Scotland and to provide legal advice to the Scottish government. The law officer added that it was time to \"step down and do other things\". In a statement, Mr Mulholland said: \"In recent years the Crown has embedded specialisms in the way it does its job. \"Our expertise in handling offences including rape, domestic abuse, serious organised crime, counter terrorism and cold cases has helped us become one of the most effective prosecution services in the world and given victims greater confidence to report crimes. \"It's been an honour to do this job working with so many dedicated and talented people to deliver justice in some of the most demanding and challenging of cases.\" Nicola Sturgeon described Mr Mulholland as \"an outstanding Lord Advocate\". In a statement, she said he had carried out his role with \"dedication, energy, integrity and intellect\". She highlighted his work in leading Scotland's first successful \"double jeopardy\" murder prosecution, against the Worlds End murderer Angus Sinclair. The first minister also praised his role in establishing a National Sexual Crimes Unit and appointing Scotland's first specialist prosecutor to deal with domestic abuse. \"It is clear that he has worked to bring about change to ensure that the system makes a real difference to people's lives, and his dedication to the law and his compassion for others has been behind that drive,\" she added. \"Frank has made a substantial contribution to the law and Scottish society.\" Mr Mulholland served as Solicitor General until 2011, when he succeeded Dame Elish Angiolini as Lord Advocate. He has faced some criticism during his tenure, most notably over the Crown's decision not to press charges over the Glasgow bin lorry crash. The families of some of the victims of the 2014 tragedy are now pursuing a private prosecution against the driver. It is understood that he will formally step down when his successor is appointed by the Queen.",
"Gold reference": "Scotland's top law officer, Frank Mulholland, will step down after the Scottish Parliament elections in May.",
"Greedy candidate": "A former solicitor general has said he has been \"honoured\" to lead the prosecution service in Scotland.",
"Beam candidate": "A law officer has said he has been informed by the Crown of his intention to quit the role of Solicitor General in the Glasgow bin lorry crash.",
"Top-p candidate": "Attorney General Frank Mulholland has formally resigned as the first minister of the church."
},
{
"Entry ID": 89,
"Input": "summarize: Dead Men Risen, written by Toby Harnden and published by Quercus, took the prize at a ceremony in Westminster and was the judges' unanimous choice. It focuses on the death of Lt Colonel Rupert Thorneloe in 2009. It was published in amended form after the first print run was destroyed by the MoD. The judges said the book \"takes us into the hearts and minds of the Welsh Guards in a way that is both interesting and visceral\". \"It challenges every citizen of this country to examine exactly what we're asking soldiers to do in Afghanistan,\" the panel continued. \"Rather than offering easy answers it lets the soldiers speak for themselves.\" Other awards presented included a posthumous honour for Christopher Hitchens, whose final book, Arguably, was included on the long list for the top prize. Hitchens' widow Carol Blue accepted the award on behalf of the Vanity Fair writer. The journalism prize was awarded to Amelia Gentleman for her work in The Guardian, while the blog award went to Rangers Tax Case - an online commentary on the ongoing financial problems at the historic Scottish football club. The writers of the blog said they aimed to \"provide the details of what Rangers FC have done, why it was illegal and what the implications are for one of the largest football clubs in Britain\". The winners were chosen from shortlists of six books, six journalists and seven bloggers, whittled down from longlists of 17 books, 12 journalists and 18 bloggers. Each of the winners received a \u00c2\u00a33,000 prize.",
"Gold reference": "A book about the death of a British officer in Afghanistan, once pulped by the Ministry of Defence, has won the Orwell Prize for political writing.",
"Greedy candidate": "The BBC's BBC Wales and BBC Wales journalists have won the BBC Wales and BBC Wales journalism prize.",
"Beam candidate": "The BBC has won a \u00a335,000 prize for the BBC's \"Dead Men Risen\".",
"Top-p candidate": "The writers of a literary journal also was given a prize for writing a travel journal to solve Afghanistan's biggest terror crisis."
},
{
"Entry ID": 90,
"Input": "summarize: Russia's CG effects and the brilliance of Australia's singing were not enough to defeat jazz artist Jamala. Russia's Sergey Lazarev had been the bookies' top tip for days, possibly because his song was so similar to 2015's Swedish winner - with innovative staging and a slick song to match. But Ukraine stole past Russia and Australia under the radar, with the new voting system providing a huge surprise at the 11th hour when Jamala was crowned as winner. She is the first Crimean Tatar to perform at the contest, and her song, 1944, could not have been further from Eurovision's usual fare. It deals with Stalin, Crimea and claims of ethnic cleansing. Jamala dedicated it to her great-grandmother and her five children, who were deported by Soviet troops from Crimea in 1944. Simon Bennett, head of the International OGAE Eurovision fan club, told the BBC that former Soviet countries that would \"normally vote for Russia\" had sent it a message by voting for Ukraine instead. Political songs are not allowed at Eurovision, but 1944 was permitted because it was based on historic fact, rather than current politics. BBC Music reporter Mark Savage wrote in February that Ukraine's 2004 Eurovision winner, Ruslana, had said the song 1944 had struck a chord over current circumstances in the region. \"This song... is precisely what we are all suffering in Ukraine today,\" she said, referencing Russia's seizure of Crimea in 2014. Jamala simply said after her win: \"I want peace and love for everyone,\" adding at the press conference: \"I was sure that if you talk about truth it really can touch people.\" But John Kennedy O'Connor, broadcaster, author and Eurovision expert, was not happy with Saturday's result. \"I'm disappointed that a dirge about genocide and delivering a pointed slap in Russia's face has won this year,\" he told the BBC. \"This contest should never be a political platform and I'm almost angry that it's been turned into one, despite the very clear rule book on the matter.\" He said that while third place was an \"excellent result\", the Russians must be \"sick as parrots\" at the moment. Alasdair Rendall, president of the Eurovision fan club OGAE UK, said immediate reaction to Jamala's victory was \"mixed\". \"Many people admired her strong voice and the impressive visuals on show,\" he told the BBC. \"However many are already saying it won due to the strong political message it carried rather than its musical quality.\" As for Australia, Bennett said it was \"neutral and easy to give your votes to\" while O'Connor said it was \"time for them to go away and start AsiaVision now\", referring to a song contest for Asia Pacific countries. And at the other end of the leaderboard, hopes for the UK's Joe and Jake were dashed when they came third from bottom. Rendall felt the result was \"totally undeserved\" and Bennett was \"distraught for them\". But O'Connor added: \"The fact that their single is not in the UK top 100 after a month [plus] since its release says it all really.\" Joe and Jake told the BBC they had given \"it their all\" and sent \"huge congratulations\" to Jamala. The new voting system also got a mixed reception, with Bennett saying it was \"a disaster that destroyed the atmosphere\"' while Rendall said it had \"really ramped up the tension\". It seems that the only thing everyone agreed on was the show itself. \"Congratulations to Swedish TV for putting on one of the most impressive, exciting and high quality Eurovisions ever,\" said Rendall.",
"Gold reference": "So Ukraine confounded the bookmakers and Eurovision commentators who had been convinced that Russia - or possibly Australia - would win.",
"Greedy candidate": "Eurovision's Eurovision Song Contest, has beaten Russia's top scorer in the final Eurovision Song Contest.",
"Beam candidate": "Ukraine's Eurovision Song Contest has won a third place in the European Music Hall of Fame.",
"Top-p candidate": "Russia\u2019s Eurovision venue has a triumphant victory in the semifinals of Eurovision music contests."
},
{
"Entry ID": 91,
"Input": "summarize: Areas in Counties Londonderry, Antrim and Down were affected. A spokesperson for Northern Ireland Electricity said was an equipment fault was detected at 21.40 BST. All properties have had power restored had their power restored by 22.14 BST.",
"Gold reference": "Several thousand customers were left without electricity for a time on Wednesday night.",
"Greedy candidate": "Northern Ireland has been affected by a fault in a power supply fault in the north of the country.",
"Beam candidate": "An equipment fault has been detected in parts of Northern Ireland, a statement has said.",
"Top-p candidate": "The halt to electricity across Ireland caused massive power shortages, county councillors have said."
},
{
"Entry ID": 92,
"Input": "summarize: Media playback is not supported on this device Ali Crawford missed a hat-trick of chances for Accies in the first half while Killie's Kris Boyd twice headed wide from close range. Souleymane Coulibaly's volley for the hosts just after the break was well saved by Gary Woods. Boyd fired into the net after connecting with an Adam Frizzell shot but the striker was flagged offside as both sides had to settle for a point. There was a familiarity about the manner in which Accies enjoyed periods of dominance and yet failed to capitalise. It is a characteristic that has haunted them throughout the early part of the season and has cost them points on several occasions. Media playback is not supported on this device So it proved again in east Ayrshire as a combination of poor finishing and good goalkeeping denied them a breakthrough. And though a point away from home might prove valuable in the final analysis, a win would certainly have been more welcome. Accies were culpable of a lack of composure and accuracy in front of goal, with the normally reliable Crawford skewing shots wide or hitting tamely into the keeper's arms. Rakish Bingham missed arguably the chance of the match when he headed wide of goal from inside the six-yard box. But Accies were not the only team guilty of profligacy in front of goal. Kilmarnock - and Boyd - in particular passed up good chances, with the striker heading off target from good positions on a couple of occasions. He was also caught offside far too often, notably when tapping Frizzell's shot into the net. When the strikers did find their shooting boots, both keepers earned their corn with some excellent saves. Woods kept out a controlled Coulibaly volley and also denied Frizzell late in the game, with the Kilmarnock substitute making a good impression from the bench. Jamie MacDonald, so often a hero for Kilmarnock, did superbly to tip Greg Docherty's goal-bound header round the post. And he did likewise with a Massimo Donati long-range volley in added time to ensure the game ended in a stalemate. Kilmarnock manager Lee Clark: \"It was a good point when you consider Jamie's made a fantastic save right at the death. I don't think we deserved anything more - Hamilton have had their fair share of opportunities. \"We've blown a big opportunity to get ourselves into the top six going into the international break and feel good about ourselves. \"In comparison to where we were in our last two home games and where we were against Inverness and St Johnstone, we didn't play enough on the front foot and we let Hamilton's shape cause us too many problems.\" Hamilton manager Martin Canning: \"I thought we deserved to win the game on opportunities created but if you're having one of those days when the ball's not going to go in for you, you need to keep the back door shut. \"I thought Dougie Imrie should have had a penalty [in the first half] - he's wrong side of the defender and I don't see why he would go down as he's driving across the box. \"If we continue to perform to a high level, I've no doubt we can win games.\" Match ends, Kilmarnock 0, Hamilton Academical 0. Second Half ends, Kilmarnock 0, Hamilton Academical 0. Corner, Hamilton Academical. Conceded by Jamie MacDonald. Attempt saved. Massimo Donati (Hamilton Academical) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom right corner. Attempt blocked. Ali Crawford (Hamilton Academical) right footed shot from the left side of the box is blocked. Attempt blocked. Michael Devlin (Hamilton Academical) right footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked. Corner, Hamilton Academical. Conceded by Rory McKenzie. Attempt blocked. Louis Longridge (Hamilton Academical) right footed shot from a difficult angle and long range on the left is blocked. Attempt missed. Adam Frizzell (Kilmarnock) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the right. Attempt saved. Souleymane Coulibaly (Kilmarnock) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom left corner. Jordan Jones (Kilmarnock) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Foul by Scott McMann (Hamilton Academical). Attempt saved. Jordan Jones (Kilmarnock) right footed shot from a difficult angle on the left is saved in the bottom left corner. Corner, Kilmarnock. Conceded by Georgios Sarris. Substitution, Hamilton Academical. Scott McMann replaces Dougie Imrie. Attempt missed. Souleymane Coulibaly (Kilmarnock) header from the centre of the box is close, but misses to the right. Corner, Kilmarnock. Conceded by Michael Devlin. Attempt saved. Adam Frizzell (Kilmarnock) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the centre of the goal. Jonathan Burn (Kilmarnock) wins a free kick on the left wing. Foul by Eamonn Brophy (Hamilton Academical). Corner, Kilmarnock. Conceded by Massimo Donati. Foul by Adam Frizzell (Kilmarnock). Darian MacKinnon (Hamilton Academical) wins a free kick on the left wing. Substitution, Hamilton Academical. Louis Longridge replaces Gramoz Kurtaj. Georgios Sarris (Hamilton Academical) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul. Jordan Jones (Kilmarnock) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Foul by Georgios Sarris (Hamilton Academical). Foul by Jonathan Burn (Kilmarnock). Eamonn Brophy (Hamilton Academical) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Attempt blocked. Eamonn Brophy (Hamilton Academical) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked. Foul by Scott Boyd (Kilmarnock). Gramoz Kurtaj (Hamilton Academical) wins a free kick in the attacking half. Substitution, Hamilton Academical. Eamonn Brophy replaces Rakish Bingham. Attempt blocked. Grant Gillespie (Hamilton Academical) right footed shot from the left side of the box is blocked. Foul by Gary Dicker (Kilmarnock). Gramoz Kurtaj (Hamilton Academical) wins a free kick in the defensive half. Attempt missed. Rory McKenzie (Kilmarnock) right footed shot from outside the box is too high. Corner, Kilmarnock. Conceded by Michael Devlin. Attempt saved. Souleymane Coulibaly (Kilmarnock) header from the centre of the box is saved in the top centre of the goal. Adam Frizzell (Kilmarnock) wins a free kick in the defensive half.",
"Gold reference": "Kilmarnock and Hamilton Academical drew a blank in the Scottish Premiership.",
"Greedy candidate": "Kilmarnock's first win of the season was a resounding success for Kilmarnock, with Kilmarnock relegated to the top of the League Two table.",
"Beam candidate": "Kilmarnock's first win of the season was a resounding one-goal victory for the County Antrim side.",
"Top-p candidate": "Kilmarnock looked almost apologised after a late goal from Chris Kelly offside in the final minute of the match."
},
{
"Entry ID": 93,
"Input": "summarize: Frenchman Christophe Borgye's remains were found at a property in Ellesmere Port, Merseyside, in 2013 - four years after he was reported missing. Manuel Wagner, 29, has been found guilty of murder and sentenced to a minimum jail term of 16 years following a trial at Liverpool Crown Court. Two other men were convicted in 2014. Mr Borgye, 36, was killed in May 2009 and buried in the outbuilding of the house he shared with German national Wagner and fellow Frenchmen Sebastian Bendou and Dominik Kocher. Bendou contacted Cheshire Police in May 2013 and led officers to Mr Borgye's body, which was wrapped in tarpaulin and encased in thick concrete. Officers said a low brick wall had been built inside the outhouse with three layers of concrete placed over the body. A post-mortem examination found My Borgye died from hammer blows to the head. He had been reported missing by a work colleague, but after launching an investigation police said they believed he had left the country. Det Sgt Steve Currie said the case had been \"complicated\" and \"devastating\" for Mr Borgye's family, but added \"the final jigsaw piece in this shocking crime is now in place\". Wagner was previously found not guilty of assisting an offender and preventing a lawful burial. However, was re-arrested in 2015 when new evidence came to light. Bendou, now 39, and Kocher, now 38, were given life sentences for murder with minimum terms of 14 and 23 years respectively in 2014.",
"Gold reference": "A third man has been jailed for murdering a flight attendant who was bludgeoned with a hammer and buried in a concrete tomb.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man has been found guilty of murdering a man who was found dead in a house in Cheshire.",
"Beam candidate": "A man has been found guilty of murdering a Frenchman who was found dead in the house of his family in Cheshire.",
"Top-p candidate": "A soldier whose body was discovered in an outhouse in the north of France was a \"jigsaw piece\" of art."
},
{
"Entry ID": 94,
"Input": "summarize: They will consider plans by Third Energy to frack a well at a site near the village of Kirby Misperton in the district of Ryedale. Campaigners say approval would set a \"dangerous precedent\". But the company says its operations are no risk to people or the environment. Fracking involves injecting water, sand and chemicals at high pressure into rocks deep underground to unlock trapped gas. The process was banned in 2011 after the shale gas firm Cuadrilla caused minor earth tremors when it fracked a well in Lancashire. Third Energy has licences to produce gas in North Yorkshire and offshore in the North Sea. In 2013 it drilled an exploratory well near the village of Kirby Misperton, close to the North York Moors National Park. It now wants to frack the well to test whether it can unlock shale gas from rocks up to 10,000ft (3,000m) underground. \"All we want to do is test whether gas will flow from an existing well using hydraulic fracturing,\" says Rasik Valand, chief executive of Third Energy. \"What we are planning is safe. There is no risk to the environment or the public.\" But there has been strong opposition to the plan from the local community and environmentalists. Hundreds of anti-fracking protesters are expected to gather outside the council meeting in Northallerton on Friday. The council has received more than 4,000 representations, the vast majority against the proposal. Green campaigners fear that approval here would open the door for fracking elsewhere. \"It risks setting a dangerous precedent for Britain,\" says Craig Bennett, chief executive of Friends of the Earth. \"We strongly urge councillors to reject this planning application which is clearly deeply unpopular with the local community.\" Others are concerned about the impact on the local economy as Kirby Misperton is also home to Flamingo Land, one of Yorkshire's top tourists attractions. \"This place is beautiful,\" says retired bishop, the Right Reverend Graham Cray, who lives in the village. \"The economy is based on tourism and agriculture. Tourists don't come to a gas field and that is what we will turn into if we get the scale of fracking that is intended.\" Last year Lancashire County Council rejected Cuadrilla's plan to carry out exploratory drilling and fracking at two new sites on the Fylde. A planning inquiry into that application took place earlier this year. A recommendation will be sent in the summer to the communities secretary for a final decision. The Third Energy application involves an existing site that has produced gas since the 1990s. The well has already been drilled. The shale gas produced will also be sent through a network of pipes to a nearby power station. That will avoid air pollution caused by flaring gas. So the company expects the fracking activity to be completed within eight weeks. The council's planning officer has recommended that the application be approved. But it is now down to the 11 councillors on the planning committee to take the final decision. That decision may not come until Monday due to the number of people who have registered to speak at the meeting. If approved, fracking could start by the end of the year. The Department of Energy and Climate Change refused to comment on Third Energy's application ahead of the council meeting. But in a statement it said: \"Shale gas is a fantastic opportunity which will create jobs, boost our economy and strengthen our energy security. \"There is tough regulation in place to ensure that fracking can take place safely - now is the time to start exploration and find out just how much shale gas is there and how much we can get out of the ground.\" You can follow John on Twitter at @JohnMoylanBBC",
"Gold reference": "Councillors in North Yorkshire will on Friday consider whether to approve fracking in England for the first time since a ban on the technique was lifted in 2012.",
"Greedy candidate": "A shale gas company has rejected a plan to frack a well in a remote area of Yorkshire.",
"Beam candidate": "Plans to frack shale gas at a site near Kirby Misperton in Lancashire have been rejected.",
"Top-p candidate": "A rural oil company that created a well in Lancashire has been backed by anti-fracking activists to protest its proposal to drill in 15,000ft (3,000m) shale gas in 2014."
},
{
"Entry ID": 95,
"Input": "summarize: Almost 80,000 passengers and crew have sailed into Belfast this year on 43 different tourist ships. One of the big draws is the new Titanic Visitor Centre, which so far has welcomed people from 111 different countries. Belfast is no longer building ships, but it is now attracting them. The peace process has transformed the city. During the 1970s, 1980s and early 1990s the cruise ship industry steered clear of Belfast. It was not until 1997 that modern luxury liners started sailing up Belfast Lough. In recent years, numbers have soared. Next year, more than 50 are expected. So what's the big attraction? The Giant's Causeway, golf and Titanic Belfast are pulling in the visitors. However, there is also a human factor - curiosity. Gerry Lennon, chief executive of the Belfast Visitor and Convention Bureau, said: \"Curiosity is a huge driver for tourism. A lot of people are curious about Belfast and Northern Ireland. \"The political stability has given us that ability to go to the market-place and now say 'look what we have to offer'.\" The Glens of Antrim, the walls of Londonderry and Belfast's shopping districts are also proving popular. The recent three nights of rioting in one part of north Belfast do not seem to have put people off. Money has been invested in Belfast Harbour to ensure it can cope with the increasingly large vessels sailing into the city, including the latest arrival, the 113,000-tons Emerald Princess. Tony McAuley, commercial officer for Belfast Harbour, said: \"Once we get people here, the facilities almost sell themselves.\" The Titanic Visitor Centre has attracted more than 500,000 visitors since it opened six months ago - double what was expected. The cruise ship business alone is worth an estimated \u00c2\u00a315m a year to Northern Ireland's economy. There is a certain novelty factor to Belfast at the moment. This will wear off in time. In the meantime, the city is enjoying riding the wave of international interest. Follow Mark Simpson on Twitter: @BBCMarkSimpson",
"Gold reference": "A record number of luxury cruise ships have come to Belfast this year, making it one of the fastest growing cruise destinations in the world.",
"Greedy candidate": "The Belfast city is attracting more than 500,000 visitors this year, according to the BBC.",
"Beam candidate": "The city of Belfast is attracting more than 500,000 visitors this year, according to the BBC.",
"Top-p candidate": "A floating aquarium in Belfast is taking its sights on the Clyde of the Dragon."
},
{
"Entry ID": 96,
"Input": "summarize: A team from Glasgow University found there was a sharp fall in accidents from 5,901 in 1997 to 2,914 in 2014. The researchers said, however, there was \"no evidence\" the M74 had impacted on an \"already decreasing trend\". The five-mile (8km) route, which cost \u00c2\u00a3692m, links the M74 at Carmyle to the M8 southwest of the Kingston Bridge. Planning permission for the route was granted in October 1995 and immediately opposed by Joint Action Against the M74 (Jam74) - a coalition of community, environmental and sustainable transport groups. Construction began in 2008 after a last-ditch legal bid to halt the project was abandoned by Friends of the Earth Scotland and Jam74. Supporters claimed the road would bring economic benefits to the west of Scotland and help cut accidents, whereas critics argued it would cause more pollution, increase health problems and fragment communities. The Glasgow University study looked to evaluate the impact of the M74 extension on the number of road accidents on local roads during the construction period and following its opening. Lead author of the report, Dr Jonathan Olsen, said: \"The building of the M74 extension in the south of Glasgow was controversial. There were strong arguments for and against its construction, but ultimately it went ahead. \"One of the arguments in favour was that it could reduce road accidents on local streets. \"In our study we examined police accident data from 1997 to 2014, three years after the new motorway was opened, and found that this predicted reduction in road accident numbers had not materialised.\" He added: \"But on the other hand, we found no evidence that the M74 extension had led to an increase in accidents.\" Report co-author, Professor Rich Mitchell, added: \"There is surprisingly little evidence about the impacts new motorways have. \"This research will be useful for planners, politicians and residents elsewhere who are trying to decide whether to build or not.\" The study is published in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health.",
"Gold reference": "The controversial M74 extension through Glasgow has had little impact on road traffic accidents in the city since it opened in 2011, a new study has found.",
"Greedy candidate": "A new motorway in Glasgow has been built to reduce road accidents on roads, a study has found.",
"Beam candidate": "The number of road accidents on the M74 at Carmyle in Glasgow has risen by more than a third in the last three years.",
"Top-p candidate": "The idea of linking the M74 to Carmyle and Carmyle near Glasgow is \"could stop coming from its former gateway\", a report has found."
},
{
"Entry ID": 97,
"Input": "summarize: The writer's work tells the story of a Nigerian woman who moves to the US to pursue a college education. In 2008, her second novel, Half of a Yellow Sun, won the UK's Orange Prize and Purple Hibiscus was longlisted for the Booker Prize four years earlier. Other category winners for the US honour included Sheri Fink's book about Hurricane Katrina. Her account of the patients, staff and families who took shelter in New Orleans' Memorial Hospital during the devastating storm took the non-fiction prize. Frank Bidart won the poetry section for his collection Metaphysical Dog, while Amy Wilentz was honoured with the autobiography award for her account of journeys to Haiti following the 2010 earthquake in the country. For the first time, a special award was given for a debut writer, crossing all categories. Anthony Marra was honoured with the prize for his novel A Constellation of Vital Phenomena. Adichie's third novel was also named as one of the New York Times' top 10 books of 2013. In an interview with the Los Angeles Times, the author said her book drew on her own experiences as an African living in the US, particularly with African Americans. \"I don't know race in the way an African American knows race\u00e2\u20ac\u00a6 Sometimes it takes an outsider to see something about your own reality that you don't,\" she said. Her preceding work, Half of a Yellow Sun, is set during the Biafran War of the late 1960s and has been adapted into a forthcoming film starring Chiwetel Ejiofor and Thandie Newton. The writer is also in the running for the UK's Baileys Women's Prize for Fiction - formerly known as the Orange Prize - for Americanah. The National Critics Book Prize was first awarded in 1974 and is open to writers of all nationalities whose work has been published in the US.",
"Gold reference": "Nigerian author Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie has won the US National Critics Book Prize for her novel Americanah.",
"Greedy candidate": "A novel by African American author Adichie has been named the New York Times's top 10 book awards.",
"Beam candidate": "An African American writer has won the National Critics Book Prize for Fiction for the first time in five years.",
"Top-p candidate": "A new book featuring Auschwitz's Ruthin Adichie has been named the New York Times' top literary critic."
},
{
"Entry ID": 98,
"Input": "summarize: Six members of Cymdeithas yr Iaith Gymraeg blocked the entrance to the building at Llandudno Junction at about 06:30 GMT. North Wales Police were called to the protest, which ended at midday. The Welsh government said it was taking action to promote the language. The protestors said the action was part of a general Cymdeithas campaign to put pressure on the Labour administration in Wales to act urgently for the Welsh language. They want the Welsh government to adopt six basic policy changes, including making Welsh-medium education available for all and what they call \"fair funding\" for the language. Robin Farrar, chairman of the society, said: \"We're here to speak out for the present generation, and those to come, who should be able to live in Welsh. \"There's a real crisis facing the language, but the Welsh government is not acting seriously. \"We're certain that our unique national language can thrive over the years to come with positive campaigning and political will.\" A Welsh government spokesperson said: \"We are very disappointed that Cymdeithas yr Iaith has decided to take this course of action, especially as we've held regular, and constructive, dialogue with the group. \"Over the past year we have taken positive action to promote the Welsh language, including significant measures such as publishing proposed standards to improve Welsh language services to citizens.\"",
"Gold reference": "Welsh language campaigners have chained themselves to the gates of Welsh government offices in a protest at a \"lack of response\" to the decline in the number of Welsh speakers.",
"Greedy candidate": "A group of protesters have blocked a building in a Welsh language protest in the city of Llandudno.",
"Beam candidate": "Cymdeithas yr Iaith Gymraeg has blocked the entrance to a Welsh language building in north Wales.",
"Top-p candidate": "A group of protesters have condemned the Welsh language as being held by opposition activists."
},
{
"Entry ID": 99,
"Input": "summarize: Dating back 520 million years, the clawed spider-like fossil shows clear evidence of a brain and of nerve cords running through the creature's trunk. The specimen now confirms that the ancestors of spiders and scorpions were related, but branched off more than half-a-billion years ago. A team of international scientists present their work in Nature. The \"great appendage\" arthropods, are an extinct group of joint-legged creatures with large claw-like appendages - or growths - protruding from their heads. The nervous system tends to be similar between major groups of animals, which helps palaeontologists work out how they are related, explained Greg Edgecombe from the Natural History Museum in London. \"The nervous system is one of the more reliable tool-kits we have. We were trying to investigate whether there was evidence for the preservation of neural tissues from very early parts of the animal fossil record,\" he told BBC News. \"What we've been working with is fossils with very fine anatomical preservation from the Cambrian period. These have given us information about brains, the nerve cords and the neural tissue that goes into the eyes.\" New to science, the fossil was recently discovered in South China and is part of the genus Alalcomenaeus. This group had segmented bodies equipped with about a dozen pairs of appendages which enabled the creatures to swim or crawl. It was placed in a CT scanner and compared with other arthropods in order to understand its evolution. The team then used 3D software to see structures not visible on the surface of the fossil. \"People like myself who are mad keen on creepy crawlies want to understand how very strange early arthropods relate to living ones,\" added Dr Edgecombe. \"By having access to the nervous system it allows us to study the evolutionary relationships of very ancient fossils using the same kind of information that we would use for living animals.\" Co-author, Xiaoya Ma, also from the Natural History Museum, said: \"It is very exciting to use new techniques to successfully reveal such a complete central nervous system from a 520-million-year old fossil, and in such detail.\" She told the BBC's Science in Action programme that the high resolution of the reconstructed image allowed the team to see \"the concentrated neural structures in the head region\". They could also observe the segments of the brain associated with the claw-like appendages. The fossil belongs to an extinct group of marine arthropods known as megacheirans, Greek for \"large claws\". To infer the evolutionary relationships between species, the fields of palaeontology and neuroanatomy came together. Nicholas Strausfeld was from the anatomy side of the team at the University of Arizona, US. \"We now know that the megacheirans had central nervous systems very similar to today's horseshoe crabs and scorpions,\" said Prof Strausfeld. \"This means the ancestors of spiders and their kin lived side by side with the ancestors of crustaceans in the Lower Cambrian.\" He added that their prominent appendages were clearly used for grasping and holding. \"Based on their location, we can now say that the biting mouthparts in spiders and their relatives evolved from these appendages.\" The team says they expect to find more fossils dating even further back, which will shed new light onto the ancestors of many of today's arthropods.",
"Gold reference": "Scientists have discovered the best-preserved nervous system in an ancient fossil.",
"Greedy candidate": "A 520 million-year-old spider-like fossil has been a tool-kit for palaeontologists to study the evolution of the elusive arthropods.",
"Beam candidate": "A 520-million-year-old spider-like fossil has revealed a \"great appendage\" arthropod, which is part of the genus Alalcomenaeus.",
"Top-p candidate": "A fossil which has been found in modern North Africa has led to a real resemblance to the high-potential biological animal fossil."
},
{
"Entry ID": 100,
"Input": "summarize: The Muslim Council of Britain (MCB) said mosques would offer refreshments and \"insight\" into how they run. Leaders from other religions have also been invited, to \"demonstrate unity\". The MCB has raised concerns about anti-Muslim sentiment since 17 people were killed by Islamist militants in Paris last month. Announcing Visit My Mosque Day, the MCB said: \"Mosques will be sharing tea and refreshments alongside an insight into the day-to-day goings on of a busy Muslim centre of worship. Members of the Muslim community \"may be on hand to answer questions about Muslims and Islam where this is possible,\" it said. \"Local mosques will also be inviting inter-faith leaders as well, and all will be invited to come together to demonstrate unity and solidarity during what has been a tense time for faith communities.\" Speaking outside the East London Mosque in Whitechapel, MCB assistant secretary general Miqdaad Versi said the organisation wanted to \"de-mystify what Islam, Muslims and mosques are all about\". \"People can have the opportunity to understand these things directly from people that they can speak to, and by actually experiencing these institutions and coming into mosques they can break down the barriers that they previously had,\" he said. Mr Versi said there had been a rise in \"Islamophobia\" since the Paris killings, with attacks on three or four mosques, more verbal attacks against Muslims and \"a lot more hate mail\" being received by the MCB. \"For us it's important to try and create a positive image, and not let the actions of a few impact the reality of the many,\" he added. The Reverend Fred Ashford-Okai, one of those who visited East London Mosque earlier, said: \"The more we know about each other - Muslims, Christians, Jews, even those with no faith - the more we can actually live a more cohesive life in our community.\" More than 20 mosques were expected to take part. The figure is a small proportion of the total number of mosques in Britain, which is estimated to be 1,750. The MCB said only 55-60% of mosques were affiliated to it, and the total includes small establishments such as prayer rooms in schools and offices.",
"Gold reference": "Mosques have opened their doors to the public as part of a drive to \"reach out to fellow Britons following tensions around terrorism\".",
"Greedy candidate": "Muslims and Muslims are to be invited to attend a visit to the East London Mosque in Whitechapel, the Muslim Council has said.",
"Beam candidate": "The Muslim community has been invited to take part in a visit to the East London Mosque in Whitechapel.",
"Top-p candidate": "The Muslim community will welcome membership of UK mosques and meeting in the south of England, a group of 13 mosques are to attend."
},
{
"Entry ID": 101,
"Input": "summarize: The spelling error was spotted close to the High Street in Warsop, Nottinghamshire on Friday afternoon. Eric Hill quickly photographed the sign, which should have read \"right\", prior to the error being painted over. A spokesman for the Co-op said the contractors were made aware of their mistake and would amend the spelling \"as quickly as possible\".",
"Gold reference": "Contractors were left red-faced after incorrectly painting the word \"rihgt\" on a road off a supermarket car park.",
"Greedy candidate": "A sign that reads \"right\" has been painted over by a contractor in Nottingham.",
"Beam candidate": "A sign has been painted over by a Co-op contractor in Nottingham.",
"Top-p candidate": "A sign in the namesake of the company Co-op has been painted over as the finish was finally on and corrected."
},
{
"Entry ID": 102,
"Input": "summarize: Former Carrick boss Haveron was appointed Glens supremo this week and could not have asked for a more high-profile first match in charge. Glentoran have slumped to 10th in the table after taking just one point from a possible 15. \"We must show how much it means to play in games like these,\" said Haveron. \"Our fans expect the players to show passion and pride and that is how it should be. \"We have got to get a bit belief and a win would do that. \"The best way to turn our season around would be to beat Linfield on Saturday.\" Despite being at home, Glentoran will be firm underdogs against David Healy's Linfield who are unbeaten this season. The Belfast Blues sit in second place and are five points behind champions Crusaders with a match in hand. The unbeaten Crues also face a big derby fixture as they host north Belfast neighbours Cliftonville at Seaview. Crusaders have won five league matches in a row while Cliftonville are up to fourth following back-to-back victories. \"Cliftonville are back in form and are winning games of football quite well,\" said Crusaders manager Stephen Baxter. \"They are packed full of quality players and have loads of confidence and ability. They will expect to get a result.\" Ballymena United travel to their fiercest rivals Coleraine looking to make it four wins in a row in the league. They came from behind to beat Glentoran 4-1 last weekend to consolidate third place in the table. \"It will be my first experience of a Coleraine/Ballymena derby and we're looking forward to it,\" said Sky Blues boss David Jeffrey. \"They came from two down to draw against Glenavon last week so that is an indication of the character they possess.\" The fourth derby clash in Saturday's Premiership is at Mourneview Park where Glenavon host Portadown. Final Score from Northern Ireland is on BBC1 NI at 17:00 BST on Saturday",
"Gold reference": "New manager Gary Haveron has called on Glentoran's players to show pride in the shirt as they take on Belfast rivals Linfield on Saturday.",
"Greedy candidate": "Glentoran manager Brendan Haveron says he is \"willing to show how much it means to play in games like these\" after he was appointed to the post.",
"Beam candidate": "Glentoran manager Brendan Haveron says he is confident the players will show passion and pride in their game.",
"Top-p candidate": "Belfast Scorpions manager Martin Haveron says fans who represent Belfast can tell a personal confidence they will have \"a bit confidence and determination\"."
},
{
"Entry ID": 103,
"Input": "summarize: Machinery that used to be \"the heart\" of Poldark Mine is to be restored by Cornwall College engineering students. The tin mine, which is open to the public, is one of the oldest industrial structures in the UK, its owner said. It is believed that the renovation project on the mine at Wendron near Helston could take several years to complete. David Edwards, who bought it last year, said the machinery on site \"has suffered after 14 years of little or no investment\" but that the recent BBC television series has prompted the need for it to be rejuvenated. \"Poldark definitely had an impact for us, it brought more people in buying bookmarks and taking a tour of the mine,\" he said. \"The challenge now is to restore the machinery we have on display and get it back in order so that it is more interesting to the public. \"This has been a place of industry since the 1400s, one of the oldest industrial structures in the UK, so keeping it going is vital for Cornwall's heritage.\" Luke Bazeley, an engineering lecturer at Cornwall College, said: \"We always try to give the students work experience and this is the perfect live project to work on - they've loved visiting the site and finding out more about Cornwall's heritage.\" He added the students will need to do some research to find replacement parts for the machinery.",
"Gold reference": "A mine, which has been made popular again by the recent BBC series Poldark, is to get a \"facelift\".",
"Greedy candidate": "A tin mine in Cornwall is to be restored to its former glory after a 14-year-old man was killed in a fire.",
"Beam candidate": "A tin mine in Cornwall is to be re-opened to the public, it has been claimed.",
"Top-p candidate": "Thousands of containers and spare parts of a tin mine in Cornwall will be restored and demolished."
},
{
"Entry ID": 104,
"Input": "summarize: Pedro, 25, had been training with the Cumbrians and impressed in reserve games against Barrow and Burnley. The Angola-born wide-man has spent much of his career in the Dutch league with teams such as Feyenoord and Heracles, plus stints in Bulgaria and Romania. \"We've seen enough to know that he adds something different to the group,\" said head of recruitment Lee Dykes. He told the club website: \"This is a chance for him to show everyone what he can do.\" Find all the latest football transfers on our dedicated page.",
"Gold reference": "Carlisle United have signed free-agent winger Louis Pedro on a short-term contract that will expire on 21 May.",
"Greedy candidate": "Holland have signed midfielder Pedro Pedro on a one-year deal.",
"Beam candidate": "Holland winger Pedro has signed a one-year contract extension with the Dutch club.",
"Top-p candidate": "Club Crystal Palace have signed Nigeria striker Tito Pedro on a one-year contract with the club until the end of this season."
},
{
"Entry ID": 105,
"Input": "summarize: The world number 45 took the first set but lost 6-7 (2-7) 6-4 6-4 against the reigning US Open champion. Edmund, 21, impressed but Wawrinka broke serve at 3-2 in the second set and twice in the decider to win in two hours 36 minutes. The Swiss 31-year-old will play third seed Kei Nishikori in the semi-finals. Canadian top seed and defending champion Milos Raonic beat 14-time Grand Slam champion Rafael Nadal 4-6 6-3 6-4 to reach the last four. The world number three will play Bulgarian seventh seed Grigor Dimitrov, who beat Austrian Dominic Thiem. British number four Aljaz Bedene was also knocked at the quarter-final stage of the Chennai Open in India on Friday. The world number 101 lost 6-3 6-0 to French fifth seed Benoit Paire.",
"Gold reference": "British number two Kyle Edmund is out of the Brisbane International after losing to world number four Stan Wawrinka in the quarter-finals.",
"Greedy candidate": "Britain's No. 1 Johann Edmund won the first set of the Australian Open to reach the finals of the World Open.",
"Beam candidate": "Britain's Andy Wawrinka lost 6-3 6-0 to defending champion Rafael Nadal to reach the semi-finals of the US Open.",
"Top-p candidate": "Donald Wawrinka knocked over France's Kane Wawrinka to reach the quarter-finals of the US Open."
},
{
"Entry ID": 106,
"Input": "summarize: They have increased the cash component of their bid by 1.2bn euros to 8.2bn euros (\u00c2\u00a36.6bn; $11.2bn). The improved offer raises the valuation of Alstom's energy business by 400m euros to 14.6bn euros. The move by Siemens and Mitsubishi comes just a day after rival bidder General Electric sweetened its offer. On Thursday, GE offered to create a joint venture with the firm's nuclear and energy businesses and to sell its profitable rail signalling business to Alstom. However, it did not increase its $17bn bid. Alstom, which also makes the high-speed TGV train, is seen as one of France's key industrial firms. The French government can therefore block a foreign takeover of the firm. As a result, all parties have discussed their offers with French President Francois Hollande, who is concerned about the break-up of Alstom and the loss of jobs. The rival bidders have also been sweetening other parts of their bid. GE's previous offer had been for a straight purchase of Alstom's power business. But it has now proposed to also create a joint venture with Alstom in the nuclear and energy business and to sell its rail signalling business to Alstom. \"The alliance will retain and strengthen France's presence in the energy business and reinforce Alstom Transport,\" said GE's chief executive, Jeff Immelt. \"It creates jobs, establishes headquarters decision-making in France and ensures that the Alstom name will endure.\" On Friday, Siemens also offered to enter into a \"immediate\" joint venture with Alstom in mobility management for the rail business, including signalling. \"The specified proposal continues to preserve Alstom's current perimeter in almost all its activities, enhances its industrial sustainability, strengthens its financial structure,\" Siemens and Mitsubishi said in a joint statement.",
"Gold reference": "Siemens and Mitsubishi Heavy Industries have upped their offer to buy the energy business of France's Alstom, in the latest move by competing bidders.",
"Greedy candidate": "Siemens and Mitsubishi have offered to buy Alstom's energy business Alstom, a French company that makes the TGV train.",
"Beam candidate": "Siemens and Mitsubishi have offered to sell Alstom's rail signalling business in France.",
"Top-p candidate": "Siemens and Siemens have announced that it will unveil their announced new contract."
},
{
"Entry ID": 107,
"Input": "summarize: Police said he was James Gunn, from Stromness. Mr Gunn's white Ford Focus crashed on the A967 at Garson Farm, Shandwick, on Saturday morning. Police have appealed for anyone who saw the car between Stromness and Twatt from 04:15 to 05:30 to come forward.",
"Gold reference": "A 32-year-old man who died after his car crashed on Orkney has been named.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man has been charged with the murder of a man who crashed into a car in Shandwick.",
"Beam candidate": "Police have appealed for anyone who saw a car between Stromness and Twatt on Saturday to come forward.",
"Top-p candidate": "A black Ford Focus in Scotland has crashed a car with an engine in Grange after a collision with a car at Wolverhampton."
},
{
"Entry ID": 108,
"Input": "summarize: BBC Radio 4's File on 4 programme discovered 22 profiles belonging to men convicted of child sex offences, which included grooming a child on Facebook and attempting to meet her for sex. Six of the accounts remained live three weeks after the BBC reported them. Facebook's UK policy director Simon Milner said the company was effective in dealing with the issue. He said he appreciated the BBC bringing the pages to light but said Facebook worked proactively to search out behaviour that should not be happening on the site. According to the platform's own rules, convicted sex offenders are not allowed to use the social media network. Among the profiles uncovered was one belonging to Bruce Cordwell, 20, who groomed 15-year-old Kayleigh Haywood through Facebook and Whatsapp just days before she was raped and murdered by another man, Stephen Beadman, in November 2015. \"It's absolutely vile,\" said Stephanie Haywood, Kayleigh's mother, when she was shown Cordwell's page. Kayleigh, from Measham, Leicestershire, was contacted by 28-year-old Luke Harlow on Facebook in 2015 and the pair exchanged more than 2,600 messages during a two-week period. After Harlow convinced art enthusiast Kayleigh he was her boyfriend, she agreed to stay over at his flat in Ibstock. The following night, his neighbour Stephen Beadman came round to the flat and later raped and murdered the teenager before dumping her body in a hedgerow. Beadman was jailed for 35 years for murder, rape and false imprisonment, and Harlow received a 12-year sentence for meeting a child following sexual grooming, sexual activity with a child and false imprisonment. But while detectives were investigating the case, they discovered Cordwell, then 19, had also been sexually grooming Kayleigh. In February, he was jailed for three years and seven months after pleading guilty to attempting to arrange the commission of a child sex offence. Stephanie, a mother-of-eight, said convicted child sex offenders who remained on social media posed a huge risk. \"There is a risk they could do what they've done again, or worse,\" she said. \"I say, 'Once a groomer always a groomer.' \"Once they've been inside for whatever they've done, I think they should remove it. I think it's horrible.\" By comparing police mug shots and media coverage of child sex abuse cases and cross-referencing them with the details on Facebook, File on 4 tracked down accounts belonging to 22 convicted offenders. Facebook has a rule that forbids convicted sex offenders from using its site and has a portal for people to report pages belonging to offenders. The portal requires people to supply a link to the offender's page and provide evidence of their offending, which could be a link to a media report of the court case. Facebook then checks on the offenders with the police before removing them from the site. When the BBC reported the 22 pages it had found, most were removed within 48 hours - but six remained live three weeks after the BBC reported them. Facebook said it was waiting for confirmation from police that the final six were convicted offenders before it could remove the pages. In response to File on 4's findings Facebook's UK policy director Simon Milner, said: \"We appreciate you did that, we appreciate it when anybody reports to us things that are happening on Facebook that shouldn't be. \"Our teams that focus on this work with the relevant local police force to get authorisation from them and it works.\" Mr Milner said Facebook worked proactively to search out behaviour that should not be happening on the site. He added: \"We've found in terms of our working relationship with law enforcement in this country and elsewhere they think we are amongst the most effective companies in dealing with this issue and we actually do have the right kind of arrangements in place.\" Meanwhile, exclusive figures obtained by File on 4 through Freedom of Information requests revealed the most popular social media platforms had been linked to more than 7,000 reports of child sex crimes over the past three years. Figures from 22 police forces revealed 7,162 child sex offences had been recorded between 2014-15 and 2016-17, with a 44% increase recorded over the three-year period. The offences included rape, sexual activity with a child and child sexual grooming involving children as young as three years old. File on 4: Online Grooming is on BBC Radio 4, 13 June at 20:00 BST - catch up on BBC iPlayer Radio. Have you got something you want investigating? We want to hear from you. Tweet us, or email fileon4@bbc.co.uk",
"Gold reference": "Facebook accounts belonging to convicted child sex offenders have been uncovered by a BBC investigation.",
"Greedy candidate": "A number of profiles of convicted sex offenders who remained on social media have been found on the BBC.",
"Beam candidate": "A number of profiles of convicted sex offenders who remain on social media have been uncovered by the BBC.",
"Top-p candidate": "The BBC has removed the profile of 25 people who were convicted of child sex offences by Facebook."
},
{
"Entry ID": 109,
"Input": "summarize: Antoine Maury was last seen in Edinburgh on Monday 24 October. The 21-year-old was last seen at Edinburgh College's Milton Road East campus at 22:00 when he suddenly left his friends. Between 22:45 and 23:00, a man matching Mr Maury's description was seen near Duddingston Village. He was topless and heading towards Holyrood Park. The Maury family said: \"We are still appealing to the public for any information which can help find our son, Antoine. \"We want anyone who was in the area of Duddingston, Holyrood Park or Pollock Halls, on Monday 24 October, between 22:30 and 23:30, who saw a male running and walking, to contact the police.\" Mr Maury is white and of medium build. He is about 6ft, with short, brown hair, a beard and a fair complexion. He has a tattoo of a bleeding hand on his forearm. When last seen he was wearing a brown/green bomber jacket with dark-coloured chinos and a white beanie hat. He is also believed to have been wearing black and white Vans trainers. Glasses belonging to Mr Maury, who suffers from poor eyesight, have since been found with some of his clothes on a golf course. Divers are still searching Duddingston Loch and there are police searches in Holyrood Park. On Saturday and Sunday about 100 volunteers joined officers in the search around Duddingston Golf Club and Holyrood High School. Police Scotland has also continued its media appeal for Mr Maury. This has resulted in more than 464,000 people being contacted through Police Scotland's Facebook page. Officers have conducted door-to-door inquiries in the Duddingston and Pollock Halls areas and have reviewed CCTV in a bid to establish Mr Maury's last known movements. Insp Alan Carson, of Police Scotland, said: \"Throughout this inquiry we have sought to provide Mr Maury's family with the answers they are desperately seeking. \"We are continuing to support and work with them and I pay tribute to the dignity and courage they have shown throughout this period. \"This is still a live investigation and we will carry on our search until we have exhausted our search parameters. \"The public response to our appeal has been enormous and we are grateful for the support offered by the people of Edinburgh. \"I would again appeal to anyone who may have information to come forward. Even the smallest amount of information may be the key to helping us find Antoine.\"",
"Gold reference": "Sonar equipment has been used across Duddingston Loch in the last few days in the search for a missing student.",
"Greedy candidate": "Police Scotland has appealed for a man who was seen walking in Duddingston, Holyrood Park or Pollock Halls, to contact police.",
"Beam candidate": "Police Scotland has appealed to the public for information about a man missing in Duddingston, Holyrood and Pollock Halls.",
"Top-p candidate": "An appeal has been made to help a teen missing from school near Duddingston have been unsuccessful."
},
{
"Entry ID": 110,
"Input": "summarize: The bird and wildlife charity was due to unveil its new sites at Snape and Hollesley later. However, the flooded River Alde over-topped the reserve at Snape, filling the freshwater marshes with saltwater. Work to clear up the damage is continuing and the RSPB said it hoped to open the reserves in the spring. Aaron Howe, RSPB reserves project manager, said: \"The rain has helped flush out virtually all of the salt and the marsh will recover, but the project has been delayed.\" The 125-acre marsh at Snape is an extension to the existing 70-acre reserve. The reserve at Hollesley was not flooded, but the RSPB was hoping to formally open it on the same day as it opened Snape.",
"Gold reference": "The RSPB has had to cancel the opening of its two new reserves in Suffolk due to damage created by December's coastal surge tides.",
"Greedy candidate": "A RSPB reserve has been flooded after a flooded river over-flooded the grounds of the River Alde.",
"Beam candidate": "The RSPB has said it is planning to open a 125-acre marsh on the River Alde in the spring.",
"Top-p candidate": "Royally flooded river Seville and the Baffin island which flooded into the islands is letting out a limited amount of water, the BBC has learned."
},
{
"Entry ID": 111,
"Input": "summarize: The lawsuit accuses Jean Kasem of elder abuse and inflicting emotional distress on Kasem's children by restricting their access to him before his death, according to the AP news agency. Kasem was known as host of the American Top 40 radio show and as the voice of Shaggy in the TV animation Scooby Doo. He died last June at the age of 82. He had been suffering from dementia, and the battle between his children from a previous marriage and their stepmother Jean began before his death. They claim she abused him before he died, moved him from Santa Monica to Washington without telling them and, after his death, had him buried in an unmarked grave in Norway despite his wishes to be laid to rest in Los Angeles. \"What she did to my father is reprehensible,\" daughter Kerri Kasem said, according to AP. \"It's disgusting. It's horrific.\" Jean Kasem's lawyer H Michael Soroy did not immediately return a request for comment to the news agency. Kerri Kasem said the family members were taking legal action after US prosecutors decided not to bring criminal charges against Jean Kasem, who was married to the star for more than 30 years. In May, Los Angeles prosecutors said they could not prove at trial that her actions led to his death. Kerri has taken out the lawsuit with siblings Julie and Michael Kasem and their uncle Mouner. They are seeking damages of $250,000 (\u00c2\u00a3166,000). But Kerri Kasem said: \"We would rather see her in jail than receive one dime. We don't care about the money. We care about justice.\" Casey Kasem began his career in the 1950s and found fame with the chart programme in the 1970s. He famously ended his broadcasts with his signature sign-off: \"Keep your feet on the ground and keep reaching for the stars.\"",
"Gold reference": "Three of US DJ Casey Kasem's children and his brother have sued the late star's widow for wrongful death in the latest move in a bitter family feud.",
"Greedy candidate": "Casey Kasem has been sued by US prosecutors over his death in Los Angeles.",
"Beam candidate": "Casey Kasem has filed a lawsuit accusing him of abuse and inflicting emotional distress on his children.",
"Top-p candidate": "Kari Kasem faces lawsuit against comedian Casey Kasem over his physical abuse after the death of his family."
},
{
"Entry ID": 112,
"Input": "summarize: After their engine failed and their anchor was lost off the coast of India's Andhra Pradesh state in June last year, the men were left stranded in dangerous waters. They drifted helplessly for a week in the Bay of Bengal until an oil tanker under the command of Capt Menon came to their rescue. Her efforts have now been recognised with the International Maritime Organization's (IMO) Award for Exceptional Bravery at Sea, handed out in London on Monday. Not only is Capt Menon the first female captain in the Indian Merchant Navy, but she is the only woman to have won the award, which recognises those who risk their own lives to save others at sea. As waves rose to 9m and wind speed reached 60-70 knots, she commanded a rescue operation last June that required three attempts to get the fishermen onboard the massive tanker via a pilot ladder from their small boat. The Sampurna Swarajya tanker's second officer had earlier spotted the fishing boat 2.5km away off the coast of Gopalpur in Orissa. The men had been surviving off ice from their cold storage after food and drinking supplies were washed away. \"The sea was very, very turbulent, there was a depression... which was stagnant for two or three days and it had intensified into a deep depression,\" Capt Menon told BBC World News TV. \"It was a very difficult task but we had to do it because if I didn't do that I was knowing very well that these fishermen never stood a chance of rescue, no survival at all.\" As far as being a path-breaking female ship captain goes, Radhika Menon doesn't appear to make a big deal of it. She says gender means little on the kind of ships she works on. \"[It is] gender neutral in the sense that even if you are female, you know how to do your job,\" she says. \"People appreciate you, they respect you, you'll be able to carry out your orders and all that.\"",
"Gold reference": "Seven fishermen owe Captain Radhika Menon their lives.",
"Greedy candidate": "Indian navy captain Radhika Menon has been named the first female captain in the Indian Merchant Navy.",
"Beam candidate": "Indian navy captain Radhika Menon has been awarded the IMO's Exceptional Bravery at Sea award.",
"Top-p candidate": "Great Britain captain Radhika Menon, who will helm the Indian Merchant Navy's Fishing and Rescue Division, has won the accolade she is giving her second official service with the Institute of Women in Wrexham."
},
{
"Entry ID": 113,
"Input": "summarize: An area of the town near the swimming pool had been evacuated for most of the morning and early afternoon. Other residents close by had been advised to open windows, stay indoors near walls and to avoid going outside. An exclusion zone remains in force on the river while experts make safe the sea mine which was spotted on Monday. It is thought to be a British mine, dating from the 1940s or 1950s. The evacuation affected three streets, with wider safety advice issued to residents within 500m of the device. There was also an exclusion zone at sea of about half a mile, and small boat owners were told not to sail during the operation. Caledonian MacBrayne reported some disruption to ferry services, affecting sailings from Gourock and Rothesay. Ch Insp Elliot Brown, the local area commander for Inverclyde, stressed that the evacuation had been a precautionary measure, and that there was no immediate danger to the community of Gourock. Lt Cdr Tim Castrinoyannakis, the officer in charge of the Royal Navy's Northern Diving Unit, said that due to the deterioration of the mine it was not possible to conclude how much explosive material it still contained. He said that because of this it was decided to move it to a safer place before dealing with it. Inverclyde Council said: \"Thanks to residents and businesses in Gourock for their patience while the cordon and safe evacuation procedures were carried out today.\"",
"Gold reference": "Residents are returning to their homes after an operation to move an unexploded mine discovered in the Firth of Clyde.",
"Greedy candidate": "A mine in Inverclyde has been evacuated after a huge explosion in the River Inverclyde.",
"Beam candidate": "A mine in Inverclyde has been evacuated from the town of Gourock.",
"Top-p candidate": "A fire at a remote harbour roost has killed a 90-year-old man."
},
{
"Entry ID": 114,
"Input": "summarize: Arriva Trains Wales faced criticism over \"unacceptable\" queues at central station during the Rugby World Cup. The firm wants to iron out issues before 74,000 people attend the Champions League final at the Principality Stadium in May 2017. Trials for the truck stunt event include Queen Street station opening. Usually it is closed after big events, with all people attending rugby and football matches and pop concerts using Cardiff Central only. But assembly members called for urgent change after people were left waiting for hours in long queues, most notably during the 2015 Rugby World Cup. To reduce waits, Queen Street will be open on Saturday for all people using Valley Lines services. People travelling to Bridgend and further west will use the rear of central, while those going to Newport, Ebbw Vale, north Wales, London, Bristol, Crewe, Gloucester and Birmingham will use the front. Bus replacement services will be used to take people to Pontyclun, Llanharan and Pencoed. Ongoing work on the Central Square development directly in front of the main station had made the need for changes more pressing. \"As always we will be working to ensure passengers can get on trains as quickly and safely as possible,\" said Arriva's customer services director Lynne Milligan.",
"Gold reference": "Plans to avert big event travel chaos in Cardiff will be trialled as 30,000 people head to the city for Saturday's Monster Jam event.",
"Greedy candidate": "Arriva Trains Wales has launched a truck stunt event in Cardiff to help passengers get on the train.",
"Beam candidate": "Arriva Trains Wales has launched a truck stunt event at Cardiff Central.",
"Top-p candidate": "Planned trips and talks to the Premiership stadium in Wales are set to go ahead in this week's Cardiff Central Championship final."
},
{
"Entry ID": 115,
"Input": "summarize: In the footage, some Kenyan soldiers can be seen carrying white shopping bags, while others appear to take white boxes from a mobile phone store. At least 67 people died when suspected al-Shabab militants stormed the Nairobi shopping centre on 21 September. The Kenyan military says it is investigating the looting allegations. News agencies say the CCTV footage is taken inside the entrance to the Westgate mall's Nakumatt supermarket, which sells everything from food to televisions. In one section of footage, several soldiers are seen walking out of the supermarket, past a blood-spattered floor, carrying plastic carrier bags. In another clip, Kenyan soldiers can be seen next to a mobile phone outlet. Heroes of attack Victims of attack One reaches over the counter, and apparently removes a white item. Then more soldiers remove white items, which the Reuters news agency describes as mobile phone boxes. The Westgate attack sparked a four-day siege in which large parts of the shopping centre were destroyed. The Kenyan military says it has launched an investigation into the looting allegations, which correspondents say will have angered many Kenyans. At the weekend, Kenya's biggest-selling newspaper, The Nation, ran an article entitled \"Shame of soldiers looting Westgate\". The footage of the alleged looting emerged as the Kenyan authorities announced they had recovered the body of what they consider to be a fourth attacker. \"Today, Sunday 20 October 2013, we recovered a fourth body, which we know from CCTV footage to be that of a terrorist,\" said the Kenyan interior minister, Joseph Ole Lenku. \"DNA and other investigations will confirm their identities. We have also recovered four AK47 assault rifles which we know were used by the terrorists in the assault. We also recovered 11 magazines of AK47 assault rifles.\" Officials had initially said 10 to 15 gunmen were involved, but CCTV footage appears to show only four militants. It is still not clear whether some of the attackers might have escaped. The Somali militant group al-Shabab said its members staged the attack in response to Kenya's army carrying out operations on Somali territory. Last week, the BBC's Newsnight programme revealed that one of the suspected attackers was believed to be a 23-year-old Somalia-born Norwegian national, Hassan Abdi Dhuhulow. His family fled to Norway in the 1990s, but he returned to Somalia in 2009 and allegedly joined the Somali militant group. Sources in al-Shabab have told the BBC Somali Service that Dhuhulow attended a training camp in El Bur in central Somalia, one of the militants' main bases. The sources said Dhuhulow took part in many al-Shabab operations in Mogadishu and Kismayo and was well-known in jihadist circles.",
"Gold reference": "Security camera footage has emerged which appears to show Kenyan security forces looting goods during last month's siege of the Westgate mall.",
"Greedy candidate": "A Kenyan military has recovered a fourth body of a suspected militant in the attack on a shopping centre in Nairobi.",
"Beam candidate": "The Kenyan military has recovered a fourth body of suspected al-Shabab militants who stormed the Nairobi shopping centre.",
"Top-p candidate": "Nine suspected militants have been shot down after authorities have recovered the body of a chain of four attackers."
},
{
"Entry ID": 116,
"Input": "summarize: The High Court granted the adjournment after hearing a share purchase agreement was due to be completed, which meant HMRC would receive \u00a31.4m. HMRC had applied to put the Formula 1 team, based in Enstone, Oxfordshire, in administration over unpaid tax. On Thursday, Renault confirmed it would take over Lotus. The adjournment was granted by Mr Justice Birss until 21 December, with the completion of the purchase agreement due on 16 December. He approved Lotus' application for the adjournment, which was backed by Renault Sport and not resisted, because the proposed deal was the result most likely to be of benefit to the creditors and the best chance of rescuing the business as a going concern. Other creditors, owed in excess of \u00a32m, would be paid by 31 December, counsel Jeremy Bamford told the court. Renault first announced its intention to take over the cash-strapped team in September. HMRC brought the case against Lotus because of unpaid income tax and National Insurance contributions.",
"Gold reference": "Lotus has been given a further two-week breathing space in insolvency proceedings brought by Revenue and Customs (HMRC).",
"Greedy candidate": "A \u00a34m cash-strapped Renault team has been adjourned by the High Court.",
"Beam candidate": "A court has adjourned Renault to take over the cash-strapped Lotus team.",
"Top-p candidate": "Lotus's cash-strapped team has been withdrawn by the Court of Justice over the decision to purchase Lotus shares."
},
{
"Entry ID": 117,
"Input": "summarize: Speaking to reporters, FBI boss James Comey said the plans to enable encryption by default could thwart law enforcement investigations. Lives could depend on police forces continuing to get access to the data on devices used by criminals and terrorists, he said. The FBI was talking to both Apple and Google about its fears, said Mr Comey. The conversations with tech firms needed to be had before the day when police forces lost access to those devices, he said. \"I'd hate to have people look at me and say, 'Well how come you can't save this kid?' 'How come you can't do this thing?'\" said Mr Comey in a briefing. His comments came in reaction to a decision by Apple to enable a file encryption system on its iOS 8 software for which it has no keys. This means it would not be able to comply with any official request to help police get at the data on those devices. Google has said it too is planning to enable a similar encryption system by default on the next version of Android. Mr Comey said he was \"very concerned\" about these plans because of what they would allow people to do. \"What concerns me about this is companies marketing something expressly to allow people to place themselves beyond the law,\" he said. \"I am a huge believer in the rule of law, but I am also a believer that no-one in this country is beyond the law,\" he added. Apple and Google have yet to respond to Mr Comey's comments. Ten days prior to Mr Comey's press statement, iOS data forensics expert Jonathan Zdziarski pointed out that Apple's encryption system would not stop police getting at data on portable devices. Specifically weakening security systems just to aid the police was a bad decision, he said. \"For the sake of privacy and overall security, the only logical solution is to make products as secure as possible, and let good detective work do the crime solving, rather than an easy button,\" he wrote in a blogpost.",
"Gold reference": "Plans by Apple and Google to do more to protect customers' privacy have made the FBI \"very concerned\".",
"Greedy candidate": "Apple and Google have been discussing plans to enable encryption on devices that could be used to help police get at data on mobile devices, the FBI has said.",
"Beam candidate": "The FBI has said it is \"very concerned\" that Apple and Google are planning to enable a similar encryption system by default on the next version of Android.",
"Top-p candidate": "FBI agents could \"destruct\" police on devices not capable of obtaining at high speed, fearing that the technology could undermine a law enforcement force, the government has said."
},
{
"Entry ID": 118,
"Input": "summarize: Meden Sports Centre in Warsop, Nottinghamshire, has faced ongoing maintenance issues with a temporary closures and \u00c2\u00a3500,000 spent on repairs. Mansfield District Council has said it is \"unsustainable\" and has launched a consultation on its future. However, Warsop Parish Council said it was \"essential\" to the area and it would fight to keep it open. The centre, which dates from the 1960s, was closed for six months in 2014 after an inspection identified fire safety concerns. Officials have said renovation or rebuilding costs could cost between \u00c2\u00a31m to \u00c2\u00a38m. Andrew Tristram, district council portfolio holder for the environment, said: \"The council has undergone a review of leisure services at Meden Sports Centre and concluded that the current operating model is not sustainable for the future. \"There are increasing uncertainties about the running costs and capital investment due to the condition of the building\". However, parish council chairman Andy Wetton said: \"The centre is essential to the area but this administration seems hell-bent on closing it. \"There was money available to replace it but this has been spent on other things. \"Any attempt to close it would be a declaration of war on Warsop and we would fight it hard.\" The district council said no changes would be made before April 2018.",
"Gold reference": "Any move to close a sports centre would be a \"declaration of war\" on the local community, a councillor has warned.",
"Greedy candidate": "A former sports centre in Mansfield has been closed for a year and costs \u00a31m.",
"Beam candidate": "Plans to close a sports centre in Mansfield have been halted by the administration.",
"Top-p candidate": "A development for an injured Meden Sports Centre in Mansfield in Nottingham has been close to closures and thousands of construction workers are being unpaid, the assembly has said."
},
{
"Entry ID": 119,
"Input": "summarize: Steven Conway died while working at Diamond Wheels (Dundee) Ltd, a firm owned and operated by former Dundee FC director of football Paul Marr. The 33-year-old was sent in to remove debris from a chemical tank with limited protective clothing in August 2011. The firm will be sentenced for health and safety breaches in October. Dundee Sheriff Court heard that Mr Conway sent into the tank containing \"volatile\" chemicals while wearing only trainers, tracksuit bottoms and a t-shirt and fleece. The mask he was given did nothing to protect him from the toxic fumes let off by the chemicals, which were used to strip alloy wheels for cars. Co-workers found the father of two unconscious inside the tank, and he was taken to hospital before being pronounced dead. A post-mortem examination found he had suffered chemical burns from contact with hydrofluoric acid. Pathologists concluded he had died from inhaling industrial paint stripper. Prosecutors said the tank Mr Conway was working in was not properly ventilated, the gloves he was given had holes in them and the face mask he was wearing was actually releasing \"contaminants\" into his air supply. The court also heard that there were no safety protocols in place at the premises, no risk assessment was carried out and there was no safe system of work in place. Defence advocate Gavin Anderson said the company had undertaken extensive efforts to adhere to health and safety standards since Mr Conway's death. He said: \"I express publicly in open court that Mr Conway's tragic death is genuinely and deeply regretted by all associated with the company. \"He had been a friend of Mr Marr for seven years prior to this and was valued not only as an employee but also as a friend.\" Diamond Wheels (Dundee) Ltd, registered at Nethergate, Dundee, pleaded guilty to a charge under the Health and Safety at Work Act. Sheriff Alistair Brown deferred sentence until October for the Crown and defence to make written submissions. Addressing Mr Conway's parents in the public benches, he said: \"Nothing that I can say or do will bring him back and I recognise that. \"It is certainly not the case in selecting a fine that I will be in any way seeking to put any kind of value on him or his life. \"It is important to keep in mind that Mr Conway died as a result of this - he's not to be forgotten in this process.\"",
"Gold reference": "A Dundee company has admitted health and safety failings after a worker died while cleaning out a chemical tank.",
"Greedy candidate": "A man who was a friend of a former Dundee FC boss has been jailed for seven years.",
"Beam candidate": "A former Dundee FC boss has been jailed for seven years for using a mask he was given to protect him from toxic fumes.",
"Top-p candidate": "A company's strike-and-split cap can be used to clean a chemical tank with essentials after it started to strip off chemicals in its factory equipment."
},
{
"Entry ID": 120,
"Input": "summarize: Carmarthenshire's Mark James and Pembrokeshire's Bryn Parry Jones had been given cash payments in lieu of employer pension contributions. Dyfed-Powys Police said the force was in discussions with the auditors. Carmarthenshire council said it was pleased the auditor did not rule its pension policy as unlawful. The public spending watchdog report said that both authorities had acted unlawfully in allowing the chief executives to opt out of the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) to avoid potential tax payments. Mr James was also unlawfully given an indemnity against potential libel costs. Assistant auditor general Anthony Barrett said: \"Carmarthenshire council has acted unlawfully on two fundamental issues, both of which the public need to be fully aware of. \"The authority has taken decisions and used taxpayers' money in areas that they do not have the legal powers to do so.\" In a separate report on Pembrokeshire council, Mr Barrett concluded similar pension arrangements for some senior officers were also contrary to law. It is expected that by the end of March 2014, \u00a351,011 will have been paid to chief executive Mr Jones and one other senior officer. The auditor said the decisions to allow certain officers to receive payments, and then for payments to be made, were unlawful on several grounds. \"The public should be able to expect the highest standards of decision making at local authorities and the council must now address the procedural weaknesses I have identified in my report,\" he said. \"It needs to demonstrate to its electorate that it is operating in accordance with the law and in line with good governance principles.\" Mr Barrett said neither council had the lawful power to give cash supplements in lieu of pension contributions to avoid tax liabilities, but said it was up to the local authorities whether they tried to claw back any money. Mr Barrett conducted two reports into Carmarthenshire council - the first into pension payments, and another into the decision to grant an indemnity to the chief executive to bring a libel counterclaim. He said the council acted \"contrary to law\" by allowing senior officers to opt out of the LGPS. More than \u00a327,000 was paid to Mr James under the scheme since 2012. Mr Barrett said the council had since \"rescinded its decision to offer a pay supplement in lieu of pension contributions and announced that no further payments will be made to the chief executive from January 2014\". The original decision taken in November 2011 was considered by the council's executive board without appearing on the agenda and without being open to inspection by members of the public. In his report on the libel indemnity, the auditor said the council \"does not have the legal powers to make such payments and there were inadequacies in the processes adopted by the council when making the decision\". It concerned Mr James's libel action against Jacqui Thompson, a blogger who was arrested after filming a council meeting on her mobile phone. He won the case and Ms Thompson was ordered to pay costs of \u00a323,217. Her own attempt to sue Mr James for libel during the course of the dispute was rejected. Carmarthenshire has paid out more than \u00a326,000 in external legal costs since 2012 under the decision to indemnify its chief executive. The auditor added: \"The libel counterclaim is still on-going and it is unclear what the final external legal costs to the council will be.\" Carmarthenshire council said is was pleased the report did not think its pensions policy was unlawful but that its procedural process was flawed. It said steps had been taken to sure ensure such matters are considered as separate items on an agenda. The council said it remained convinced that indemnifying Mr James in the libel action was correct, and claimed the audit office had not objected to the policy when first consulted on it. The local authority noted that the audit office had changed its mind on the issue some months later, and claimed it was \"too late for us to turn back the clock\". Pembrokeshire council also insisted its pension payment policy was lawful. Reacting to the report, deputy leader Rob Lewis said: \"While I note the auditor's views in relation to the decision taken, I am pleased he has concluded the council could take a lawful decision once a number of procedural matters have been addressed.\" Janet Finch-Saunders, the Welsh Conservatives' shadow minister for local government, said: \"These reports are further evidence of the need for a Wales-wide review of senior pay in Welsh local authorities, which is out of control and failing to deliver value for money for hardworking families.\" She told BBC Good Morning Wales: \"We do have some excellent local authorities, but this has cast a shadow now over... our chief executives, who do work within their remit in an honest and transparent manner. \"As to the consequences, it's time now for the chief executive Mark James to resign or, certainly, be instantly dismissed.\" Meanwhile, Plaid Cymru called for councillors who approved Carmarthenshire's pension and libel case payments to resign. Rhodri Glyn Thomas, the party's AM for Carmarthenshire East and Dinefwr, has also called for Mr James to quit. He added: \"This is a very dark day for Carmarthenshire, a dark day for democracy in Carmarthenshire, and is an example of what happens when you have a very weak executive and a council controlled by powerful unelected officers.\" The chair of the public accounts committee, Darren Millar, said the reports showed both councils had fallen well below expected standards. The committee will now consider these findings as part of a wider inquiry into senior managers' pay in the Welsh public sector. Dyfed-Powys Police said it was \"aware of the reports\" and \"whilst the matter hasn't been referred to us, we are in discussions with the auditor and will be making an assessment in relation to any appropriate action by the police\".",
"Gold reference": "Two councils acted unlawfully by letting chief executives opt out of a pension scheme to avoid potential tax payments, the Wales Audit Office says.",
"Greedy candidate": "Police have been told to pay a libel counterclaim against a council's pension policy.",
"Beam candidate": "Carmarthenshire council has acted unlawfully in allowing senior officers to opt out of the Local Government Pension Scheme.",
"Top-p candidate": "An investigative report by Carmarthenshire police has criticised the council for its leadership, while a survey on senior officers said it acted unlawfully."
},
{
"Entry ID": 121,
"Input": "summarize: The group were convicted of Tuesday of assaulting social worker and activist Ken Tsang as he took part in the 2014 pro-democracy rallies. TV cameras caught the officers removing Mr Tsang from the protest area to a nearby park and kicking and punching him as he lay on the ground. The incident, at the height of the protests, caused public outrage. Police in Hong Kong are generally well-respected and incidents of police violence are rare, though there were accusations of heavy-handedness during the protests. The 2014 protests saw 79 days of student-led demonstrations and street occupations by protesters seeking freedom from mainland Chinese intervention in elections for the territory's leader. Defence lawyer Lawrence Lok had argued that the protests had affected police morale, saying that one of the officers who watched the violence had been physically and verbally abused by protesters. But in sentencing, Judge David Dufton noted the men had been working under \"immense stress\" but that there was \"no justification\" for their actions. The \"vicious assault\" had \"brought damage to Hong Kong in the international community\", he said. Tuesday's ruling said Mr Tsang suffered injuries to his face, neck and body, but that these did not amount to the original charge of \"grievous bodily harm\". Last year Mr Tsang was himself found guilty of assaulting and resisting officers on the same evening. He splashed an unknown liquid on police and was handed a five-week sentence. Hong Kong has been part of China since 1997 but enjoys a high degree of autonomy under a principle of \"one country, two systems\". But many Hong Kong locals are concerned about what they see as growing Chinese influence in the city's affairs, with some activists even calling for independence from China.",
"Gold reference": "Seven Hong Kong police officers have been jailed for two years each for beating a handcuffed protester.",
"Greedy candidate": "Police in Hong Kong have been jailed for a year for allegedly assaulting a social worker and activist in a protest in the city of Hong Kong.",
"Beam candidate": "Police in Hong Kong have been jailed for allegedly assaulting and resisting officers in a protest in the city of Hongkong.",
"Top-p candidate": "People in Hong Kong have been jailed for 25 years for violence against police on the street in a capital, a city in China's capital."
},
{
"Entry ID": 122,
"Input": "summarize: Marie Black, 34, of Norwich, stood trial with nine others, including five women, at Norwich Crown Court. Black denied 26 charges. A jury found her guilty of all but three counts. She was convicted of offences including rape and inciting a child to engage in sexual activity. Two men were found guilty of child sex abuse and another woman was found guilty of assault. Michael Rogers, 53, from Romford, was found guilty of 14 counts including cruelty, rape and inciting a child to engage in sexual activity. Jason Adams, 43, from Norwich, was convicted of 13 similar counts. Carol Stadler, 60, from Atkinson Close, Bowthorpe, Norwich, was found guilty of assault causing actual bodily harm but cleared of nine other charges, including serious sexual assaults. They are due to be sentenced on 28 September. Six other defendants, Anthony Stadler, 63, Nicola Collins, 36, Andrew Collins, 52, Judith Fuller, 32, Denise Barnes, 34, and Kathleen Adams, 84, all from Norwich, were cleared of all charges. Black sobbed uncontrollably in the dock as the verdicts were delivered. Opening the trial, prosecutor Angela Rafferty QC said Black, previously known as Marie Adams, played an instrumental role in using the five children as \"sexual playthings\". The abuse, which is said to have happened in and around Norwich and London, included forcing the children to have sex with one another. On some occasions, the adults threw parties and played card games to decide who would abuse which child, Mrs Rafferty said. In interviews the victims described how they were abused in front of one another and other adults. Some of the abuse involved children's toys, including Barbie dolls. All of the defendants denied abusing the children, saying it simply did not happen. During the trial it emerged police had launched an investigation into the conduct of one agency social worker involved in the case. The court heard that the trial had originally been due to start last year only to be delayed when prosecutors raised concerns over changes made by social workers to statements taken from the children. This resulted in Norfolk Police launching an investigation into anomalies in documents. Prosecutors decided no action should be taken, Norfolk Police said after the trial. A police spokeswoman added: \"There was no wrongdoing found on the part of the council.\" Sheila Lock, interim executive director of children's services at Norfolk County Council, said: \"The victims in this case have shown tremendous courage in speaking out. \"The needs of the children, who were central to the prosecution case, have always been at the fore of our minds and have been the main focus of all of the agencies involved. \"Our priority continues to be the children in this case who, despite the ordeal they have been through, are now doing well and are safe from harm.\" Deanna Neilson, head of safeguarding at Action for Children, said: \"This appalling case reveals the premeditated and organised approach some people take to abusing children. \"We cannot lose sight of the needs of the children who suffered at their hands, even though the abuse has stopped. \"Children must be supported, and in some cases receive therapy, to ensure they are armed with the confidence and knowledge they need to recover from this trauma.\"",
"Gold reference": "A woman said to be at the centre of an abuse ring has been found guilty of child sex offences.",
"Greedy candidate": "A woman has been jailed for a year for sexual abuse of five children in Norwich.",
"Beam candidate": "A woman has been found guilty of child sex abuse and inciting a child to engage in sexual activity.",
"Top-p candidate": "Norwich Crown Court has ordered an appeal by a criminal sex abuse trial to go ahead with a trial in the Netherlands."
},
{
"Entry ID": 123,
"Input": "summarize: Shaun Ritchie, 20, was last seen with friends at a remote woodland area near Strichen on the night of Friday 31 October into the Saturday morning. Police Scotland said it had been one of the biggest ever search operations carried out by the force. There was no evidence, said the police, that he had been the victim of a crime. Insp Stewart Drummond said: \"The searches carried out to locate Shaun have been extensive and also challenging due to the difficult terrain. \"Items of Shaun's clothing were recovered as part of the early stages of the enquiry which would have placed him in the Greenburn area. \"If Shaun has walked on from this area, as appears to be the case, we have no indication of the direction he has taken, which compounds further searches due to the size of terrain already searched.\" He explained: \"We have interviewed a number of people, including those who were with Shaun on the night he was last seen. \"Although we will always keep an open mind as to the circumstances, there is no evidence to date which would indicate that Shaun has been a victim of any crime. \"We understand this is a difficult time for Shaun's family who just want answers and not knowing where he is or what has happened to him is beyond frustration for them. \"We are therefore again appealing for any information which may assist us in finding Shaun and ask people to come forward and contact Police Scotland.\" A CCTV image released earlier showed Mr Ritchie wearing dark grey skinny jeans, a white t-shirt, a grey hoodie and brown trainers.",
"Gold reference": "Police investigating the disappearance of a Fraserbugh man have launched a fresh appeal for information six months after he was last seen.",
"Greedy candidate": "Police searching for a man who was last seen in a remote area of Greenburn have said they are appealing for information.",
"Beam candidate": "Police searching for a man who was last seen in the Greenburn area have said they are appealing for information.",
"Top-p candidate": "A man in a rural area who was last seen as being in the community following a shooting in a remote area has been found."
},
{
"Entry ID": 124,
"Input": "summarize: Emergency services were called to the scene at Main Road, where the A78 Largs to Seamill road was closed to traffic. The woman's 60-year-old husband and the lorry driver, 54, were rescued and taken to hospital with minor injuries. The building is split into five homes and the couple had been watching television in their bottom-floor flat. One other man who was in the building at the time was evacuated unhurt. Another resident Callum Calvey had been out at work when the lorry struck the building at about 13:45. \"My bathroom has been wiped out,\" said the 21-year-old tree surgeon, who lives directly upstairs from the the couple. \"There are five flats and none of the other residents are about, but I believe the couple's dog got out as well.\" Photographer Arlene Foster, who works for Anna Conway Photography, was quickly at the scene from her local shop. \"The lorry is literally in someone's front room,\" she told BBC Scotland. \"The lorry seems to have been going towards Ardrossan but hit the building on the opposite side of the road. \"Fortunately, it was quite quiet at the time - school kids could have been affected as well if it happened later.\" Police are urging drivers to stay away from the area, with southbound traffic being diverted at Largs onto the A760 at Hayley Brae and northbound traffic being diverted at the Hunterston Roundabout. The local community had been pressing for a widening of the main road to Hunterston power station and Clyde Port. Steve Graham, chairman of Fairlie Community Council, said: \"This was an accident waiting to happen. \"There have been a number of near misses, but nothing on this scale. It is a very narrow road with premises adjacent to the road. \"We in the community council have been complaining about the weight of traffic coming through the A78, which it's not built for. It would not meet current standards for a trunk road.\" A Strathclyde Police spokesman added: \"The ground floor of the building has been seriously damaged and has been deemed structurally unsound.\"",
"Gold reference": "A 55-year-old woman has died after a couple became trapped under rubble when a coal lorry ploughed into a house in Fairlie, Ayrshire.",
"Greedy candidate": "A woman and her husband have been rescued after a lorry struck a flat in the town of Ardrossan.",
"Beam candidate": "A woman and her husband have been taken to hospital after a lorry struck their home in Ardrossan.",