feat: initial version #3
Conversation
WalkthroughThe pull request implements a comprehensive rebranding of the Changes
Poem
📜 Recent review detailsConfiguration used: CodeRabbit UI 📒 Files selected for processing (1)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 19
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (11)
examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yaml (1)
1-4: Add description and documentation for the stack configuration.While the configuration is valid, adding a description would help users understand the purpose of this example stack and its settings. Consider adding YAML comments to explain:
- The purpose of this example stack
- Why state management is enabled
- What the
enabledflag controlsHere's a suggested enhancement:
+# Example stack configuration for the random-pet component +# Demonstrates basic stack setup with state management stack_settings: + # Enable Spacelift to manage the Terraform state manage_state: true tfvars: + # Enable the random-pet component features enabled: trueexamples/complete/main.tf (3)
8-8: Remove temporary branch configuration.The TODO comment indicates this is a temporary configuration. Consider removing the branch parameter unless you specifically need to pin to a non-default branch.
- branch = "feature/initial-version" # TODO: remove this
9-9: Consider using a more intuitive path structure.The relative path
../../examples/complete/componentsmight be confusing for users. Consider restructuring to make the relationship between the example and its components more obvious, or add documentation explaining the path structure.
1-12: Add example documentation.Consider adding comments or a README in the examples directory to:
- Explain the purpose of this example configuration
- Document prerequisites (e.g., required AWS integration setup)
- Provide usage instructions
- List expected outcomes
examples/complete/context.tf (1)
81-166: LGTM! Consider adding input validation.The variables are well-defined with appropriate types and descriptions. Consider adding validation blocks for critical variables to enforce constraints at plan time.
Example validation for the
stagevariable:variable "stage" { type = string default = null description = "Stage, e.g. 'prod', 'staging', 'dev', OR 'source', 'build', 'test', 'deploy', 'release'" + validation { + condition = var.stage == null ? true : contains(["prod", "staging", "dev", "source", "build", "test", "deploy", "release"], var.stage) + error_message = "Stage must be one of: prod, staging, dev, source, build, test, deploy, release." + } }modules/spacelift-automation/context.tf (3)
1-20: Consider enhancing the header documentationWhile the header provides good context, consider adding:
- The specific version of the source file that was copied
- A versioned URL to the source file to ensure consistency
21-39: Consider updating to the latest module versionThe module uses version 0.24.1 of cloudposse/label/null. Consider updating to the latest stable version (0.25.0) to get the latest features and security updates.
148-155: Enhance regex_replace_chars documentationThe description mentions a default value (
"/[^a-zA-Z0-9-]/") but this isn't reflected in the actual default value which isnull. Consider making this more explicit in the description or setting it as the actual default.modules/spacelift-automation/README.md (2)
89-89: Convert TODO comment into a tracked issue.The TODO comment about creating a wrapper for automation using Taskit should be tracked properly.
Would you like me to create a GitHub issue to track this TODO item? This will help ensure the task is properly tracked and not lost in the documentation.
75-77: Fix inconsistent list style markers.The unordered list uses asterisks (*) while the rest of the document uses dashes (-). This inconsistency was flagged by markdownlint.
Apply this diff to maintain consistent list style:
-* Common configuration set in `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/stacks/common.yaml` are applied to both Stacks. -* However, if there is an override in a Stack config, it takes precedence over common configs. -* Corresponding Terraform variables are generated by [Initialization Hook](https://docs.spacelift.io/concepts/run#initializing) and placed in the root of each Stack's working directory during each run or task. For example, the content of the file `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/tfvars/dev.tfvars` will be copied to the Stack `spacelift-aws-role-dev` as file `spacelift.auto.tfvars` allowing the OpenTofu/Terraform inputs to be automatically loaded. +- Common configuration set in `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/stacks/common.yaml` are applied to both Stacks. +- However, if there is an override in a Stack config, it takes precedence over common configs. +- Corresponding Terraform variables are generated by [Initialization Hook](https://docs.spacelift.io/concepts/run#initializing) and placed in the root of each Stack's working directory during each run or task. For example, the content of the file `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/tfvars/dev.tfvars` will be copied to the Stack `spacelift-aws-role-dev` as file `spacelift.auto.tfvars` allowing the OpenTofu/Terraform inputs to be automatically loaded.🧰 Tools
🪛 Markdownlint
75-75: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
76-76: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
77-77: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1)
83-83: Simplify boolean comparison in '_administrative_labels'The comparison
tobool(try(configs.administrative, false)) == truecan be simplified.Since
toboolalready returns a boolean, you can simplify the condition:for stack, configs in local.stack_configs : stack => ["administrative"] if - tobool(try(configs.administrative, false)) == true + tobool(try(configs.administrative, false))
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (21)
- README.md (1 hunks)
- context.tf (0 hunks)
- examples/complete/.terraform.lock.hcl (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/common.yaml (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yaml (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/tfvars/example.tfvars (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/variables.tf (0 hunks)
- examples/complete/context.tf (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/fixtures.auto.tfvars (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/main.tf (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/outputs.tf (0 hunks)
- examples/complete/providers.tf (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/variables.tf (0 hunks)
- examples/complete/versions.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/README.md (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/context.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/providers.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/versions.tf (1 hunks)
- outputs.tf (0 hunks)
💤 Files with no reviewable changes (5)
- context.tf
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/variables.tf
- examples/complete/outputs.tf
- examples/complete/variables.tf
- outputs.tf
✅ Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (7)
- examples/complete/.terraform.lock.hcl
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/tfvars/example.tfvars
- examples/complete/fixtures.auto.tfvars
- examples/complete/providers.tf
- examples/complete/versions.tf
- modules/spacelift-automation/providers.tf
- modules/spacelift-automation/versions.tf
🧰 Additional context used
🪛 LanguageTool
README.md
[grammar] ~5-~5: The verb form ‘provides’ does not seem to match the subject ‘collections’.
Context: ...est) This Terraform module collections provides infrastructure automation for projects ...(SUBJECT_VERB_AGREEMENT_PLURAL)
🪛 Markdownlint
modules/spacelift-automation/README.md
75-75: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
76-76: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
77-77: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
🔇 Additional comments (7)
examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yaml (1)
1-2: Verify state management configuration.The
manage_state: truesetting indicates that Spacelift will manage the Terraform state. This is a critical setting that affects state handling.Let's verify if this follows the repository's state management patterns:
✅ Verification successful
State management configuration is consistent across stack definitions
The verification shows that
manage_state: trueis consistently configured across both stack files in the random-pet component:
examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yamlexamples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/common.yaml🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for other stack configurations to verify consistent state management patterns rg -t yaml "manage_state:" --glob "examples/**/stacks/*.yaml"Length of output: 222
examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/common.yaml (1)
4-5: Verify the impact of disabled state.The stack is disabled by default while example.yaml has it enabled. Let's verify this is intentional and doesn't cause issues.
✅ Verification successful
No issues with disabled state in common.yaml
This is an intentional and valid configuration pattern. The
common.yamlserves as a base configuration with the feature disabled by default, whileexample.yamldemonstrates how to enable it. This is a common practice for example components where:
- Base configuration (
common.yaml) keeps features disabled by default for safety- Example configuration (
example.yaml) shows how to enable and use the feature🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for any dependencies on this stack in other configurations # Look for references to this stack in other YAML files echo "Checking for stack dependencies..." rg -l "depends_on.*random-pet" --type yaml # Check if there are any other tfvars configurations that might conflict echo "Checking for related tfvars configurations..." rg "enabled:.*(?:true|false)" --type yaml ./examples/complete/components/random-pet/Length of output: 467
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check the content of both files to understand their relationship and configuration structure echo "Content of common.yaml:" cat ./examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/common.yaml echo -e "\nContent of example.yaml:" cat ./examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yaml # Also check if there's any documentation or README that explains the purpose echo -e "\nChecking for README or documentation:" fd README.md ./examples/complete/components/random-pet/Length of output: 581
examples/complete/main.tf (1)
9-10: Consider expanding the example with more root modules.The example currently only enables a single "random-pet" module. Consider adding more diverse root modules to better demonstrate the module's capabilities and typical usage patterns.
Let's check what other root modules are available:
✅ Verification successful
The review comment is appropriate - only one example module exists
The verification confirms that:
- Only one root module (
random-pet) exists in the components directory- No other example modules are currently available to demonstrate the module's capabilities
- The suggestion to add more diverse root modules would indeed help showcase the module's functionality better
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # List available modules in the components directory fd . "../../examples/complete/components" --type d --max-depth 1Length of output: 186
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's correct the path and search from the repository root fd . "examples/complete/components" --type d --max-depth 1Length of output: 99
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Also check if there are any Terraform files in the components directory fd -e tf . "examples/complete/components"Length of output: 194
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's also check the content of the main.tf to understand the context better cat examples/complete/main.tfLength of output: 450
examples/complete/context.tf (2)
43-79: LGTM! Well-structured context variable definition.The context variable is well-defined with:
- Comprehensive object structure
- Appropriate default values
- Clear documentation explaining the override behavior
21-39: Verify module version is up to date.The module uses version 0.24.1 of cloudposse/label/null. Let's verify if this is the latest stable version.
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check if we're using the latest stable version of the module # Get latest version from Terraform registry curl -s https://registry.terraform.io/v1/modules/cloudposse/label/null/versions | jq -r '.versions[] | select(.version | test("^[0-9]+\\.[0-9]+\\.[0-9]+$")) | .version' | sort -V | tail -n 1modules/spacelift-automation/context.tf (1)
1-168: Overall implementation looks good!The file provides a solid foundation for label management following Cloud Posse's standards. The implementation is well-structured with comprehensive documentation and appropriate default values.
modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1)
205-207: Clarify the use of 'destructor_enabled'The comments suggest not toggling the creation of the destructor resource with
var.destructor_enabled, yetdeactivatedis set based on this variable. This might lead to confusion or unintended behavior.Please verify that setting
deactivated = !try(local.stack_configs[each.key].destructor_enabled, var.destructor_enabled)aligns with your intended logic. If the intention is to control deactivation viadestructor_enabled, consider updating the comments for clarity.
gberenice
force-pushed
the
feature/initial-version
branch
from
fb25ee9 to
0f6c918
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 9
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (8)
README.md (2)
5-5: Enhance module documentationThe description is too brief for an initial version. Consider adding essential sections:
- Detailed feature list of automation capabilities
- Usage examples
- Requirements and prerequisites
- Input variables and their descriptions
- Output values
- Architecture diagram (if applicable)
This will help users understand how to use this module effectively.
Would you like me to help generate a template for these documentation sections?
🧰 Tools
🪛 LanguageTool
[grammar] ~5-~5: The verb form ‘provides’ does not seem to match the subject ‘collections’.
Context: ...est) This Terraform module collections provides infrastructure automation for projects ...(SUBJECT_VERB_AGREEMENT_PLURAL)
Line range hint
9-9: Replace TODO placeholder with actual issues URLThe link to open issues contains a TODO placeholder.
-Found an issue or want to request a feature? [Open an issue](TODO) +Found an issue or want to request a feature? [Open an issue](https://github.com/masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation/issues/new/choose)🧰 Tools
🪛 LanguageTool
[grammar] ~5-~5: The verb form ‘provides’ does not seem to match the subject ‘collections’.
Context: ...est) This Terraform module collections provides infrastructure automation for projects ...(SUBJECT_VERB_AGREEMENT_PLURAL)
modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (1)
235-242: Enhance worker_pool_id description.The description could be more specific about when worker_pool_id is required and its implications.
variable "worker_pool_id" { type = string description = <<-EOT - ID of the worker pool to use. - NOTE: worker_pool_id is required when using a self-hosted instance of Spacelift. + ID of the worker pool to use for running Terraform operations. + NOTE: worker_pool_id is required when: + 1. Using a self-hosted instance of Spacelift + 2. Running operations that require specific compute resources or network access + 3. Implementing custom security or compliance requirements EOT default = null }modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1)
97-101: Potential circular dependency in stack dependenciesThe
_dependency_labelscreates dependencies onspacelift-automation-${terraform.workspace}for all stacks. This could create circular dependencies if the automation stack itself is managed by this module.Consider:
- Making the dependency optional
- Adding validation to prevent circular dependencies
- Documenting the dependency requirements clearly
modules/spacelift-automation/README.md (4)
26-26: Fix typo in documentation."opiniated" should be "opinionated".
-Spacelift Automation logic is pretty opiniated and heavily relies on the Git repository structure. +Spacelift Automation logic is pretty opinionated and heavily relies on the Git repository structure.
89-89: Remove internal team note from public documentation.The TODO note appears to be an internal comment for the Masterpoint team. Consider moving this to an internal tracking system or issue.
-NOTE to Masterpoint team: We might want to create a small wrapper to automatize this using Taskit.
83-87: Clarify OpenTofu vs Terraform usage in bootstrap instructions.The module uses OpenTofu as the default workflow tool (line 179), but the bootstrap instructions only mention Terraform. Consider updating the documentation to clearly indicate both options.
-1. Create a vanilla OpenTofu/Terraform configuration for this module. -1. Create OpenTofu/Terraform workspace that will be used for your Automation configuration. -1. Apply the vanilla OpenTofu/Terraform configuration. +1. Create a vanilla configuration for this module using either OpenTofu (default) or Terraform. +1. Create a workspace that will be used for your Automation configuration. +1. Apply the configuration.
75-77: Maintain consistent list style markers.The list uses asterisks (*) while other lists in the document use dashes (-). Maintain consistency by using dashes throughout the document.
-* Common configuration set in `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/stacks/common.yaml` are applied to both Stacks. -* However, if there is an override in a Stack config, it takes precedence over common configs. -* Corresponding Terraform variables are generated by [Initialization Hook](https://docs.spacelift.io/concepts/run#initializing) and placed in the root of each Stack's working directory during each run or task. +- Common configuration set in `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/stacks/common.yaml` are applied to both Stacks. +- However, if there is an override in a Stack config, it takes precedence over common configs. +- Corresponding Terraform variables are generated by [Initialization Hook](https://docs.spacelift.io/concepts/run#initializing) and placed in the root of each Stack's working directory during each run or task.🧰 Tools
🪛 Markdownlint
75-75: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
76-76: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
77-77: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (16)
- README.md (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/common.yaml (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yaml (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/tfvars/example.tfvars (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/variables.tf (0 hunks)
- examples/complete/fixtures.auto.tfvars (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/main.tf (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/outputs.tf (0 hunks)
- examples/complete/providers.tf (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/variables.tf (0 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/README.md (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/context.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/providers.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/versions.tf (1 hunks)
💤 Files with no reviewable changes (3)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/variables.tf
- examples/complete/outputs.tf
- examples/complete/variables.tf
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (8)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/common.yaml
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yaml
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/tfvars/example.tfvars
- examples/complete/fixtures.auto.tfvars
- examples/complete/main.tf
- examples/complete/providers.tf
- modules/spacelift-automation/providers.tf
- modules/spacelift-automation/versions.tf
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (1)
Learnt from: gberenice PR: masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation#3 File: modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf:54-64 Timestamp: 2024-10-28T12:47:36.579Z Learning: In the `spacelift-automation` module, the variable `aws_integration_attachment_write` has a default value of `true`, which matches the default value in the provider.
🪛 LanguageTool
README.md
[grammar] ~5-~5: The verb form ‘provides’ does not seem to match the subject ‘collections’.
Context: ...est) This Terraform module collections provides infrastructure automation for projects ...(SUBJECT_VERB_AGREEMENT_PLURAL)
🪛 Markdownlint
modules/spacelift-automation/README.md
75-75: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
76-76: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
77-77: Expected: dash; Actual: asterisk
Unordered list style(MD004, ul-style)
🔇 Additional comments (5)
README.md (1)
1-3: LGTM!The repository name and badge URL have been updated consistently.
modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (3)
153-160: LGTM! Well-structured deep merge implementationThe deep merge implementation using the cloudposse module is clean and version-pinned appropriately.
31-36: Add error handling for YAML file operationsThe
filesetandyamldecodeoperations could fail silently if files are missing or malformed. Consider adding validation or error handling.
141-150: Review security implications of file copying in before_initThe
cpcommand inbefore_initassumes the existence of source files and directories. This could lead to failures or potential security risks if paths are manipulated.modules/spacelift-automation/README.md (1)
182-184: Add useful outputs to the module.The module still lacks outputs that would be valuable for users. This issue was previously raised and remains unaddressed.
gberenice
force-pushed
the
feature/initial-version
branch
from
0f6c918 to
4d367d9
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 6
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
modules/spacelift-automation/context.tf (1)
23-26: Consider documenting Terraform version requirementsThe module uses
cloudposse/label/nullversion 0.25.0 which requires Terraform >= 0.13.0. Consider adding this requirement to the module's documentation to help users avoid compatibility issues.modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1)
1-26: Consider enhancing documentation with YAML configuration examplesWhile the documentation clearly explains the module's functionality, it would be helpful to include example YAML configurations for both stack and common configurations to demonstrate the expected structure.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (16)
- README.md (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/common.yaml (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yaml (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/tfvars/example.tfvars (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/variables.tf (0 hunks)
- examples/complete/fixtures.auto.tfvars (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/main.tf (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/outputs.tf (0 hunks)
- examples/complete/providers.tf (1 hunks)
- examples/complete/variables.tf (0 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/README.md (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/context.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/providers.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/versions.tf (1 hunks)
💤 Files with no reviewable changes (3)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/variables.tf
- examples/complete/outputs.tf
- examples/complete/variables.tf
✅ Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- examples/complete/fixtures.auto.tfvars
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (9)
- README.md
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/common.yaml
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yaml
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/tfvars/example.tfvars
- examples/complete/main.tf
- examples/complete/providers.tf
- modules/spacelift-automation/README.md
- modules/spacelift-automation/providers.tf
- modules/spacelift-automation/versions.tf
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (1)
Learnt from: gberenice PR: masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation#3 File: modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf:54-64 Timestamp: 2024-10-28T12:47:36.579Z Learning: In the `spacelift-automation` module, the variable `aws_integration_attachment_write` has a default value of `true`, which matches the default value in the provider.
🔇 Additional comments (3)
modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (2)
33-46: LGTM! Well-structured workflow tool configuration.The variable has proper validation for allowed values and clear documentation.
66-155: LGTM! Well-structured stack configuration.The variables have consistent defaults and clear documentation. The script hooks follow a consistent pattern with empty array defaults.
modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1)
31-36:⚠️ Potential issueUse
filepath.Joinfor safe path handlingThe current path concatenation using string interpolation could be unsafe. Consider using a more robust path handling approach.
- "${path.root}/${var.root_modules_path}/${module}/stacks/${yaml_file}" + "${abspath(join("/", [path.root, var.root_modules_path, module, "stacks", yaml_file]))}"
| variable "github_enterprise" { | ||
| type = object({ | ||
| namespace = string | ||
| id = optional(string) | ||
| }) | ||
| description = "The GitHub VCS settings" | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add validation for GitHub namespace format.
Consider adding validation to ensure the namespace follows GitHub's organization naming conventions.
variable "github_enterprise" {
type = object({
namespace = string
id = optional(string)
})
description = "The GitHub VCS settings"
+ validation {
+ condition = can(regex("^[a-zA-Z0-9](?:[a-zA-Z0-9]|-(?=[a-zA-Z0-9])){0,38}$", var.github_enterprise.namespace))
+ error_message = "GitHub namespace must follow organization naming rules: up to 39 chars, alphanumeric or single hyphens, and cannot start with a hyphen."
+ }
}📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| variable "github_enterprise" { | |
| type = object({ | |
| namespace = string | |
| id = optional(string) | |
| }) | |
| description = "The GitHub VCS settings" | |
| } | |
| variable "github_enterprise" { | |
| type = object({ | |
| namespace = string | |
| id = optional(string) | |
| }) | |
| description = "The GitHub VCS settings" | |
| validation { | |
| condition = can(regex("^[a-zA-Z0-9](?:[a-zA-Z0-9]|-(?=[a-zA-Z0-9])){0,38}$", var.github_enterprise.namespace)) | |
| error_message = "GitHub namespace must follow organization naming rules: up to 39 chars, alphanumeric or single hyphens, and cannot start with a hyphen." | |
| } | |
| } |
| variable "descriptor_formats" { | ||
| type = any | ||
| default = {} | ||
| description = <<-EOT | ||
| Describe additional descriptors to be output in the `descriptors` output map. | ||
| Map of maps. Keys are names of descriptors. Values are maps of the form | ||
| `{ | ||
| format = string | ||
| labels = list(string) | ||
| }` | ||
| (Type is `any` so the map values can later be enhanced to provide additional options.) | ||
| `format` is a Terraform format string to be passed to the `format()` function. | ||
| `labels` is a list of labels, in order, to pass to `format()` function. | ||
| Label values will be normalized before being passed to `format()` so they will be | ||
| identical to how they appear in `id`. | ||
| Default is `{}` (`descriptors` output will be empty). | ||
| EOT | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add validation for descriptor_formats variable
While the variable description clearly defines the expected structure, consider adding validation to ensure the input matches the required format:
format = string
labels = list(string)Add this validation block to enforce the structure:
variable "descriptor_formats" {
# ... existing configuration ...
validation {
condition = alltrue([
for k, v in var.descriptor_formats :
try(
can(v.format) && can(v.labels) &&
type(v.format) == "string" &&
type(v.labels) == "list"
, false)
])
error_message = "Each descriptor must contain 'format' (string) and 'labels' (list) attributes."
}
}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@gberenice big review, but this is looking awesome. Excited to ship it!
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 7
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (1)
21-25: Enhance root_modules_path description.
The description should provide more context about the expected directory structure and its purpose in the module.
variable "root_modules_path" {
type = string
- description = "The path, relative to the root of the repository, where the root module can be found."
+ description = <<-EOT
+ The path, relative to the root of the repository, where root modules are located.
+ This directory should contain subdirectories for each root module, each potentially containing its own stack configuration.
+ Example: "root-modules/prod", "root-modules/staging"
+ EOT
default = "root-modules"
}modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1)
224-230: Consider using a version range constraint
Using a fixed version (1.0.2) might make it difficult to adopt bug fixes or minor improvements.
Consider using a version range constraint:
module "deep" {
source = "cloudposse/config/yaml//modules/deepmerge"
- version = "1.0.2"
+ version = "~> 1.0"
for_each = local.root_module_stack_configs
maps = [local.common_configs[each.value.root_module], each.value]
}📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (3)
- modules/spacelift-automation/README.md (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1 hunks)
- modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- modules/spacelift-automation/README.md
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (1)
Learnt from: gberenice
PR: masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation#3
File: modules/spacelift-automation/variables.tf:54-64
Timestamp: 2024-10-28T12:47:36.579Z
Learning: In the `spacelift-automation` module, the variable `aws_integration_attachment_write` has a default value of `true`, which matches the default value in the provider.
🔇 Additional comments (1)
modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1)
1-317: Overall implementation looks solid! 👍
The code demonstrates good practices in terms of:
- Comprehensive documentation
- Proper error handling
- Flexible configuration management
- Consistent resource naming
modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf
Outdated
| resource "spacelift_stack" "default" { | ||
| for_each = local.enabled ? local.stacks : toset([]) | ||
|
|
||
| space_id = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].space_id, null), var.space_id) | ||
| name = each.key | ||
| administrative = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].administrative, null), var.administrative) | ||
| after_apply = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_apply, []), var.after_apply)) | ||
| after_destroy = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_destroy, []), var.after_destroy)) | ||
| after_init = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_init, []), var.after_init)) | ||
| after_perform = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_perform, []), var.after_perform)) | ||
| after_plan = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_plan, []), var.after_plan)) | ||
| autodeploy = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].autodeploy, null), var.autodeploy) | ||
| autoretry = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].autoretry, var.autoretry) | ||
| before_apply = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_apply, []), var.before_apply)) | ||
| before_destroy = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_destroy, []), var.before_destroy)) | ||
| before_init = compact(coalesce(try(local.before_init[each.key], []), var.before_init)) | ||
| before_perform = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_perform, []), var.before_perform)) | ||
| before_plan = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_plan, []), var.before_plan)) | ||
| description = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].description, null), var.description) | ||
| repository = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].repository, var.repository) | ||
| branch = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].branch, var.branch) | ||
| project_root = local.configs[each.key].project_root | ||
| manage_state = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].manage_state, var.manage_state) | ||
| labels = local.labels[each.key] | ||
| enable_local_preview = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].enable_local_preview, var.enable_local_preview) | ||
| terraform_smart_sanitization = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].terraform_smart_sanitization, var.terraform_smart_sanitization) | ||
| tf_version = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].tf_version, var.tf_version) | ||
| terraform_workflow_tool = var.terraform_workflow_tool | ||
| terraform_workspace = local.configs[each.key].terraform_workspace | ||
|
|
||
| protect_from_deletion = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].protect_from_deletion, var.protect_from_deletion) | ||
|
|
||
| worker_pool_id = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].worker_pool_id, var.worker_pool_id) | ||
|
|
||
| dynamic "github_enterprise" { | ||
| for_each = var.github_enterprise != null ? [var.github_enterprise] : [] | ||
| content { | ||
| namespace = github_enterprise.value["namespace"] | ||
| } | ||
| } | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add preconditions for critical stack attributes
Consider adding lifecycle preconditions to validate critical attributes before creating the stack.
Add validations for critical attributes:
resource "spacelift_stack" "default" {
# ... existing configuration ...
+ lifecycle {
+ precondition {
+ condition = can(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].space_id, null), var.space_id))
+ error_message = "space_id must be provided either in stack configuration or as a variable"
+ }
+ precondition {
+ condition = can(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].repository, null), var.repository))
+ error_message = "repository must be provided either in stack configuration or as a variable"
+ }
+ precondition {
+ condition = length(local.labels[each.key]) > 0
+ error_message = "at least one label must be provided for the stack"
+ }
+ }
}📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| resource "spacelift_stack" "default" { | |
| for_each = local.enabled ? local.stacks : toset([]) | |
| space_id = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].space_id, null), var.space_id) | |
| name = each.key | |
| administrative = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].administrative, null), var.administrative) | |
| after_apply = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_apply, []), var.after_apply)) | |
| after_destroy = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_destroy, []), var.after_destroy)) | |
| after_init = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_init, []), var.after_init)) | |
| after_perform = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_perform, []), var.after_perform)) | |
| after_plan = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_plan, []), var.after_plan)) | |
| autodeploy = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].autodeploy, null), var.autodeploy) | |
| autoretry = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].autoretry, var.autoretry) | |
| before_apply = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_apply, []), var.before_apply)) | |
| before_destroy = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_destroy, []), var.before_destroy)) | |
| before_init = compact(coalesce(try(local.before_init[each.key], []), var.before_init)) | |
| before_perform = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_perform, []), var.before_perform)) | |
| before_plan = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_plan, []), var.before_plan)) | |
| description = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].description, null), var.description) | |
| repository = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].repository, var.repository) | |
| branch = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].branch, var.branch) | |
| project_root = local.configs[each.key].project_root | |
| manage_state = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].manage_state, var.manage_state) | |
| labels = local.labels[each.key] | |
| enable_local_preview = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].enable_local_preview, var.enable_local_preview) | |
| terraform_smart_sanitization = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].terraform_smart_sanitization, var.terraform_smart_sanitization) | |
| tf_version = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].tf_version, var.tf_version) | |
| terraform_workflow_tool = var.terraform_workflow_tool | |
| terraform_workspace = local.configs[each.key].terraform_workspace | |
| protect_from_deletion = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].protect_from_deletion, var.protect_from_deletion) | |
| worker_pool_id = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].worker_pool_id, var.worker_pool_id) | |
| dynamic "github_enterprise" { | |
| for_each = var.github_enterprise != null ? [var.github_enterprise] : [] | |
| content { | |
| namespace = github_enterprise.value["namespace"] | |
| } | |
| } | |
| } | |
| resource "spacelift_stack" "default" { | |
| for_each = local.enabled ? local.stacks : toset([]) | |
| space_id = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].space_id, null), var.space_id) | |
| name = each.key | |
| administrative = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].administrative, null), var.administrative) | |
| after_apply = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_apply, []), var.after_apply)) | |
| after_destroy = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_destroy, []), var.after_destroy)) | |
| after_init = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_init, []), var.after_init)) | |
| after_perform = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_perform, []), var.after_perform)) | |
| after_plan = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_plan, []), var.after_plan)) | |
| autodeploy = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].autodeploy, null), var.autodeploy) | |
| autoretry = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].autoretry, var.autoretry) | |
| before_apply = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_apply, []), var.before_apply)) | |
| before_destroy = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_destroy, []), var.before_destroy)) | |
| before_init = compact(coalesce(try(local.before_init[each.key], []), var.before_init)) | |
| before_perform = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_perform, []), var.before_perform)) | |
| before_plan = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_plan, []), var.before_plan)) | |
| description = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].description, null), var.description) | |
| repository = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].repository, var.repository) | |
| branch = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].branch, var.branch) | |
| project_root = local.configs[each.key].project_root | |
| manage_state = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].manage_state, var.manage_state) | |
| labels = local.labels[each.key] | |
| enable_local_preview = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].enable_local_preview, var.enable_local_preview) | |
| terraform_smart_sanitization = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].terraform_smart_sanitization, var.terraform_smart_sanitization) | |
| tf_version = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].tf_version, var.tf_version) | |
| terraform_workflow_tool = var.terraform_workflow_tool | |
| terraform_workspace = local.configs[each.key].terraform_workspace | |
| protect_from_deletion = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].protect_from_deletion, var.protect_from_deletion) | |
| worker_pool_id = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].worker_pool_id, var.worker_pool_id) | |
| dynamic "github_enterprise" { | |
| for_each = var.github_enterprise != null ? [var.github_enterprise] : [] | |
| content { | |
| namespace = github_enterprise.value["namespace"] | |
| } | |
| } | |
| lifecycle { | |
| precondition { | |
| condition = can(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].space_id, null), var.space_id)) | |
| error_message = "space_id must be provided either in stack configuration or as a variable" | |
| } | |
| precondition { | |
| condition = can(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].repository, null), var.repository)) | |
| error_message = "repository must be provided either in stack configuration or as a variable" | |
| } | |
| precondition { | |
| condition = length(local.labels[each.key]) > 0 | |
| error_message = "at least one label must be provided for the stack" | |
| } | |
| } | |
| } |
gberenice
force-pushed
the
feature/initial-version
branch
from
ae4fe7c to
4302523
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 13
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (14)
examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/example.yaml (1)
1-2: Consider enhancing the stack description.While the description indicates this is for testing purposes, it would be more helpful to specify what aspects of Masterpoint's testing this stack covers (e.g., specific features, scenarios, or environments).
stack_settings: - description: This Automation stack is used for Masterpoint's testing purposes + description: This Automation stack demonstrates Spacelift configuration capabilities and is used for Masterpoint's integration testingversions.tf (1)
5-11: Provider configurations look good.The provider configurations are appropriate for the module's requirements. The Spacelift provider is essential for core functionality, and the external provider will be useful for YAML configuration processing.
Consider adding comments above each provider block to document their specific purposes in the module, especially for the external provider's role in YAML processing.
required_providers { + # Core provider for Spacelift automation functionality spacelift = { source = "spacelift-io/spacelift" version = ">= 1.14" } + # Used for processing YAML configurations external = { source = "hashicorp/external" version = ">= 2.0" }examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1)
1-12: Add descriptive comments to the exampleSince this is an example implementation that users will likely reference, consider adding comments to explain:
- The purpose of this example module
- Key configuration choices made
- Expected outcomes
Example addition:
+# This example demonstrates the basic usage of the spacelift-automation module +# with GitHub Enterprise integration and AWS integration enabled. +# It showcases the recommended way to organize your Spacelift automation +# following our opinionated structure. + module "automation" { source = "../../../../" # ... rest of the configurationdata.tf (1)
8-11: Remove or update commented codeThe commented output block should either be removed or updated to match the current implementation. If it's meant for debugging, consider adding it to examples instead.
-# # Output the list of directories -# output "directories" { -# value = data.external.list_directories[0].result -# }examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (2)
1-7: Remove unnecessary commented variable references.These commented-out variable references don't provide additional value and could be confusing to users. Consider removing them as the variable declarations below are self-documenting with proper descriptions.
-# github_enterprise = var.github_enterprise -# repository = var.repository -# branch = var.branch -# root_modules_path = var.root_modules_path -# enabled_root_modules = var.enable_all_root_modules -# aws_integration_id = var.aws_integration_id -
33-36: Enhance the repository variable description.Consider providing more context in the description about the expected repository format and its relationship with the GitHub Enterprise namespace.
variable "repository" { type = string - description = "The name of your infrastructure repo" + description = "The name of your infrastructure repository (e.g., 'infrastructure-live'). This should be the repository name without the namespace, as the namespace is specified in the github_enterprise variable." }variables.tf (3)
27-35: Enhance documentation for enabled_root_modules variableThe description could be more specific about the relationship between these paths and root_modules_path variable.
description = <<-EOT - List of root modules where to look for stack config files. + List of subdirectories within root_modules_path where to look for stack config files. Ignored when enable_all_root_modules is true. Example: ["spacelift-automation", "k8s-cluster"] EOT
43-56: Enhance documentation for terraform_workflow_tool CUSTOM optionThe description should clarify what the CUSTOM option entails and when it should be used.
description = <<-EOT Defines the tool that will be used to execute the workflow. This can be one of OPEN_TOFU, TERRAFORM_FOSS or CUSTOM. + CUSTOM allows for using a custom version of Terraform/OpenTofu specified through other means. EOT
245-251: Enhance worker_pool_id documentationThe documentation should clarify the implications for cloud-hosted Spacelift instances.
description = <<-EOT ID of the worker pool to use. NOTE: worker_pool_id is required when using a self-hosted instance of Spacelift. + For cloud-hosted Spacelift instances, this can be left as null to use the default worker pool. EOTREADME.md (4)
94-94: Fix line wrapping in FAQ answer.The explanation about tfvars would be more readable if properly wrapped.
-This is to support easy local and outside-spacelift operations. Keeping variable values in a `tfvars` file per workspace allows you to simply pass that file to the relevant CLI command locally via the `-var-file` option so that you don't need to provide values individually. +This is to support easy local and outside-spacelift operations. Keeping variable values in a `tfvars` +file per workspace allows you to simply pass that file to the relevant CLI command locally via the +`-var-file` option so that you don't need to provide values individually.
100-100: Clarify the vanilla OpenTofu/Terraform explanation.The explanation of "vanilla" configuration is embedded in the numbered list item, making it harder to understand.
-1. Create a new vanilla OpenTofu/Terraform root module that consumes this child module and supplies the necessary configuration for your unique setup. In other words, it's a configuration that uses the default capabilities of either OpenTofu or Terraform without any customization, or third-party tools or plugins. +1. Create a new vanilla OpenTofu/Terraform root module that consumes this child module and supplies the necessary configuration for your unique setup. + + Note: A "vanilla" configuration uses the default capabilities of either OpenTofu or Terraform without any customization or third-party tools/plugins.
86-88: Improve clarity of configuration precedence explanation.The explanation of configuration precedence could be clearer with bullet points.
-Stacks track changes in GitHub repo `github.com/masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation`, branch `main` (the default), and directrory `root-modules`. -Common configuration is defined in `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/stacks/common.yaml` and applied to both Stacks. However, if there is an override in a Stack config (e.g. `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/stacks/dev.yaml`), it takes precedence over common configs. -Corresponding Terraform variables are generated by an [Initialization Hook](https://docs.spacelift.io/concepts/run#initializing) and placed in the root of each Stack's working directory during each run or task. For example, the content of the file `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/tfvars/dev.tfvars` will be copied to working directory of the Stack `spacelift-aws-role-dev` as file `spacelift.auto.tfvars` allowing the OpenTofu/Terraform inputs to be automatically loaded. +The stacks are configured as follows: + +* Source Control: + - GitHub Repository: `github.com/masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation` + - Default Branch: `main` + - Tracked Directory: `root-modules` + +* Configuration Precedence: + 1. Stack-specific config (e.g. `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/stacks/dev.yaml`) + 2. Common config (`root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/stacks/common.yaml`) + +* Variable Loading: + - An [Initialization Hook](https://docs.spacelift.io/concepts/run#initializing) copies tfvars files + - Example: `root-modules/spacelift-aws-role/tfvars/dev.tfvars` → `spacelift.auto.tfvars` + - Location: Root of each Stack's working directory + - Timing: During each run or task
24-25: Enhance repository structure explanation.The explanation of the repository structure requirements could be more prominent.
-Spacelift Automation logic is opinionated and heavily relies on the Git repository structure. -This module is configured to track all the files in the provided root module directory and create the stack based on the provided configuration (if any). +# Repository Structure Requirements + +The Spacelift Automation module is opinionated and requires a specific Git repository structure: + +* The module tracks all files in the provided root module directory +* Stacks are created based on the provided configuration (if present)main.tf (1)
243-243: Handle missingbefore_initcommands gracefullyThe
before_initattribute accesseslocal.before_init[each.key], which might be undefined iftfvars.enabledisfalsefor a stack. Although thetryfunction is used, it's good practice to ensure the key exists to prevent unexpected behaviors.Consider initializing
local.before_initwith empty lists for all stacks to ensure consistency:before_init = { for stack in local.stacks : stack => compact(concat( var.before_init, try(local.stack_configs[stack].before_init, []), ["cp tfvars/${local.configs[stack].terraform_workspace}.tfvars spacelift.auto.tfvars"], )) if try(local.configs[stack].tfvars.enabled, false) + else [] }
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (17)
.gitignore(1 hunks)README.md(1 hunks)data.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/random-pet/versions.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/.terraform.lock.hcl(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/backend.tf.json(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/main.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/common.yaml(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/example.yaml(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/tfvars/example.tfvars(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/variables.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/versions.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/main.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/versions.tf(1 hunks)main.tf(1 hunks)variables.tf(1 hunks)versions.tf(1 hunks)
✅ Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (7)
- .gitignore
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/versions.tf
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/.terraform.lock.hcl
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/backend.tf.json
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/common.yaml
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/tfvars/example.tfvars
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/versions.tf
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (2)
- examples/complete/main.tf
- examples/complete/versions.tf
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (1)
Learnt from: Gowiem
PR: masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation#3
File: modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf:221-227
Timestamp: 2024-10-29T00:06:05.693Z
Learning: In the Terraform module `modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf`, when `var.aws_integration_id` is a required variable, avoid suggesting to make the `spacelift_aws_integration_attachment` resource conditional based on whether `aws_integration_id` is provided.
🔇 Additional comments (9)
versions.tf (1)
2-2: Verify the Terraform 1.6+ requirement rationale.
The requirement for Terraform 1.6+ is relatively recent and might limit adoption. While this is acceptable for an initial release, please ensure there are specific features from 1.6+ that are necessary for this module.
Consider documenting the specific Terraform 1.6+ features that this module depends on in the README.
examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/main.tf (1)
11-11: Consider making AWS integration optional
As per the PR description question about making AWS integration optional, this example shows it as a required parameter. Consider implementing conditional AWS integration to provide more flexibility for users who might not need AWS integration.
Let's check if AWS integration is required in the root module:
data.tf (1)
1-7: Verify the impact on Spacelift stack configurations
Since this is part of the Spacelift automation module, we should verify how this data source affects stack configurations.
✅ Verification successful
Let me check the content of these YAML files to understand if and how they use the list_root_modules data source.
Based on the comprehensive search results, I can now provide a final response about the impact of the list_root_modules data source on Spacelift stack configurations.
The list_root_modules data source is safely integrated into the stack configuration workflow
The data source is part of a well-structured system where:
- It's only executed when
enable_all_root_modulesis true - Its output is used in
main.tfto populatelocal.enabled_root_modules - The result feeds into the stack configuration process by scanning for YAML files in the discovered module directories
- Example configurations show both manual module listing and auto-discovery working as intended
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for references to list_root_modules in stack configurations
echo "Searching for references to list_root_modules in stack configurations..."
rg -l "list_root_modules" --type yaml
# Check for potential stack configuration files
echo "Checking for stack configuration files..."
fd -e yaml -e yml
Length of output: 573
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check content of stack configuration files
echo "Content of example stack configurations:"
for file in examples/complete/components/*/stacks/*.yaml; do
echo "=== $file ==="
cat "$file"
echo
done
# Search for any other references to root_modules in the codebase
echo "Searching for other references to root_modules:"
rg "root_modules" -A 3 -B 3
Length of output: 32115
examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/variables.tf (2)
8-11: LGTM! Required AWS integration ID aligns with module design.
The variable declaration is correct and properly enforces the requirement of an AWS integration ID.
13-31: LGTM! Well-structured variable declarations.
The remaining variable declarations are well-defined with appropriate types, clear descriptions, and sensible defaults where applicable. The use of the optional() function in the github_enterprise object type is a particularly good practice.
Also applies to: 38-42
variables.tf (1)
58-74: Consider security improvements for AWS integration configuration
- Having both read and write permissions enabled by default might be too permissive.
- There's no validation to prevent both read and write being false simultaneously.
Consider these improvements:
- Make the default more restrictive:
variable "aws_integration_attachment_write" {
type = bool
description = "Indicates whether this attachment is used for write operations."
- default = true
+ default = false
}- Add validation to ensure at least one permission is enabled:
variable "aws_integration_attachment_read" {
# ... existing configuration ...
validation {
condition = var.aws_integration_attachment_read || var.aws_integration_attachment_write
error_message = "At least one of read or write permissions must be enabled."
}
}main.tf (3)
30-30: Check the usage of data.external.list_root_modules
The variable enabled_root_modules depends on data.external.list_root_modules, but the data source definition is not shown. Ensure that this data source is defined and properly configured elsewhere in the module.
Confirm that data.external.list_root_modules is defined and returns the expected result. If not, add the necessary data source definition.
271-273: Avoid toggling creation of spacelift_stack_destructor resource
As noted in the comments, toggling the creation of the spacelift_stack_destructor resource can lead to unintended destruction of resources.
The implementation correctly uses the deactivated attribute to control the behavior, aligning with best practices.
1-26: Documentation is comprehensive and helpful
The comments at the beginning of the file provide a clear and detailed explanation of the module's functionality, which aids in understanding the code.
| stack_settings: | ||
| description: This Automation stack is used for Masterpoint's testing purposes | ||
| tfvars: | ||
| enabled: true |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Consider adding more configuration examples.
Since this is an example stack that others might reference when implementing their own configurations, it would be valuable to showcase more available configuration options mentioned in the README (e.g., administrative settings, worker pool configurations, integration settings).
Consider adding more configuration examples:
stack_settings:
description: This Automation stack demonstrates Spacelift configuration capabilities and is used for Masterpoint's integration testing
administrative:
autoApply: false
branch: main
worker_pool: "default"
labels:
- environment:example
- team:infrastructure
tfvars:
enabled: true
aws_integration:
space_name: "example-space"
role_arn: "arn:aws:iam::123456789012:role/example-role"| github_enterprise = var.github_enterprise | ||
| repository = var.repository | ||
| branch = var.branch | ||
|
|
||
| root_modules_path = var.root_modules_path | ||
| enable_all_root_modules = var.enable_all_root_modules | ||
|
|
||
| aws_integration_id = var.aws_integration_id |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Consider grouping related variables
The variables could be organized better by grouping related configurations together using spacing and comments. This improves readability and maintenance.
Consider this organization:
module "automation" {
source = "../../../../"
+ # GitHub Configuration
github_enterprise = var.github_enterprise
repository = var.repository
branch = var.branch
+ # Module Configuration
root_modules_path = var.root_modules_path
enable_all_root_modules = var.enable_all_root_modules
+ # Integration Configuration
aws_integration_id = var.aws_integration_id
}📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| github_enterprise = var.github_enterprise | |
| repository = var.repository | |
| branch = var.branch | |
| root_modules_path = var.root_modules_path | |
| enable_all_root_modules = var.enable_all_root_modules | |
| aws_integration_id = var.aws_integration_id | |
| # GitHub Configuration | |
| github_enterprise = var.github_enterprise | |
| repository = var.repository | |
| branch = var.branch | |
| # Module Configuration | |
| root_modules_path = var.root_modules_path | |
| enable_all_root_modules = var.enable_all_root_modules | |
| # Integration Configuration | |
| aws_integration_id = var.aws_integration_id |
|
|
||
| lifecycle { | ||
| precondition { | ||
| condition = can(regex("^([0-9,\\-\\*]+\\s+){4}[0-9,\\-\\*]+$", try(local.stack_configs[each.key].drift_detection_schedule, var.drift_detection_schedule))) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Refine cron schedule validation for drift detection
The regex pattern used in the precondition at line 309 may not cover all valid cron expressions, especially those with advanced syntax like ranges, steps, or special keywords (e.g., @hourly, */5). This could cause valid schedules to fail validation.
Consider using a more comprehensive regex or a dedicated cron validation function. I can assist in providing an improved regex pattern or alternative validation method. Would you like me to help with this?
main.tf
Outdated
| resource "spacelift_stack" "default" { | ||
| for_each = local.enabled ? local.stacks : toset([]) | ||
|
|
||
| space_id = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].space_id, null), var.space_id) | ||
| name = each.key | ||
| administrative = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].administrative, null), var.administrative) | ||
| after_apply = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_apply, []), var.after_apply)) | ||
| after_destroy = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_destroy, []), var.after_destroy)) | ||
| after_init = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_init, []), var.after_init)) | ||
| after_perform = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_perform, []), var.after_perform)) | ||
| after_plan = compact(concat(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].after_plan, []), var.after_plan)) | ||
| autodeploy = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].autodeploy, null), var.autodeploy) | ||
| autoretry = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].autoretry, var.autoretry) | ||
| before_apply = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_apply, []), var.before_apply)) | ||
| before_destroy = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_destroy, []), var.before_destroy)) | ||
| before_init = compact(coalesce(try(local.before_init[each.key], []), var.before_init)) | ||
| before_perform = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_perform, []), var.before_perform)) | ||
| before_plan = compact(coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].before_plan, []), var.before_plan)) | ||
| description = coalesce(try(local.stack_configs[each.key].description, null), var.description) | ||
| repository = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].repository, var.repository) | ||
| branch = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].branch, var.branch) | ||
| project_root = local.configs[each.key].project_root | ||
| manage_state = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].manage_state, var.manage_state) | ||
| labels = local.labels[each.key] | ||
| enable_local_preview = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].enable_local_preview, var.enable_local_preview) | ||
| terraform_smart_sanitization = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].terraform_smart_sanitization, var.terraform_smart_sanitization) | ||
| terraform_version = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].terraform_version, var.terraform_version) | ||
| terraform_workflow_tool = var.terraform_workflow_tool | ||
| terraform_workspace = local.configs[each.key].terraform_workspace | ||
|
|
||
| protect_from_deletion = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].protect_from_deletion, var.protect_from_deletion) | ||
|
|
||
| worker_pool_id = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].worker_pool_id, var.worker_pool_id) | ||
|
|
||
| dynamic "github_enterprise" { | ||
| for_each = var.github_enterprise != null ? [var.github_enterprise] : [] | ||
| content { | ||
| namespace = github_enterprise.value["namespace"] | ||
| } | ||
| } | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Review the use of coalesce and try for defaulting values
In the spacelift_stack resource, several attributes use coalesce and try to determine their values. While this works, it can be simplified for better readability by defining default values in variables or locals.
Consider setting default values in variables or using a function to streamline the defaulting logic. This makes the code cleaner and easier to maintain.
| for_each = local.enabled ? local.stacks : toset([]) | ||
|
|
||
| stack_id = spacelift_stack.default[each.key].id | ||
| deactivated = !try(local.stack_configs[each.key].destructor_enabled, var.destructor_enabled) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Clarify the logic for deactivated in spacelift_stack_destructor
The deactivated attribute is set using !try(local.stack_configs[each.key].destructor_enabled, var.destructor_enabled). The use of negation can be confusing.
For better readability, consider avoiding the negation by adjusting the logic:
resource "spacelift_stack_destructor" "default" {
for_each = local.enabled ? local.stacks : toset([])
stack_id = spacelift_stack.default[each.key].id
- deactivated = !try(local.stack_configs[each.key].destructor_enabled, var.destructor_enabled)
+ deactivated = coalesce(try(!local.stack_configs[each.key].destructor_enabled, null), !var.destructor_enabled)
depends_on = [
spacelift_drift_detection.default,
spacelift_aws_integration_attachment.default
]
}This makes the intention clearer by directly setting deactivated based on the desired state.
📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| deactivated = !try(local.stack_configs[each.key].destructor_enabled, var.destructor_enabled) | |
| deactivated = coalesce(try(!local.stack_configs[each.key].destructor_enabled, null), !var.destructor_enabled) |
main.tf
Outdated
| resource "spacelift_stack_destructor" "default" { | ||
| for_each = local.enabled ? local.stacks : toset([]) | ||
|
|
||
| stack_id = spacelift_stack.default[each.key].id | ||
| deactivated = !try(local.stack_configs[each.key].destructor_enabled, var.destructor_enabled) | ||
|
|
||
| depends_on = [ | ||
| spacelift_drift_detection.default, | ||
| spacelift_aws_integration_attachment.default | ||
| ] | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Codebase verification
Dependencies in spacelift_stack_destructor need adjustment
The verification reveals that the dependencies need to be modified as:
spacelift_drift_detection.defaultis conditionally created based ondrift_detection_enabled(defaults to false)spacelift_aws_integration_attachment.defaultis created for all stacks wherelocal.enabledis true
To avoid potential dependency errors, you should:
- Remove
spacelift_drift_detection.defaultfrom thedepends_onblock since it's optional - Keep
spacelift_aws_integration_attachment.defaultas it's created for all enabled stacks
🔗 Analysis chain
Verify the dependencies in spacelift_stack_destructor
The depends_on block in the spacelift_stack_destructor resource references spacelift_drift_detection.default and spacelift_aws_integration_attachment.default. However, these resources may not always be created, particularly if they are made optional.
Ensure that the dependencies are correctly handled to avoid reference errors when optional resources are not created. You might need to conditionally adjust the depends_on block.
Run the following script to check for stacks where these resources are not created:
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Identify stacks where optional resources are not created.
# Check if `spacelift_drift_detection` is enabled for all stacks.
ast-grep --pattern '$.resource["spacelift_drift_detection"]["default"].for_each != {}'
# Check if `spacelift_aws_integration_attachment` is enabled for all stacks.
ast-grep --pattern '$.resource["spacelift_aws_integration_attachment"]["default"].for_each != {}'
Length of output: 188
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's check the actual resource definitions and their conditions
# Check drift detection resource definition
rg "resource\s+\"spacelift_drift_detection\"\s+\"default\"" -A 10
# Check aws integration attachment resource definition
rg "resource\s+\"spacelift_aws_integration_attachment\"\s+\"default\"" -A 10
# Check if there are any conditional variables controlling these resources
rg "drift_detection_enabled|aws_integration_enabled" -A 2
Length of output: 5934
gberenice
force-pushed
the
feature/initial-version
branch
from
4302523 to
ca711fa
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 5
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (7)
variables.tf (5)
2-8: Add validation for GitHub namespace formatThe
github_enterprisevariable should validate the namespace format to ensure it follows GitHub's requirements.variable "github_enterprise" { # ... existing configuration ... validation { condition = can(regex("^[A-Za-z0-9-]+$", var.github_enterprise.namespace)) error_message = "GitHub namespace must contain only alphanumeric characters and hyphens." } }
27-41: Clarify the relationship between root module configuration variablesThe interaction between
enabled_root_modulesandenable_all_root_modulescould be clearer in the description. Consider adding an example showing their relationship.Update the description to:
variable "enabled_root_modules" { type = list(string) description = <<-EOT List of specific root modules to enable for stack config files. NOTE: This variable is only used when enable_all_root_modules = false. Example: enabled_root_modules = ["spacelift-automation", "k8s-cluster"] enable_all_root_modules = false # Only the listed modules will be enabled enabled_root_modules = [] enable_all_root_modules = true # All modules under root_modules_path will be enabled EOT default = [] }
43-56: Enhance documentation for workflow tool optionsThe description could better explain the implications of choosing each workflow tool option.
Update the description to:
variable "terraform_workflow_tool" { type = string description = <<-EOT Defines the tool that will be used to execute the workflow: - OPEN_TOFU: Uses OpenTofu as the primary workflow tool (recommended) - TERRAFORM_FOSS: Uses Terraform open-source version - CUSTOM: Allows for custom workflow tool implementation Note: Choice impacts available features and compatibility with providers. EOT default = "OPEN_TOFU" # ... existing validation ... }
58-74: Add validation for AWS integration configurationThe AWS integration configuration could benefit from:
- Validation for the integration ID format
- Clearer documentation about the implications of read/write permissions
variable "aws_integration_id" { type = string description = <<-EOT ID of the AWS integration to attach. Format: aws/xxxxxxxx-xxxx-xxxx-xxxx-xxxxxxxxxxxx EOT validation { condition = can(regex("^aws/[a-f0-9]{8}-[a-f0-9]{4}-[a-f0-9]{4}-[a-f0-9]{4}-[a-f0-9]{12}$", var.aws_integration_id)) error_message = "AWS integration ID must be in format: aws/xxxxxxxx-xxxx-xxxx-xxxx-xxxxxxxxxxxx" } } variable "aws_integration_attachment_read" { type = bool description = <<-EOT Enables read operations (e.g., terraform plan) using this AWS integration. At least one of read or write must be enabled. EOT default = true } variable "aws_integration_attachment_write" { type = bool description = <<-EOT Enables write operations (e.g., terraform apply) using this AWS integration. At least one of read or write must be enabled. EOT default = true }
89-159: Enhance documentation for lifecycle hooksThe before/after script hooks would benefit from more detailed documentation about their execution context and typical use cases.
Example for one hook (apply similar pattern to others):
variable "before_apply" { type = list(string) description = <<-EOT Scripts to run before terraform apply. Execution context: - Runs before the apply phase - Has access to plan output - Commonly used for: pre-apply validation, notifications Example: ["./scripts/validate-plan.sh", "./scripts/notify-team.sh"] EOT default = [] }README.md (2)
5-5: Enhance module description clarity.Consider rephrasing to better highlight the module's purpose:
-This Terraform child module provides infrastructure automation for projects in [Spacelift](https://docs.spacelift.io/). +This Terraform module provides automated infrastructure management and deployment for projects using [Spacelift](https://docs.spacelift.io/).
Move logo image from imgur to repository assets
The Masterpoint logo is currently hosted at
https://i.imgur.com/RDLnuQO.png. Since there are no existing image assets in the repository, I recommend:
- Create an
assetsordocs/assetsdirectory in the repository- Download and save the logo image there
- Update the README.md link to use a relative path like
./assets/masterpoint-logo.pngThis will ensure the logo remains available even if the external hosting service becomes unavailable.
🔗 Analysis chain
Line range hint
213-213: Consider hosting the logo image in a more stable location.The Masterpoint logo is currently hosted on imgur.com, which might not be suitable for long-term reliability. Consider:
- Moving the image to your organization's own CDN or image hosting service
- Including the image directly in the repository under an
assetsdirectory🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if an assets directory exists in the repository fd -t d "^assets$"Length of output: 20
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check for any image files in the repository fd -e png -e jpg -e jpeg -e gif -e svg # Also check for any references to imgur.com in the README rg -i "imgur.com" README.mdLength of output: 147
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (16)
.gitignore(1 hunks)README.md(1 hunks)data.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/random-pet/versions.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/backend.tf.json(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/main.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/common.yaml(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/example.yaml(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/tfvars/example.tfvars(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/variables.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/versions.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/main.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/versions.tf(1 hunks)main.tf(1 hunks)variables.tf(1 hunks)versions.tf(1 hunks)
✅ Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/tfvars/example.tfvars
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (12)
- .gitignore
- data.tf
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/versions.tf
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/backend.tf.json
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/main.tf
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/common.yaml
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/example.yaml
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/variables.tf
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/versions.tf
- examples/complete/main.tf
- examples/complete/versions.tf
- versions.tf
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
main.tf (1)
Learnt from: Gowiem
PR: masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation#3
File: modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf:221-227
Timestamp: 2024-10-29T00:06:05.693Z
Learning: In the Terraform module `modules/spacelift-automation/main.tf`, when `var.aws_integration_id` is a required variable, avoid suggesting to make the `spacelift_aws_integration_attachment` resource conditional based on whether `aws_integration_id` is provided.
🔇 Additional comments (4)
main.tf (3)
1-26: Well-documented module structure and functionality!
The documentation is comprehensive, well-organized, and effectively explains the module's purpose, components, and functionality.
220-226: LGTM! Good use of the deepmerge module
The implementation correctly uses CloudPosse's deepmerge module with a pinned version for stable behavior.
30-30: Add error handling for external data source
The enabled_root_modules variable relies on an external data source without proper error handling. Consider adding validation to ensure the data source returns expected results.
README.md (1)
5-5: Previous review comments are still applicable.
The following previously identified issues still need to be addressed:
- Grammar fix in the module description
- Removal of internal team note about Taskit
- Missing GitHub issue link in the Contributing section
Also applies to: 110-110, 208-208
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (10)
variables.tf (3)
27-41: Consider adding validation for root module configurationThe interaction between
enabled_root_modulesandall_root_modules_enabledcould lead to confusion. While the description mentions thatenabled_root_modulesis ignored whenall_root_modules_enabledis true, it would be helpful to add validation to ensure consistent configuration.variable "enabled_root_modules" { # ... existing configuration ... validation { condition = var.all_root_modules_enabled ? length(var.enabled_root_modules) == 0 : true error_message = "enabled_root_modules should be empty when all_root_modules_enabled is true." } }
58-81: Add validation for AWS integration configurationWhen
aws_integration_enabledis true,aws_integration_idshould be required.variable "aws_integration_id" { # ... existing configuration ... validation { condition = !var.aws_integration_enabled || var.aws_integration_id != null error_message = "aws_integration_id is required when aws_integration_enabled is true." } }
96-166: Add validation for script hooksThe before/after script hooks could benefit from validation to ensure they contain valid script paths or commands.
variable "after_apply" { # ... existing configuration ... validation { condition = alltrue([for script in var.after_apply : can(regex("^[^/].*\\.sh$", script)) || can(regex("^/", script))]) error_message = "Scripts must be either relative paths ending in .sh or absolute paths." } }Consider adding similar validation to other script hook variables.
main.tf (2)
1-26: Consider enhancing documentation with prerequisitesThe documentation is well-structured, but consider adding information about:
- Required Spacelift provider configuration
- Required permissions/roles
- Minimum Terraform version
295-304: Consider making AWS integration more flexibleThe AWS integration attachment is currently enabled for all stacks when
aws_integration_enabledis true. Consider making it more granular by:
- Allowing different read/write permissions per stack
- Supporting multiple AWS integrations per stack
README.md (5)
24-89: Add documentation for YAML configuration format.Since migrating stack configurations from tfvars to YAML files is a key change mentioned in the PR objectives, consider adding:
- Example YAML configuration file structure
- Available configuration options in YAML
- How the deepmerge module processes these configurations
116-127: Consider aligning minimum required and default versions.The module requires Terraform >= 1.6 but sets a default version of 1.7.2 in the inputs. This might cause confusion. Consider:
- Documenting why 1.7.2 is the recommended version
- Or aligning the minimum required version with the default version
128-142: Document version constraint strategy for external modules.For the cloudposse modules:
- Document the version constraint strategy (why these specific versions?)
- Consider adding a note about version compatibility testing
146-203: Enhance documentation for security-related inputs.Consider adding security best practices and recommendations for:
protect_from_deletion- When should this be enabled?terraform_smart_sanitization- Security implications of this settingaws_integration_attachment_read/write- Least privilege recommendations
207-207: Document why there are no outputs.Since the module creates Spacelift resources, consider:
- Adding outputs for created resource IDs
- Or documenting why outputs are intentionally omitted
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (8)
README.md(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/main.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/common.yaml(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/tfvars/example.tfvars(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/variables.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/main.tf(1 hunks)main.tf(1 hunks)variables.tf(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (5)
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/main.tf
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/common.yaml
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/tfvars/example.tfvars
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/variables.tf
- examples/complete/main.tf
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (2)
main.tf (2)
Learnt from: Gowiem
PR: masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation#3
File: main.tf:56-59
Timestamp: 2024-10-30T17:04:09.798Z
Learning: In this module, `path.root` is intentionally used instead of `path.module` when constructing file paths, as it refers to the root path of the calling module, which is necessary for correctly locating the stack YAML files.
Learnt from: Gowiem
PR: masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation#3
File: main.tf:231-257
Timestamp: 2024-10-30T17:01:23.897Z
Learning: In `main.tf`, grouping related attributes in the `spacelift_stack` resource using locals may overcomplicate things and remove important logic elsewhere; prefer to keep attributes as is.
variables.tf (1)
Learnt from: Gowiem
PR: masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation#3
File: variables.tf:245-251
Timestamp: 2024-10-30T17:05:18.442Z
Learning: When users are expected to know certain requirements, such as `worker_pool_id` being required for self-hosted Spacelift instances, avoid adding additional variables solely for validation purposes.
🔇 Additional comments (5)
variables.tf (1)
43-56: LGTM! Well-structured workflow tool configuration
The variable has clear documentation, appropriate validation for allowed values, and a sensible default.
main.tf (3)
224-231: LGTM!
The deep merge implementation correctly handles the precedence of stack-specific configurations over common configurations.
318-323:
Enhance cron schedule validation
The current regex pattern for cron schedule validation might not catch all edge cases. Consider using a more comprehensive pattern that validates ranges and steps.
Apply this diff to improve validation:
precondition {
- condition = can(regex("^([0-9,\\-\\*]+\\s+){4}[0-9,\\-\\*]+$", try(local.stack_configs[each.key].drift_detection_schedule, var.drift_detection_schedule)))
+ condition = can(regex("^(((\\d+,)+\\d+|\\d+(\\/|-)\\d+|\\d+|\\*)(\\s+((\\d+,)+\\d+|\\d+(\\/|-)\\d+|\\d+|\\*)){4})$", try(local.stack_configs[each.key].drift_detection_schedule, var.drift_detection_schedule)))
error_message = "Invalid cron schedule format for drift detection"
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
27-33: Add validation for enabled_root_modules
Consider adding validation to ensure that all modules in var.enabled_root_modules actually exist in the repository.
README.md (1)
1-20: LGTM! Clear and well-structured introduction.
The introduction and overview sections effectively communicate the module's purpose and core functionality.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@gberenice okay, last round of comments. I can't review this because it's so big, so my thought is that we do the last round of changes, we get it merged and released as v0.1, and then we circle back with additional updates + tests from @oycyc. This one has grown too big... We gotta get it merged because it is too daunting to review.
| module "automation" { | ||
| source = "../../../../" |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I'm confused about why we need the root module at examples/complete and this root module. Are they not the same? Do we need the one at the root of complete/ or is it a one or the other thing? Mind sharing your thoughts here?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
At first, I had the root module at examples/complete. It was used to create a simple example to spin up random-pet stack. Then we discussed that it would be useful to show that spacelift-automation can manage itself, so I added its configuration to the expected path - ./examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/. That's why we have them both 😕
I agree that it's excessive, but we need to cut the examples/complete root module in this case. Does it make sense?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@gberenice I think it makes sense if we put a README in examples/complete that provides info on "Go to examples/complete/spacelift-automation to run that root module, it will manage itself like so...". We can do that correct?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@Gowiem removed the root module and added the README.md 👍
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
README.md (2)
162-162: Enhance aws_integration_id documentation.Consider adding an example value and instructions on how to obtain the AWS integration ID to make it easier for users to configure this required parameter.
-| <a name="input_aws_integration_id"></a> [aws_integration_id](#input_aws_integration_id) | ID of the AWS integration to attach. | `string` | n/a | yes | +| <a name="input_aws_integration_id"></a> [aws_integration_id](#input_aws_integration_id) | ID of the AWS integration to attach. Can be found in the Spacelift console under Integrations > AWS > Integration ID. Example: "01234567890ABC" | `string` | n/a | yes |
217-217: Enhance contributing guidelines.Consider adding more detailed information about:
- Development setup instructions
- Testing requirements
- Code style guidelines
- PR review process
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (1)
README.md(1 hunks)
🔇 Additional comments (2)
README.md (2)
1-20: LGTM! Clear and comprehensive introduction.
The introduction and overview sections effectively communicate the module's purpose and capabilities.
88-88: Enhance documentation about tfvars functionality.
The explanation about tfvars file usage has been improved with the addition of disabling functionality. This change provides better clarity for users who might want to opt out of this feature.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (5)
main.tf (3)
1-26: Consider enhancing documentation with troubleshooting guideThe documentation is comprehensive but could benefit from a section on error handling and troubleshooting common issues that users might encounter when using this module.
27-61: Add error handling for file operationsThe YAML file reading operations could fail if files are malformed or missing. Consider adding validation or error handling for these scenarios.
locals { _root_module_yaml_decoded = { for module in local.enabled_root_modules : module => { for yaml_file in fileset("${path.root}/${var.root_modules_path}/${module}/stacks", "*.yaml") : - yaml_file => yamldecode(file("${path.root}/${var.root_modules_path}/${module}/stacks/${yaml_file}")) + yaml_file => try( + yamldecode(file("${path.root}/${var.root_modules_path}/${module}/stacks/${yaml_file}")), + error("Failed to parse YAML file: ${yaml_file}") + ) } } }
293-302: Consider adding validation for AWS integration IDWhile the AWS integration attachment is conditionally created based on
aws_integration_enabled, there's no validation to ensureaws_integration_idis provided when enabled.resource "spacelift_aws_integration_attachment" "default" { for_each = { for stack, configs in local.stack_configs : stack => configs if try(configs.aws_integration_enabled, var.aws_integration_enabled) } + + lifecycle { + precondition { + condition = var.aws_integration_id != null || try(local.stack_configs[each.key].aws_integration_id, null) != null + error_message = "aws_integration_id must be provided when AWS integration is enabled" + } + } + integration_id = try(local.stack_configs[each.key].aws_integration_id, var.aws_integration_id) stack_id = spacelift_stack.default[each.key].id read = var.aws_integration_attachment_read write = var.aws_integration_attachment_write }README.md (2)
11-11: Add missing comma for better readabilityAdd a comma before "it creates" to improve sentence structure.
-It automates the creation of "child" stacks and all the required accompanying Spacelift resources. For each enabled root module it creates: +It automates the creation of "child" stacks and all the required accompanying Spacelift resources. For each enabled root module, it creates:🧰 Tools
🪛 LanguageTool
[uncategorized] ~11-~11: Possible missing comma found.
Context: ...celift resources. For each enabled root module it creates: 1. [Spacelift Stack](https...(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_COMMA)
7-7: Consider adding a table of contentsThe documentation is comprehensive but could benefit from a table of contents before the Overview section. This would help users navigate the different sections more easily, especially given the length and depth of the documentation.
## Overview +## Table of Contents + +- [Overview](#overview) +- [Usage](#usage) +- [FAQs](#faqs) +- [Requirements](#requirements) +- [Providers](#providers) +- [Modules](#modules) +- [Resources](#resources) +- [Inputs](#inputs) +- [Outputs](#outputs) +- [Contributing](#contributing) + The `spacelift-automation` root module is designed to streamline the deployment...
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (9)
README.md(1 hunks)context.tf(0 hunks)examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/common.yaml(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yaml(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/example.yaml(1 hunks)examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/versions.tf(1 hunks)examples/complete/versions.tf(1 hunks)main.tf(1 hunks)versions.tf(1 hunks)
💤 Files with no reviewable changes (1)
- context.tf
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (6)
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/common.yaml
- examples/complete/components/random-pet/stacks/example.yaml
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/stacks/example.yaml
- examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/versions.tf
- examples/complete/versions.tf
- versions.tf
🧰 Additional context used
📓 Learnings (1)
main.tf (2)
Learnt from: Gowiem
PR: masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation#3
File: main.tf:56-59
Timestamp: 2024-10-30T17:04:09.798Z
Learning: In this module, `path.root` is intentionally used instead of `path.module` when constructing file paths, as it refers to the root path of the calling module, which is necessary for correctly locating the stack YAML files.
Learnt from: Gowiem
PR: masterpointio/terraform-spacelift-automation#3
File: main.tf:231-257
Timestamp: 2024-10-30T17:01:23.897Z
Learning: In `main.tf`, grouping related attributes in the `spacelift_stack` resource using locals may overcomplicate things and remove important logic elsewhere; prefer to keep attributes as is.
🪛 LanguageTool
README.md
[uncategorized] ~11-~11: Possible missing comma found.
Context: ...celift resources. For each enabled root module it creates: 1. [Spacelift Stack](https...
(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_COMMA)
[uncategorized] ~88-~88: Possible missing article found.
Context: ...le/tfvars/dev.tfvarswill be copied to working directory of the Stackspacelift-aws-r...
(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_THE)
🔇 Additional comments (2)
main.tf (1)
222-229: LGTM! Deep merge implementation is well structured
The use of cloudposse's deepmerge module with a pinned version is appropriate for handling complex configuration merging.
README.md (1)
185-185: Consider using a more stable OpenTofu version
The default OpenTofu version is set to 1.7.2, which is very recent. Consider using a more stable version (e.g., 1.6.x) as the default to ensure broader compatibility and stability. Users can always override this with a newer version if needed.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (1)
examples/complete/README.md (1)
1-8: Enhance the introduction with additional clarity.The introduction effectively explains the purpose, but could be improved with:
- A note about implications of self-management (e.g., initial bootstrap process, handling failures)
- Code-formatted paths for better readability
Consider this enhancement:
# Complete Example This example demonstrates how to use the spacelift-automation component to manage Spacelift stacks, including the ability for Spacelift to manage its own configuration. -Normally, this directory would contain a simple root module to spin up a basic example. To showcase a more practical use case where Spacelift manages its own infrastructure, we've moved the configuration to the expected path: [examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/](./components/spacelift-automation/). +Normally, this directory would contain a simple root module to spin up a basic example. To showcase a more practical use case where Spacelift manages its own infrastructure, we've moved the configuration to the expected path: `examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/`. + +> **Note:** Self-management means Spacelift will be responsible for updating its own configuration. While powerful, this requires careful consideration during initial setup and when making changes that could affect Spacelift's ability to manage itself.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (2)
examples/complete/README.md(1 hunks)examples/complete/main.tf(0 hunks)
💤 Files with no reviewable changes (1)
- examples/complete/main.tf
🔇 Additional comments (1)
examples/complete/README.md (1)
17-19: Clarify the use of tofu command.
The instructions use tofu instead of the more common terraform command without explanation.
Add a note explaining the command choice:
1. Initialize Terraform:
+ > Note: This example uses `tofu` (OpenTofu) commands, but you can replace them with `terraform` if you're using Hashicorp Terraform.
```sh
tofu init
```
Co-authored-by: coderabbitai[bot] <136622811+coderabbitai[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
!
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
examples/complete/README.md (2)
5-5: Consider improving the path reference and documentation.
- Replace the relative markdown link with an absolute path to prevent broken links if the file structure changes.
- Consider adding a visual diagram or more detailed explanation of how Spacelift manages its own infrastructure.
-Normally, this directory would contain a simple root module to spin up a basic example. To showcase a more practical use case where Spacelift manages its own infrastructure, we've moved the configuration to the expected path: [examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/](./components/spacelift-automation/). +Normally, this directory would contain a simple root module to spin up a basic example. To showcase a more practical use case where Spacelift manages its own infrastructure, we've moved the configuration to the expected path: `/examples/complete/components/spacelift-automation/`. + +### Self-Management Architecture + +```mermaid +graph TD + A[Spacelift Stack] -->|Manages| B[Infrastructure] + A -->|Manages| A +```
1-37: Fix markdown formatting issues.The static analysis tool indicates formatting issues. Consider running
trunk fmtto automatically fix the formatting.🧰 Tools
🪛 GitHub Check: Trunk Check
[failure] 1-1: prettier
Incorrect formatting, autoformat by running 'trunk fmt'
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (1)
examples/complete/README.md(1 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🪛 GitHub Check: Trunk Check
examples/complete/README.md
[failure] 1-1: prettier
Incorrect formatting, autoformat by running 'trunk fmt'
🔇 Additional comments (2)
examples/complete/README.md (2)
37-37: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add expected outcomes after setup.
The instructions end without explaining what users should expect after running the commands. Consider adding:
- Expected output or success indicators
- How to verify the stack was created correctly
- Common issues and troubleshooting steps
This will set up the Spacelift stack that manages itself.
+
+### Expected Outcomes
+
+After running these commands successfully:
+1. A new Spacelift stack will be created in your organization
+2. The stack will be configured to manage its own infrastructure
+3. You should see a successful initial plan in the Spacelift UI
+
+### Troubleshooting
+
+If you encounter issues:
+1. Verify your AWS credentials and permissions
+2. Check the Spacelift UI for detailed error messages
+3. Ensure all prerequisite values were properly replacedLikely invalid or redundant comment.
26-26: Verify the use of tofu commands.
The instructions use tofu instead of terraform. While OpenTofu is a valid alternative to Terraform, we should verify if this is intentional and add a note explaining the choice.
Also applies to: 30-30, 34-34
✅ Verification successful
Let me gather more context about the OpenTofu usage in the repository.
The use of tofu commands is intentional and correct
The repository explicitly uses OpenTofu as the default workflow tool, as evidenced by:
- The default
terraform_workflow_toolvariable is set to"OPEN_TOFU"in the module configuration - The documentation consistently refers to "OpenTofu/Terraform" throughout, indicating both tools are supported
- The repository includes proper OpenTofu documentation links (e.g., opentofu.org)
No issues found with the usage of tofu commands in the examples.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check if there are any references to terraform commands in the codebase
rg -i "terraform\s+(init|plan|apply|workspace)" --type md
Length of output: 357
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check for OpenTofu/tofu related content
rg -i "opentofu|tofu\s+(init|plan|apply|workspace)" --type md
# Check the main README for any migration or tool choice explanations
cat README.md
Length of output: 30263
Info
This is an initial open-sourced version of
spacelift-automationmodule.examples/completedcan be found here: https://masterpointio.app.spacelift.io/stack/random-pet-example.Questions
Summary by CodeRabbit
Release Notes
New Features
terraform-module-templatetospacelift-automation.Bug Fixes
Documentation
Chores