-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 780
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Details of QUnit.begin error are lost #1446
Comments
Definitely sounds like a bug. Based on the report, my guess is it has something to do with the handlers in this code: Lines 70 to 91 in 474a708
|
#1595 has given me some better insight into this kind of exception management. Building on that PR makes this look very solvable - I'll wait for that to land and then iterate on this, given that there's a little overlap with how |
I'm able to reproduce this still, and it seems like this is quite similar to #1377 indeed. And the same applies to Pen repro: https://codepen.io/Krinkle/pen/PomYvwN |
== Background == Previously, QUnit.onError and QUnit.onUnhandledRejection could report global errors by synthesizing a new test, even after a run has ended. This is problematic when an errors ocurrs after all modules (and their hooks) have finished, and the overall test run has ended. The most immediate problem is that hooks having finished already, means it is illegal for a new test to start since "after" has already run. To protect against such illegal calls, the hooks object is emptied internally, and this new test causes an internal error: ``` TypeError: Cannot read property 'length' of undefined ``` This is not underlying problem though, but rather our internal safeguard working as intended. The higher-level problem is that there is no appropiate way to report a late error as a test since the run has already ended. The `QUnit.done()` callbacks have run, and the `runEnd` event has been emitted. == Approach == Instead of trying to report (late) errors as a test, only print them to `console.warn()`, which goes to stderr in Node.js. For the CLI, also remember that uncaught errors were found and use that to make sure we don't change exitCode back to zero (e.g. in case we have an uncaught error after the last test but before our `runEnd` callback is called). == Changes == * Generalise `QUnit.onUnhandledRejection` and re-use it for `window.onerror` (browser), and uncaught exceptions (CLI). * Fix broken use of `QUnit.onError` in `process.on( "uncaughtException" )`. This was passing the wrong parameters. Use the new onUncaughtException method instead. * Clarify that `QUnit.onError` is only for `window.onerror`. For now, keep its strange non-standard signature as-is (with the custom object parameter), but document this and its return value. * Remove the unused "..args" from `QUnit.onError`. This was only ever passed from one of our unit tests to give one extra argument (a string of "actual"), which then ended up passed as "actual" parameter to `pushFailure()`. We never used this in the actual onError binding, so remove this odd variadic construct for now. * Change `ProcessingQueue#done`, which is in charge of reporting the "No tests were run" error, to no longer rely on the way that `QUnit.onError` previously queued a late test. The first part of this function may run twice (same as before, once after an empty test run, and one more time after the synthetic test has finished and the queue is empty again). Change this so that we no longer assign `finished = true` in that first part. This means we will still support queueing of this one late test. But, since the quueue is empty, we do need to call `advance()` manually as otherwise it'd never get processed. Previously, `finished = true` was assigned first, which meant that `QUnit.onError` was adding a test under that condition. But this worked anyway because `Test#queue` internally had manual advancing exactly for this use case, which is also where we now emit a deprecation warning (to become an error in QUnit 3). Note that using this for anything other than the "No tests run" error was already unreliable since generally runEnd would have been emitted already. The "No tests run" test was exactly done from the one sweet spot where it was (and remains) safe because that threw an error and thus prevented runEnd from being emitted. Fixes qunitjs#1377. Ref qunitjs#1322. Ref qunitjs#1446.
== Background == Previously, QUnit.onError and QUnit.onUnhandledRejection could report global errors by synthesizing a new test, even after a run has ended. This is problematic when an errors ocurrs after all modules (and their hooks) have finished, and the overall test run has ended. The most immediate problem is that hooks having finished already, means it is illegal for a new test to start since "after" has already run. To protect against such illegal calls, the hooks object is emptied internally, and this new test causes an internal error: ``` TypeError: Cannot read property 'length' of undefined ``` This is not underlying problem though, but rather our internal safeguard working as intended. The higher-level problem is that there is no appropiate way to report a late error as a test since the run has already ended. The `QUnit.done()` callbacks have run, and the `runEnd` event has been emitted. == Approach == Instead of trying to report (late) errors as a test, only print them to `console.warn()`, which goes to stderr in Node.js. For the CLI, also remember that uncaught errors were found and use that to make sure we don't change exitCode back to zero (e.g. in case we have an uncaught error after the last test but before our `runEnd` callback is called). == Changes == * Generalise `QUnit.onUnhandledRejection` and re-use it for `window.onerror` (browser), and uncaught exceptions (CLI). * Fix broken use of `QUnit.onError` in `process.on( "uncaughtException" )`. This was passing the wrong parameters. Use the new onUncaughtException method instead. * Clarify that `QUnit.onError` is only for `window.onerror`. For now, keep its strange non-standard signature as-is (with the custom object parameter), but document this and its return value. * Remove the unused "..args" from `QUnit.onError`. This was only ever passed from one of our unit tests to give one extra argument (a string of "actual"), which then ended up passed as "actual" parameter to `pushFailure()`. We never used this in the actual onError binding, so remove this odd variadic construct for now. * Change `ProcessingQueue#done`, which is in charge of reporting the "No tests were run" error, to no longer rely on the way that `QUnit.onError` previously queued a late test. The first part of this function may run twice (same as before, once after an empty test run, and one more time after the synthetic test has finished and the queue is empty again). Change this so that we no longer assign `finished = true` in that first part. This means we will still support queueing of this one late test. But, since the quueue is empty, we do need to call `advance()` manually as otherwise it'd never get processed. Previously, `finished = true` was assigned first, which meant that `QUnit.onError` was adding a test under that condition. But this worked anyway because `Test#queue` internally had manual advancing exactly for this use case, which is also where we now emit a deprecation warning (to become an error in QUnit 3). Note that using this for anything other than the "No tests run" error was already unreliable since generally runEnd would have been emitted already. The "No tests run" test was exactly done from the one sweet spot where it was (and remains) safe because that threw an error and thus prevented runEnd from being emitted. Fixes qunitjs#1377. Ref qunitjs#1322. Ref qunitjs#1446.
