diff --git a/app/src/services/object.js b/app/src/services/object.js
index 3b9c1735..3bcc163d 100644
--- a/app/src/services/object.js
+++ b/app/src/services/object.js
@@ -210,6 +210,30 @@ const service = {
     }
   },
 
+  /**
+   * @function exists
+   * Checks if an object db record exists
+   * @param {string} objId The object uuid to read
+   * @param {object} [etrx=undefined] An optional Objection Transaction object
+   * @returns {Promise<object>} true if object exists in db, false otherwise
+   * @throws The error encountered upon db transaction failure
+   */
+  exists: async (objId, etrx = undefined) => {
+    let trx;
+    try {
+      trx = etrx ? etrx : await ObjectModel.startTransaction();
+
+      const response = await ObjectModel.query(trx).findById(objId);
+
+      if (!etrx) await trx.commit();
+
+      return Promise.resolve(response) ? true : false;
+    } catch (err) {
+      if (!etrx && trx) await trx.rollback();
+      throw err;
+    }
+  },
+
   /**
    * @function update
    * Update an object DB record
diff --git a/app/src/services/sync.js b/app/src/services/sync.js
index 1477e3d2..6598ff99 100644
--- a/app/src/services/sync.js
+++ b/app/src/services/sync.js
@@ -21,10 +21,12 @@ const service = {
    * @function _deriveObjectId
    * Checks an S3 Object for any previous `coms-id` tag traces and returns it if found.
    * Otherwise it writes a new `coms-id` to the S3 Object if none were previously found.
+   * If the `coms-id` conflicts with an existing COMS object, it is replaced with a new one.
    * @param {object | boolean} s3Object The result of an S3 HeadObject operation
    * @param {string} path String representing the canonical path for the specified object
    * @param {string | null} bucketId uuid of bucket or `null` if syncing object in default bucket
-   * @returns {Promise<string>} Resolves to an existing objectId or creates a new one
+   * @returns {Promise<string>} Resolves to an existing objectId (if not already in COMS)
+   *                            or creates a new one
    */
   _deriveObjectId: async (s3Object, path, bucketId) => {
     let objId = uuidv4();
@@ -32,12 +34,21 @@ const service = {
     if (typeof s3Object === 'object') { // If regular S3 Object
       const TagSet = await storageService.getObjectTagging({ filePath: path, bucketId: bucketId })
         .then(result => result.TagSet ?? []);
+
       const s3ObjectComsId = TagSet.find(obj => (obj.Key === 'coms-id'))?.Value;
 
-      if (s3ObjectComsId && uuidValidate(s3ObjectComsId)) {
+      if (s3ObjectComsId
+        && uuidValidate(s3ObjectComsId)
+        && !(await objectService.exists(s3ObjectComsId))) {
+        // re-use existing coms-id (if no conflict)
         objId = s3ObjectComsId;
-      } else { // Update S3 Object if there is still remaining space in the TagSet
-        if (TagSet.length < 10) { // putObjectTagging replaces S3 tags so new TagSet must contain existing values
+      } else {
+        // remove `coms-id` tag since it conflicts with an existing COMS object
+        TagSet.filter(x => x.Key != 'coms-id');
+
+        // Update S3 Object if there is still remaining space in the TagSet
+        if (TagSet.length < 10) {
+          // putObjectTagging replaces S3 tags so new TagSet must contain existing values
           await storageService.putObjectTagging({
             filePath: path,
             bucketId: bucketId,
@@ -175,7 +186,7 @@ const service = {
 
         // Case: not in COMS - insert new COMS object
         else {
-          const objId = await service._deriveObjectId(s3Object, path, bucketId);
+          let objId = await service._deriveObjectId(s3Object, path, bucketId);
 
           response = await objectService.create({
             id: objId,