fix!: traits, id and reply problems for v3 (#910)

src/constants.ts

@@ -14,6 +14,7 @@ export const xParserOriginalTraits = 'x-parser-original-traits';
 
 export const xParserCircular = 'x-parser-circular';
 export const xParserCircularProps = 'x-parser-circular-props';
+export const xParserObjectUniqueId = 'x-parser-unique-object-id';
 
 export const EXTENSION_REGEX = /^x-[\w\d.\-_]+$/;
 

src/custom-operations/apply-traits.ts

@@ -51,12 +51,17 @@ function applyTraitsToObjectV2(value: Record<string, unknown>) {
 const v3TraitPaths = [
   // operations
   '$.operations.*',
+  '$.operations.*.channel.*',
+  '$.operations.*.channel.messages.*',
+  '$.operations.*.messages.*',
   '$.components.operations.*',
-  // messages
+  '$.components.operations.*.channel.*',
+  '$.components.operations.*.channel.messages.*',
+  '$.components.operations.*.messages.*',
+  // Channels
   '$.channels.*.messages.*',
-  '$.operations.*.messages.*',
   '$.components.channels.*.messages.*',
-  '$.components.operations.*.messages.*',
+  // messages
   '$.components.messages.*',
 ];
 
@@ -100,4 +105,4 @@ function applyTraitsToObjectV3(value: Record<string, unknown>) {
       value[String(key)] = mergePatch(value[String(key)], trait[String(key)]);
     }
   }
-}
+}

src/custom-operations/apply-unique-ids.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
+import { xParserObjectUniqueId } from '../constants';
+
+/**
+ * This function applies unique ids for objects whose key's function as ids, ensuring that the key is part of the value.
+ * 
+ * For v3; Apply unique ids to channel's, and message's
+ */
+export function applyUniqueIds(structure: any) {
+  const asyncapiVersion = structure.asyncapi.charAt(0);
+  switch (asyncapiVersion) {
+  case '3':
+    if (structure.channels) {
+      for (const [channelId, channel] of Object.entries(structure.channels as Record<string, any>)) {
+        channel[xParserObjectUniqueId] = channelId;
+        if (channel.messages) {
+          for (const [messageId, message] of Object.entries(channel.messages as Record<string, any>)) {
+            message[xParserObjectUniqueId] = messageId; 
+          }
+        }
+      }
+    }
+    break;
+  }
+}
+

src/custom-operations/index.ts

@@ -2,15 +2,16 @@ import { applyTraitsV2, applyTraitsV3 } from './apply-traits';
 import { resolveCircularRefs } from './resolve-circular-refs';
 import { parseSchemasV2, parseSchemasV3 } from './parse-schema';
 import { anonymousNaming } from './anonymous-naming';
+import { checkCircularRefs } from './check-circular-refs';
 
 import type { RulesetFunctionContext } from '@stoplight/spectral-core';
 import type { Parser } from '../parser';
 import type { ParseOptions } from '../parse';
 import type { AsyncAPIDocumentInterface } from '../models';
 import type { DetailedAsyncAPI } from '../types';
 import type { v2, v3 } from '../spec-types';
-import { checkCircularRefs } from './check-circular-refs';
 
+export {applyUniqueIds} from './apply-unique-ids';
 export async function customOperations(parser: Parser, document: AsyncAPIDocumentInterface, detailed: DetailedAsyncAPI, inventory: RulesetFunctionContext['documentInventory'], options: ParseOptions): Promise<void> {
   switch (detailed.semver.major) {
   case 2: return operationsV2(parser, document, detailed, inventory, options);

src/models/v3/channel.ts

@@ -6,17 +6,15 @@ import { Operations } from './operations';
 import { Operation } from './operation';
 import { Servers } from './servers';
 import { Server } from './server';
-
+import { xParserObjectUniqueId } from '../../constants';
 import { CoreModel } from './mixins';
-
 import type { ChannelInterface } from '../channel';
 import type { ChannelParametersInterface } from '../channel-parameters';
 import type { MessagesInterface } from '../messages';
 import type { OperationsInterface } from '../operations';
 import type { OperationInterface } from '../operation';
 import type { ServersInterface } from '../servers';
 import type { ServerInterface } from '../server';
-
 import type { v3 } from '../../spec-types';
 
 export class Channel extends CoreModel<v3.ChannelObject, { id: string }> implements ChannelInterface {
@@ -30,8 +28,8 @@ export class Channel extends CoreModel<v3.ChannelObject, { id: string }> impleme
 
   servers(): ServersInterface {
     const servers: ServerInterface[] = [];
-    const allowedServers = this._json.servers || [];
-    Object.entries(this._meta.asyncapi?.parsed.servers || {}).forEach(([serverName, server]) => {
+    const allowedServers = this._json.servers ?? [];
+    Object.entries(this._meta.asyncapi?.parsed.servers ?? {}).forEach(([serverName, server]) => {
       if (allowedServers.length === 0 || allowedServers.includes(server)) {
         servers.push(this.createModel(Server, server, { id: serverName, pointer: `/servers/${serverName}` }));
       }
@@ -41,8 +39,10 @@ export class Channel extends CoreModel<v3.ChannelObject, { id: string }> impleme
 
   operations(): OperationsInterface {
     const operations: OperationInterface[] = [];
-    Object.entries(((this._meta.asyncapi?.parsed as v3.AsyncAPIObject)?.operations || {})).forEach(([operationId, operation]) => {
-      if ((operation as v3.OperationObject).channel === this._json) {
+    Object.entries(((this._meta.asyncapi?.parsed as v3.AsyncAPIObject)?.operations ?? {} as v3.OperationsObject)).forEach(([operationId, operation]) => {
+      const operationChannelId = ((operation as v3.OperationObject).channel as any)[xParserObjectUniqueId];
+      const channelId = (this._json as any)[xParserObjectUniqueId];
+      if (operationChannelId === channelId) {
         operations.push(
           this.createModel(Operation, operation as v3.OperationObject, { id: operationId, pointer: `/operations/${operationId}` }),
         );
@@ -53,15 +53,15 @@ export class Channel extends CoreModel<v3.ChannelObject, { id: string }> impleme
 
   messages(): MessagesInterface {
     return new Messages(
-      Object.entries(this._json.messages || {}).map(([messageName, message]) => {
+      Object.entries(this._json.messages ?? {}).map(([messageName, message]) => {
         return this.createModel(Message, message as v3.MessageObject, { id: messageName, pointer: this.jsonPath(`messages/${messageName}`) });
       })
     );
   }
 
   parameters(): ChannelParametersInterface {
     return new ChannelParameters(
-      Object.entries(this._json.parameters || {}).map(([channelParameterName, channelParameter]) => {
+      Object.entries(this._json.parameters ?? {}).map(([channelParameterName, channelParameter]) => {
         return this.createModel(ChannelParameter, channelParameter as v3.ParameterObject, {
           id: channelParameterName,
           pointer: this.jsonPath(`parameters/${channelParameterName}`),

src/models/v3/message.ts

@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ import { MessageTraits } from './message-traits';
 import { MessageTrait } from './message-trait';
 import { Servers } from './servers';
 import { Schema } from './schema';
-
+import { xParserObjectUniqueId } from '../../constants';
 import type { ChannelsInterface } from '../channels';
 import type { ChannelInterface } from '../channel';
 import type { MessageInterface } from '../message';
@@ -16,7 +16,6 @@ import type { OperationInterface } from '../operation';
 import type { ServersInterface } from '../servers';
 import type { ServerInterface } from '../server';
 import type { SchemaInterface } from '../schema';
-
 import type { v3 } from '../../spec-types';
 
 export class Message extends MessageTrait<v3.MessageObject> implements MessageInterface {
@@ -58,6 +57,7 @@ export class Message extends MessageTrait<v3.MessageObject> implements MessageIn
   }
 
   channels(): ChannelsInterface {
+    const thisMessageId = (this._json)[xParserObjectUniqueId];
     const channels: ChannelInterface[] = [];
     const channelsData: any[] = [];
     this.operations().forEach(operation => {
@@ -73,7 +73,10 @@ export class Message extends MessageTrait<v3.MessageObject> implements MessageIn
 
     Object.entries((this._meta.asyncapi?.parsed as v3.AsyncAPIObject)?.channels || {}).forEach(([channelId, channelData]) => {
       const channelModel = this.createModel(Channel, channelData as v3.ChannelObject, { id: channelId, pointer: `/channels/${channelId}` });
-      if (!channelsData.includes(channelData) && channelModel.messages().some(m => m.json() === this._json)) {
+      if (!channelsData.includes(channelData) && channelModel.messages().some(m => {
+        const messageId = (m as any)[xParserObjectUniqueId];
+        return messageId === thisMessageId;
+      })) {
         channelsData.push(channelData);
         channels.push(channelModel);
       }
@@ -83,10 +86,15 @@ export class Message extends MessageTrait<v3.MessageObject> implements MessageIn
   }
 
   operations(): OperationsInterface {
+    const thisMessageId = (this._json)[xParserObjectUniqueId];
     const operations: OperationInterface[] = [];
     Object.entries((this._meta.asyncapi?.parsed as v3.AsyncAPIObject)?.operations || {}).forEach(([operationId, operation]) => {
       const operationModel = this.createModel(Operation, operation as v3.OperationObject, { id: operationId, pointer: `/operations/${operationId}` });
-      if (operationModel.messages().some(m => m.json() === this._json)) {
+      const operationHasMessage = operationModel.messages().some(m => {
+        const messageId = (m as any)[xParserObjectUniqueId];
+        return messageId === thisMessageId;
+      });
+      if (operationHasMessage) {
         operations.push(operationModel);
       }
     });

src/models/v3/operation-reply.ts

@@ -4,14 +4,12 @@ import { Message } from './message';
 import { Messages } from './messages';
 import { MessagesInterface } from '../messages';
 import { OperationReplyAddress } from './operation-reply-address';
-
 import { extensions } from './mixins';
-
+import { xParserObjectUniqueId } from '../../constants';
 import type { ExtensionsInterface } from '../extensions';
 import type { OperationReplyInterface } from '../operation-reply';
 import type { OperationReplyAddressInterface } from '../operation-reply-address';
 import type { ChannelInterface } from '../channel';
-
 import type { v3 } from '../../spec-types';
 
 export class OperationReply extends BaseModel<v3.OperationReplyObject, { id?: string }> implements OperationReplyInterface {
@@ -35,14 +33,17 @@ export class OperationReply extends BaseModel<v3.OperationReplyObject, { id?: st
 
   channel(): ChannelInterface | undefined {
     if (this._json.channel) {
-      return this.createModel(Channel, this._json.channel as v3.ChannelObject, { id: '', pointer: this.jsonPath('channel') });
+      const channelId = (this._json.channel as any)[xParserObjectUniqueId];
+      return this.createModel(Channel, this._json.channel as v3.ChannelObject, { id: channelId, pointer: this.jsonPath('channel') });
     }
     return this._json.channel;
   }
+
   messages(): MessagesInterface {
     return new Messages(
-      Object.entries(this._json.messages || {}).map(([messageName, message]) => {
-        return this.createModel(Message, message as v3.MessageObject, { id: messageName, pointer: this.jsonPath(`messages/${messageName}`) });
+      Object.values(this._json.messages ?? {}).map((message) => {
+        const messageId = (message as any)[xParserObjectUniqueId];
+        return this.createModel(Message, message as v3.MessageObject, { id: messageId, pointer: this.jsonPath(`messages/${messageId}`) });
       })
     );
   }

src/models/v3/operation.ts

@@ -17,6 +17,7 @@ import type { ServersInterface } from '../servers';
 import type { ServerInterface } from '../server';
 
 import type { v3 } from '../../spec-types';
+import { xParserObjectUniqueId } from '../../constants';
 
 export class Operation extends OperationTrait<v3.OperationObject> implements OperationInterface {
   action(): OperationAction {
@@ -48,23 +49,21 @@ export class Operation extends OperationTrait<v3.OperationObject> implements Ope
 
   channels(): ChannelsInterface {
     if (this._json.channel) {
-      for (const [channelName, channel] of Object.entries(this._meta.asyncapi?.parsed.channels || {})) {
-        if (channel === this._json.channel) {
-          return new Channels([
-            this.createModel(Channel, this._json.channel as v3.ChannelObject, { id: channelName, pointer: `/channels/${channelName}` })
-          ]);
-        }
-      }
+      const operationChannelId = (this._json.channel as any)[xParserObjectUniqueId];
+      return new Channels([
+        this.createModel(Channel, this._json.channel as v3.ChannelObject, { id: operationChannelId, pointer: `/channels/${operationChannelId}` })
+      ]);
     }
     return new Channels([]);
   }
-
+  
   messages(): MessagesInterface {
     const messages: MessageInterface[] = [];
     if (Array.isArray(this._json.messages)) {
       this._json.messages.forEach((message, index) => {
+        const messageId = (message as any)[xParserObjectUniqueId];
         messages.push(
-          this.createModel(Message, message as v3.MessageObject, { id: '', pointer: this.jsonPath(`messages/${index}`) })
+          this.createModel(Message, message as v3.MessageObject, { id: messageId, pointer: this.jsonPath(`messages/${index}`) })
         );
       });
       return new Messages(messages);

src/parse.ts

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 import { AsyncAPIDocumentInterface, ParserAPIVersion } from './models';
 
-import { customOperations } from './custom-operations';
+import { applyUniqueIds, customOperations } from './custom-operations';
 import { validate } from './validate';
 import { copy } from './stringify';
 import { createAsyncAPIDocument } from './document';
@@ -38,13 +38,26 @@ const defaultOptions: ParseOptions = {
   validateOptions: {},
   __unstable: {},
 };
-
+import yaml from 'js-yaml';
 export async function parse(parser: Parser, spectral: Spectral, asyncapi: Input, options: ParseOptions = {}): Promise<ParseOutput> {
   let spectralDocument: Document | undefined;
 
   try {
     options = mergePatch<ParseOptions>(defaultOptions, options);
-    const { validated, diagnostics, extras } = await validate(parser, spectral, asyncapi, { ...options.validateOptions, source: options.source, __unstable: options.__unstable });
+    // Normalize input to always be JSON 
+    let loadedObj;
+    if (typeof asyncapi === 'string') {
+      try {
+        loadedObj = yaml.load(asyncapi);
+      } catch (e) {
+        loadedObj = JSON.parse(asyncapi);
+      }
+    } else {
+      loadedObj = asyncapi;
+    }
+    // Apply unique ids before resolving references
+    applyUniqueIds(loadedObj);
+    const { validated, diagnostics, extras } = await validate(parser, spectral, loadedObj, { ...options.validateOptions, source: options.source, __unstable: options.__unstable });
     if (validated === undefined) {
       return {
         document: undefined,
@@ -58,12 +71,12 @@ export async function parse(parser: Parser, spectral: Spectral, asyncapi: Input,
 
     // unfreeze the object - Spectral makes resolved document "freezed" 
     const validatedDoc = copy(validated as Record<string, any>);
-    const detailed = createDetailedAsyncAPI(validatedDoc, asyncapi as DetailedAsyncAPI['input'], options.source);
+    const detailed = createDetailedAsyncAPI(validatedDoc, loadedObj as DetailedAsyncAPI['input'], options.source);
     const document = createAsyncAPIDocument(detailed);
     setExtension(xParserSpecParsed, true, document);
     setExtension(xParserApiVersion, ParserAPIVersion, document);
     await customOperations(parser, document, detailed, inventory, options);
-
+    
     return { 
       document,
       diagnostics,

src/spec-types/v3.ts

@@ -143,7 +143,7 @@ export interface OperationTraitObject extends SpecificationExtensions {
 
 export interface OperationReplyObject extends SpecificationExtensions {
   channel?: ChannelObject | ReferenceObject;
-  messages?: MessagesObject;
+  messages?: (MessageObject | ReferenceObject)[];
   address?: OperationReplyAddressObject | ReferenceObject;
 }