== Background == Previously, QUnit.onError and QUnit.onUnhandledRejection could report global errors by synthesizing a new test, even after a run has ended. This is problematic when an errors ocurrs after all modules (and their hooks) have finished, and the overall test run has ended. The most immediate problem is that hooks having finished already, means it is illegal for a new test to start since "after" has already run. To protect against such illegal calls, the hooks object is emptied internally, and this new test causes an internal error: ``` TypeError: Cannot read property 'length' of undefined ``` This is not underlying problem though, but rather our internal safeguard working as intended. The higher-level problem is that there is no appropiate way to report a late error as a test since the run has already ended. The `QUnit.done()` callbacks have run, and the `runEnd` event has been emitted. == Approach == Instead of trying to report (late) errors as a test, only print them to `console.warn()`, which goes to stderr in Node.js. For the CLI, also remember that uncaught errors were found and use that to make sure we don't change exitCode back to zero (e.g. in case we have an uncaught error after the last test but before our `runEnd` callback is called). == Changes == * Generalise `QUnit.onUnhandledRejection` and re-use it for `window.onerror` (browser), and uncaught exceptions (CLI). * Fix broken use of `QUnit.onError` in `process.on( "uncaughtException" )`. This was passing the wrong parameters. Use the new onUncaughtException method instead. * Clarify that `QUnit.onError` is only for `window.onerror`. For now, keep its strange non-standard signature as-is (with the custom object parameter), but document this and its return value. * Remove the unused "..args" from `QUnit.onError`. This was only ever passed from one of our unit tests to give one extra argument (a string of "actual"), which then ended up passed as "actual" parameter to `pushFailure()`. We never used this in the actual onError binding, so remove this odd variadic construct for now. * Change `ProcessingQueue#done`, which is in charge of reporting the "No tests were run" error, to no longer rely on the way that `QUnit.onError` previously queued a late test. The first part of this function may run twice (same as before, once after an empty test run, and one more time after the synthetic test has finished and the queue is empty again). Change this so that we no longer assign `finished = true` in that first part. This means we will still support queueing of this one late test. But, since the quueue is empty, we do need to call `advance()` manually as otherwise it'd never get processed. Previously, `finished = true` was assigned first, which meant that `QUnit.onError` was adding a test under that condition. But this worked anyway because `Test#queue` internally had manual advancing exactly for this use case, which is also where we now emit a deprecation warning (to become an error in QUnit 3). Note that using this for anything other than the "No tests run" error was already unreliable since generally runEnd would have been emitted already. The "No tests run" test was exactly done from the one sweet spot where it was (and remains) safe because that threw an error and thus prevented runEnd from being emitted. Fixes #1377. Ref #1322. Ref #1446.
Circling back to this after the refactoring in #1629. I could still reproduce the issue of swalled stacktraces for uncaught errors and rejections from ... and, that's exactly what @step2yeung already proposed with #1391. |
Capture the status quo before changing it. Minor changes: * Switch remaining notEquals/indexOf uses to the preferred `assert.true( str.includes() )` idiom. * Fix duplicate printing of error message due to V8's `Error#stack`, as used by onUncaughtException. Ref #1629. * Start normalizing stderror in tests like we do with stdout. * Account for qunit.js stack frames from native Promise in V8, which doesn't include a function name or paranthesis. Ref #1446. Ref #1633.
Capture the status quo before changing it. Minor changes: * Switch remaining notEquals/indexOf uses to the preferred `assert.true( str.includes() )` idiom. * Fix duplicate printing of error message due to V8's `Error#stack`, as used by onUncaughtException. Ref #1629. * Start normalizing stderror in tests like we do with stdout. * Account for qunit.js stack frames from native Promise in V8, which doesn't include a function name or paranthesis. Ref #1446. Ref #1633.
Capture the status quo before changing it. Minor changes: * Switch remaining notEquals/indexOf uses to the preferred `assert.true( str.includes() )` idiom. * Fix duplicate printing of error message due to V8's `Error#stack`, as used by onUncaughtException. Ref #1629. * Start normalizing stderror in tests like we do with stdout. * Account for qunit.js stack frames from native Promise in V8, which doesn't include a function name or paranthesis. Ref #1446. Ref #1633.
If
QUnit.begin
returns a rejected promise, I would expect the rejection error to be shown to the user, but it is not. You get aError: Process exited before tests finished running
error with no error info.Reproduction repo: https://github.com/asakusuma/qunit-begin-issue
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: