Broken extension (SG/Lingo?)

[GunMan-fr]

Setup and configuration

MediaWiki | 1.36.1
PHP | 7.4.15 (fpm-fcgi)
MySQL | 5.6.50-log
Semantic Glossary | 4.0.0
Semantic MediaWiki | 3.2.3
Lingo | 3.1.1

Issue

Trying desperately to setup SG/Lingo to create a working glossary for my wiki :) I've setup using Composer and the setup seems correct (no crash, no error). I can also confirm SMW is setup correctly.
I've tried to implement my glossary different ways - two found here : https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:S6wfmfqxb8clhwag and by recreating the structure found on https://sandbox.semantic-mediawiki.org/wiki/Cat%C3%A9gorie:Semantic_Glossary_example
I had trouble identifying the correct way to achieve a working glossary with SMW and willing to contribute to the wiki pages once I find the right method.

Anyway, no tooltip is displayed. I don't know whether the problem comes from SG or Lingo. Looks like no tooltip is displayed on the sandbox example either.

[GunMan-fr]

@kghbln or anyone, please PM me if you want access to the wiki. Still trying to identify whether Semantic Glossary or Lingo fail or both, but as I'm new to SG/SMW/MW, debug is tedious :)

@krabina FYI

[kghbln]

I am attending to the sandbox wiki and I also fail to get it to work. Not sure why. Apparently it works in some environments but not in all of them.

[krabina]

I don't know about MW 1.36, but according to #56 , the way to do it in MW 1.35 is:

• update Semantic Glossary to master
• update Lingo to master
• envoke both in LocalSettings.php

and make sure to have at least PHP 7.3 (see #61)

[krabina]

you can see a working example here: https://testwiki2.kdz.eu

[WouterRademaker]

MediaWiki | 1.36.1
PHP | 7.4.3 (fpm-fcgi)
MariaDB | 10.3.29-MariaDB-0ubuntu0.20.04.1
Semantic MediaWiki | 3.2.3
Semantic Glossary | 4.0.0
Lingo | 3.1.1

I probably have a related problem. For items added after the upgrade to MW 1.36, no property is created. And also no tooltip is displayed.

For example the items: ENMGV, KJB, LdH, OPV, SPL on https://nl.scoutwiki.org/Afkortingen

The last semantic edit is from before the upgrade to MW 1.36, but edits have been made after that time that should also be semantic.

https://nl.scoutwiki.org/index.php?title=Speciaal:Paginaeigenschap&limit=500&offset=0&from=Afkortingen&type=Heeft+subobject

Related to #63 ?

[krabina]

On your first link I can see working glossary items:

So did you figure it out?

[WouterRademaker]

So did you figure it out?

No

https://nl.scoutwiki.org/index.php?title=Afkortingen&type=revision&diff=100312&oldid=97458

• Items added on 2021-03-30 or before have a working glossary item.
• Items added on 2021-07-16 or after don't have a working glossary item

A likely difference between the two groups is the upgrade to MW 1.36.

[krabina]

ah, yes. I see:

I have never used SG/Lingo with subobjects. Maybe it has to do with this? Can you try adding a SG entry on a regular test page and see if you get the same result.

[krabina]

I actually excpect this more to be a SMW issue. As the properties are not set, SG can of course not display anything.
https://nl.scoutwiki.org/index.php?title=Speciaal%3AOpEigenschapZoeken&property=Begrippenlijstbegrip&value=ENMGV

[WouterRademaker]

If you put this on a page, only property "heeft plaats" is set

*[[Glossary-Link::Test]]
*[[Glossary-Term::Test]]
*[[Glossary-Definition::Dit is een test]]
*[[heeft plaats::puk]]

https://nl.scoutwiki.org/Speciaal:Bekijken/:Test

If you put it in one "set" statement no properties are set.

{{#set:Glossary-Link=Test
|Glossary-Term=Test
|Glossary-Definition=Dit is een test
|heeft plaats=puk
}}

https://nl.scoutwiki.org/Speciaal:Bekijken/:Test1

[krabina]

This is bad. I added a __SHOWFACTBOX__ on the Test1 page.
Result: the fact box is showing the properties, but the Browse interface is not. I have never seen anything like this. Maybe a major bug of SMW in MW 1.36? I guess SMW is just not compatible with 1.36 yet: https://github.com/SemanticMediaWiki/SemanticMediaWiki/blob/master/docs/COMPATIBILITY.md

[krabina]

However, the regular property is set after all: https://nl.scoutwiki.org/index.php?title=Eigenschap%3AHeeft+plaats&limit=20&offset=0&filter=puk
So this might be related to the special properties of SG after all.

[GunMan-fr]

Thanks for your inputs. I guess I'll wait for the official SMW compatibility and report back in a few weeks once it's out.

[kghbln]

Another report of SG not working: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Wic3dtzv79x894nd

[glenatron]

Do we know what the cause of the problem is here? Are MediaWiki 1.36 and SemanticMediaWiki simply incompatible somewhere?

[krabina]

SMW is not officially supporting 1.36 yet: https://www.semantic-mediawiki.org/wiki/Help:Compatibility